*POLL FOR NEXT SHOW!!*

season 1 is great but season 2 is pretty terrible. rather they watch a nice show like made in abyss ;)

Daniel Borrego

Nahh that's bait, spouting nonsense, acting goofy.

Himiyo

Vinland Saga is better than Code Geass (2nd season was terrible) and FMAB (most overrated show ever made) combined

SWAGxMAGICIAN

Mushoku Tensei is a wannabe and worse version of Re:zero and half the episodes feel like filler. It's fucking terrible.

SWAGxMAGICIAN

seconded

KenthalasAT

Crazy how you wouldn't know how to if it's "just fucking bizarre" without context from watching it, how would you know the barn scene or the scene in turning point 1 are anything but "just fucking bizarre" just from a clip of them? You couldn't. Also MIA is also a fantasy story with realistic/complex characters.

Himiyo

vinland saga won and its a fucking good show i just cant to watch their reaction

Alex

I am making my own opinions lol, watching Loli's get tortured and piss on the ground is very different from the controversial stuff in mushoku tensei, its not even comparable. One is a realistic fantasy story and the other is just fucking bizarre.

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

Code Geass is a master class on character development with amazing story telling, plot direction, soundtrack, and a wild thriller ride with tons of discussion and theory crafting to be had. It's also complete. Vinland Saga is not finished and probably won't be considering the reception of S2(which is slow imo as a manga reader)...though maybe.

BleachBoy18

Rising of the Shield Hero. Iwatani Naofumi is summoned as one of the four Cardinal Heroes, the Shield Hero, with a shield he cannot remove, nor can he use any other weapons. Forced to rely on others to fight for him, he is deceived and cast down as a fallen hero, condemned and shunned. Rising of the Shield Hero is just that - the story of Naofumi's struggle to climb back up from rock bottom. Trailer, from Crunchyroll: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rKnyi3TRznA

Josie Finch

100% agree madoka magica is one of the best anime of all time. Coming from someone whos watched 1000+ anime.

MASTER VOS

Why do you have to put three top 20 anime of all time in the same list? Haha :D

Troco72

Oh okay so I was right, all you do is shit on peoples opinions on shows you havent watched based on random clips and other peoples opinions. You do realise that you're a Mushoku Tensei fan right? Lots of people say the same about MT and you've been in the comments of other reactions defending MT from people who say the same shit you're saying about MIA, how is that anything but hypocritical and cringe as fuck? Just make your own opinions instead of going off what other people say and dickriding the anime you have actually watched.

Himiyo

I've seen scenes from Made in Abyss and anyone who enjoys watching that shit actually needs to go take a walk

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

I had not heard of Chihayafuru. This gives me another anime to check out. Thanks! :)

John Titor (name subject to change)

Since you already watching re zero and steins gate why not add summertime rendering, it's amazing mystery thriller, already finished and very underestimated due to Disney prison, but so so good

Verols

I ain't disputing that, but to relegate it to being a "hype shounen show" is nonsensical

Styx TV

I was waiting to vote for made in abyss (´･ω･｀) Hopefully it will be in the next one ! btw I like the Land of the Lustrous suggestion mentioned above. It's not perfect but it has a really unique way of combining religious elements with fantasy. It's quite popular in Japan so I'm surprised it's not that well-known in the west.

パライ

nice anime there!

Eduardo Alvarado

Sorry if my earlier comment upset you considering you won't respond to it, but like I said before, there's no reason to comment on things you're clueless about.

Himiyo

It probably is philosophical, but so is FMAB. Not even a debatable point.

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

Bro sayin this like Vinland Saga isn’t deeply philosophical

Styx TV

I think you would really enjoy Ranking of Kings- the art style is different but the story is phenomenal. It's an anime that really surprised me in terms of depth and worldbuilding.

Hannah

I think you need to take a walk

Edgar

More reasons not to: -the show's fanbase is mostly consisted of pedophiles who like to watch Loli's pee and get tortured

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

Also if you're going to pick something to watch at somepoint regardless of polls I still recommend Made in Abyss due to: -It's 21 episodes shorter than the next shortest anime on the list -It's an amazing discussion show, with one of the best soundtracks and art direction in anime (imo). -It's a very immersive show similar to how I feel about MT -From what I see from your past reactions it's different to anything you've reacted to -I think it's clear from comments on patreon on this and previous posts that a fairly large amount of your dedicated community would like to see it, even if it doesn't perform well on youtube polls -It's one of my favourite anime and you two are my favourite reactors, so I would personally be very happy Reasons not to: -I've heard it's fairly copyright heavy, though there is reactions on youtube. (good excuse for a patreon only if you wanted that) -It performs poorly on youtube polls

Himiyo

from this list FMAB is the one you will enjoy the most i am sure so i voted FMAB

Bourbon

After years of feeling alone this is the second time in 24 hours I've heard someone mention Chihayafuru. My people. (ಥ◡ಥ)

Hollow

How triggered some of you are lol. I think it's underrated in a sense that because it's older it's been not voted for compared to other (awesome) new animes

Thomas Reinhardt

Code Geass is amazing, one of the first anime I've watched that made me have post-show depression cuz it was over, just don't watch the movie:D but it can't stand a chance against more popular and recent anime, FMA is a great show, despite more vocal fans giving a bad name:d sadly the thing that they good at won't work here since it looked behind paywall, so Vinland being more recent will win, despite s2 being so boring atleast for me

Verols

I would recommend Puella Magi Madoka Magica as a future option if not already seen. Plenty to discuss there and it's not a long show. I'm honestly surprised I haven't seen it mentioned yet. I like some longer shows like Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood and Code Geass, but long shows on a reaction channel can be rough for those not interested.

Claudius White

Lol just joined to vote for vinland

Vivasvan Gautam

Bruh, like. Bruh

Edgar

Right so you didn't even watch the series and you're still on here replying to everyones comments about Vinland, makes sense. You clearly don't understand how dumb saying action is the "main focus and pull of the series" makes you look. Also yeah, it's a historical fantasy and an anime, not a documentary, no shit the action is unrealistic. Also Vinland has been releasing for years before the FMA manga ended and isn't a shounen. Looking back at your other comments it's clear you probably haven't seen MIA either and are just parroting what you've heard from other people, I'm guessing FMAB is the only one on the original list you've actually watched. Almost every comment you've made on here in the past couple weeks has just been cringe and antagonising for no reason, just let people have their opinions without picking fights on things you're clueless about, please. Also the first 6 or 7 episodes of FMAB suck complete dick and I'm someone who voted for FMAB.

Himiyo

Vinland Saga!!! Let’s goooooo!

DJ Hunter

I mean I watched 6 or 7 episodes and the action was absolutely meant to be the main focus and pull of the series, at least in the first season (I’ve heard season 2 is just a farming simulator) and yeah the action fucking sucked and was hilariously unrealistic for Viking times.

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

Dude Vinland saga isn’t even a battle Shonen. You completely missed the point of the series my guy

Rice

Lol if you think FMAB is hallow and generic you must’ve had your brain turned off while watching it. FMAB is not only one of the most nuanced and philosophical stories ever told in anime, but in all of human fiction.

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

FMAB is a hollow and generic shounen, its good but doesn't stand out in any category. Code Geass and Vinland are leagues better, more serious, and more entertaining as well

Albertan Motorcyclist

Code Geass is one of the most overrated shows of all time, looks awful, cringe edgelord characters, it's a show for people who watch Death Note and think Kira is the good guy

Jay Craig

I second Chihayafuru.

Lamont Cranston

It didn’t go over my head, the show is supposed to take place in a real historical setting and than all the fighters have ridiculous unexplained superpowers and can jump 100 feet in the air. its just dumb.

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

if you want to add some show later, i think Classroom of the Elite will be perfect for you guys since it's a mystery,& psychological thriller. it will be fun discussing it

patchwork_chimera

Vinland is seinen though, probably why it went over your head.

Weey

Tell me you haven't seen Vinland Saga without telling me you haven't seen Vinland Saga.

Oak

Did this person just call Vinlandsaga a "hype new shounen"... jfc

Drake

Totally absurd for them to watch some new hype Shounen show over one of the most iconic and influential anime ever made... FMAB

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

Lmfao people calling one of the most popular and critically acclaimed Sci-Fi/Mecha anime of all time "under rated" because some hype new shounen is a winning a reaction channel poll...

Jasmine Tea Enjoyer

I feel for the people who wanted Made in Abyss it should've gotten to the patreon poll, that being said - Vinland free. Also once again, a show that will never ever win a poll but one that might end up being Anna's favourite show ever - Chihayafuru - basically Haikyuu if it was also a shoujo romance manga

Jay Craig

How is it underrated? It was top2 on MAL for years.

Shulman

Awesome comment number 3 Please Watch Hells Paradise it is a Show by Mappa and Part of what fans dubbed the Dark Trio the other two are Jujutsu kaisen and Chainsaw man. Have a great day :)

Isac christensen

I love both these but Vinland has been too good recently.

I love Code Geass so much. But this Vinland Saga, especially this second season, has been a masterpiece

Mobin Shah

Joined the patreon to vote for made in abyss. The first season is magic.

MASTER VOS

i feel with you. One of the best Anime of the recent years

atlantiker2

Damn didn't expect this here, that show it truly a gem (hehe).

DemoniCross

Thats interesting , I would say FMA B is a well made shounen but it doesnt have anything exceptional. I would probably pick another 10 shounens before FMA B. Dropped Code Geass after first couple eps , could not stand character writing , pacing and character designs . Vinland Saga tho. I think its one of the best written anime in last 5 + years . And manga is on par with Vagabond and Berserk .

Edgar

People calling code geass underrate. Now this is underrated. To your Eternity is so good!

Joshua

Vinland Saga winning is a true shame. I really hope more people vote for Code Geass because first of all, it's complete. Second of all, it's an all time Classic Thriller with top notch characterization, crazy plot, and tons of theory crafting. Vinland Saga's first season is good but as a manga reader I feel like (no spoilers here) it kind of gets slow. Don't get me wrong, it's not awful, but nowhere near the other two outside of the first season. FMA has a ton of character building, doesn't cheap on stuff either, has a crazy plot, and also has amazing theory crafting. Code Geass is a master class on character development. FMA is pretty damn good too. Neither cheap out. Vinland Saga...I can't spoil and it hurts. Just my opinion. Edit: Whatever you guys choose tho I'm sure your discussions will be good :)

BleachBoy18

Vinland has some of the best characters in any media, let alone anime.

ThaDoubleB

FMAB is perfect for them

Slykou

I love em all, but Vinland is my favorite

Omikron

It’s really not, it’s pretty overrated because of how well the ending was done while most of season 2 was pretty meh

SWAGxMAGICIAN

Made in Abyss got robbed by Mid Geass 😿

SWAGxMAGICIAN

Both Vinland & Fullmetal are absolutely masterpieces imho. On par with AoT, even. Hope you can get to both of them!

CastSenpai

Gotta be peakland saga. Their discussions for this show will 2hrs minimum 😂

Raden

I love vinland so much :)

Martin Budjac

A bit more of a niche show to react to, but I would recommend watching Land of the Lustrous. I know these polls usually get the most well-known series, which is fine, but sometimes it would be nice to see something a bit different. Land of the Lustrous would fit your style of reaction videos perfectly, since it has lots of mystery elements, philosophical contemplation, unique worldbuilding, a diverse cast of interesting characters and genuinely touching emotional moments. It's just a very different show from most of the other anime that I've seen. I feel like all of these elements could lead to great discussions and reactions. It's also just 12 episodes, so it wouldn't be overly long.

WipWu

I feel kind of strange recommending another mecha in the post where Code Geass is an option, but you guys should watch 86 at some point! It’s very well written and masterfully directed. As a result, the show is chock full of symbolism, little details, great worldbuilding, and interesting characters/themes. I feel like it'd be very ripe for your discussions.

RetroNitez

Code Geass always there with those ~20-30%, sadly it will probably take a lot of time for them to give it a chance.

Forrial

Vinland Saga is on another level, voted that

JessesMask

I hope you're gonna watch Cowboy Bebop at some point (in English Dub).

GhostPhil

I don't think so, just a lot of great shows that are newer, so it gets overshadowed a lot. But I really hope they will watch it at some point. It's one of my favourite shows.

GhostPhil

I get a feeling Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure will never win a poll in this community because so many of us love your breakdowns and analysis of serious dramatic series but I really hope you guys check it out some time on the channel, it’s an amazing piece of media that many modern mangaka cite as inspiration for their work, and would be a fun change of pace. Among these 3 I don’t think you could go wrong with any, they’ll all make excellent reaction series :)

hman70

At some point these two need to see Erased

K_How

FMAB is one of the most boring reaction shows imo. I can't believe ppl vote for it

mpk258

Agreed

Keith

Code Geass so underrated :/

Thomas Reinhardt

Vinland Saga is the literal best show for you two to watch out of these three

VoN

You guys should watch To Your Eternity, just started watching and it's already one of the most heartfelt animes I've ever seen.

Alan