Fishing Rogues!

A bird- specifically a pigeon.

I live in Idaho and I get a lot of snags on tree branches or twigs

"You saw NOTHING!" ::paddles away::

Oops! Hazards of coastal fishing. -a

::concerned honk::

If I'd listed tin cans and tires, would it have given me away as an Animal Crossing player? -a

Yeah that happens sometimes. Sorry, fish. -a

Wow, I think I've only seen freshwater eels in an aquarium! -a

Bet that duck was pretty confused, too! Hope it was ok afterward! -a

Oops! Bet that smelled really interesting. -a

did you drink it?

Doug Watson

I have caught numerous things fishing the only thing on that list I haven't caught was undergarments but I have reeled in a pair of stilletos shoes I have also caught things like a cooler, bb gun, a house window (lake i was fishing was once a small town way back) countless tires ( people used them as like bumbers for docks), a toothbrush, and an unopened 6 pack

A length of outdoor reinforced Ethernet cable that was still in use for something? We towed it around the river for a bit and saw it connecting to what looked like a cellular tower without the tower part. We then chose to just drop it and act like we saw nothing...

Pattmyn

A seagull! That was a sad day

Kristen Cladek

I hooked a goose out of mid air on accident once

The options reads like a Minecraft player put together the poll.

Bill Shields

A fish, but with the hook underneath its belly

pawsnreflect

Sea weed bass. They can be quite plentiful in Lake Winnebago.

David Pick

I once caught an eel of some kind, while fishing in a creek. I was probably six or seven years old at the time, and regularly played and fished in the creek, so seeing this strange thing was pretty freaky. ETA: I don’t know if links work here, but this is where I caught the eel: Dropped pin https://goo.gl/maps/rm7yP3K22EckTq199

My brother once hooked a duck that paddled over his line. Thought it was the biggest fish of his life, until he seen the duck hovering above the water!

My friend's fishing pole... and a piece of a dead fish.