SamSuka
americanmcgee
americanmcgee

patreon


Enamel Pin Ponderings

Dear Insane Children

Font Lord here, ready to excite your Christmas/Boxing Day/Festive Celebrations with actual images of real pins being made   :)

Take a look at the pic and see which of these 3 samples tickles your fancy the most and sound off in the comments below.

* Over on the left, we have 'Silver Metal with Black Enamel'.
* In the middle we have 'Black Nickel and Silver Filling'. (yes, it really does have that kinda 3D look on the symbols)
*And on the right, we have 'Black Nickel with White Enamel'.

Me and American have our own ideas about which style to go for, but without letting you know which way we're leaning, we wanted to hear from you.

So, say LEFT, RIGHT or MIDDLE in the comments and then we'll see if all our ideas line up and we can tell the factory to pull the trigger on getting it all made    :)

- Cheers and a Merry Christmas to all

Comments

Right

Right

Middle :D

Right~

Middle

Left :)

NecromancerforLife

Left or Right. I don't care for the center one.

The right one!

I want the left one tbh

Right!

I think the one on the right looks best. I like the 3D aspect of the center one but it looks too cloudy...

Christ Why

Middle

Right! :)

RIGHT

Middle

LEFT

Middle or right

Middle! Love the design!!

Right

Middle

Going right, it’s clearest & makes me Cheshire grin

Right. The left one looks too bright like it is unfinished and the middle one looks wrong

I like the middle, but I don't know if it will work with all of them. I think my official vote with be the right.

Drucilla Shultz

Middle <------ 100%!!!!! *cheeto dab* *cheeto dab* EDIT: While I appreciate the highly scientific method of Patreon comments, perhaps you could put up an actual survey? Unless, the goal is plausible deniability so you can make an executive decision to go with the one you like, in which case all is proceeding according to plan and again, thank you for choosing the middle one which is obviously superior in every way. The public will never even know. :D

truth_decay

They're all gorgeous but, middle! (= Merry Christmas and happy holidays to you all!! <3

Middle

James Allvord

I like right and middle

Right looks best, middle close behind tho

Hahnt9009

Personally, leaning towards middle, I like that aesthetic

eman5112

Black and white!

right!!

Right

Right!!! :)

Right

Right :D

Right

Middle

Right !

Right, really like the middle one but the one in the right is much clearer.

3

Masha Gazizova

The one on the right. The one in the middle looks too thick on the black and looks blurry.

Middle!

Middle!! That looks sick as hell!!

Black Nickel and White Filling I like the 3D effect of #2, but it has a dim darkened look. It does seem to ‘pop’. And I like how #3 ‘pops’, the contrast is extremely striking. A mix would turn heads. And the 3D would help protect the coloring. P.S. Be cool if the Patreon exclusive pin was [Black Nickel and Rustic Gold Filling].

Right first, then middle

Right then left. The right is the clearest, but I sort of like the white on the left.

Right!

I'd go for the Middle, even if the photo is a bit blurry, but Right is a close second

I like the one on the right.

The one on the right.

Phil Swabo

Middle!

Right is the best out of them all, the middle falls second only because it looks a bit blurry with the way the clear coating on top reflects. The silver in the left just blends everything together and not as eye catching or clear as the others.

Right one as first choice. Middle is second.

Middle!

I like the right best!

Middle

ReaperNX

Right, then middle.

Right! (or middle as my second choice).

Right

The one on the right!

Definitely not Adam Driver

me and the insane husband vote middle.

Middle

Middle

First choice would be right, 2nd would be middle.

Ray Weatherford

Either of Middle or Right

Jaded Entity

Right

Erin Flower

If I have to pick, I'd say: middle. But truthfully I don't like any of them! I would like to see them in grey/silver not the black and white ones. Is it a pin you can wear? Cause now it looks like a fridge magnet! Sorry, just not really liking them

Right

Stardust

LEFT or RIGHT (I like the minimalist look of the left, but the right is also really good looking)

That SPY

Man it's a toss up between the middle and right for me, I would be happy with which ever of those two wins.

Right

Sarah McKeegan

Right.

Right.

MeBonnieLass

Middle!🎩

Right. Middle looks fuzzy (unless that's what we're going for)

Right

Abelwyn Connelly

Middle or right

Right ☺️

Right. Happy holidays everyone

Right

Right

mckenic

Middle

missa8u

Middle

Right!!!!!!!

Angel Ellis

Middle, definitely

Middle!!

Nao Stryker

Right

Katherine Shearer

Right

Right

Middle.

Right 😎

Middle

Right

Right!

Right

On the pics, right is the cleanest but you know, from pictures to reality...

Right

Right

Right

Davinellulinvega

Right

Middle

Daniel Linsley

Middle

Middle

Right

Right

Right

Tequila JoJo

Right

Right

Kizu

Right

Right

Laura Fowler

Right

Right

Right

Right

Right 🖤

WitchDoll

Right

The right one...

Right

Right

Middle

Middle or Right, the right one is more clear, the middle has something. :)

Right

Right

Henrike

In reason of the color Design... right

Right!

Right ! It's better than the others.

Right looks cleanest

Right and Middle. Left looks like a factory defect but might change my mind if I see other pins with the left style.

Right please

pretty sure "Silver metal" is still nickel, but I could be wrong

Catheryn Alice North

right

Catheryn Alice North

Right

Middle

Right

Lady Charon

I like the colors on the right one the most, but I'm allergic to nickel so just because of that I vote left 🙈

What about left, but inverted? Like black on silver?

Wendy Jaa

Right

Gregor Hähnel

Right

Right

right

MithrilRathalos

Right. It's so much cleaner and easier to read

HaywireFool

Right

Right

Middle is my favorite, but Right would be my second choice.

Summer Hinch

I like the right one a lot!

Designated Red

Middle for sure looks more to the theme

Right for me. It looks more like Hatters hat in my opinion

Right

right

Middle is my first choice, right is my second. Left has too much silver on it.

ImprudentBean35

Middle

Right, but I'd also be pretty happy with Middle as a second best.

Rosuav

Middle

Middle

They all look pretty good honestly! But I have to go with- Right!

Right

Middle - very much prefer the more ...analog (?) look of it as opposed to the other two, which have a clarity that doesn't seem to fit.

Middle

Right. The middle does look cool with the 3D effect, but the right is much more cleaner as an enamel pin.

Middle

Tika

Right

Right

Right

Middle!!!!

Middle for sure! I rather like the 3D effect it has

Right

Middle! Definitely middle! The 3d aspect makes it different and what else screams Alice than different and unique??

Middle

Middle

Right, the sharpest of the three 👌

Vladimir Ruthven

Right

Hookboy

Right

Middle.

Katelyn

Right

Middle!

Right

Right

MIDDLE!!!!

Right

RainbowViper

Right for sure

Right

Merry Christmas to my fellow insane brothers and sisters🤗and to your family...Right one. Definitely!!

Tal'Ki

Right :)

GoldenSonic115

right

right

Ashley Lopez

Right

Right

Right! :)

Right based on visibility and how immediately recognizable it is.

I like them all but Right appeals to me the most.

Right 100%

Middle or right.

Right!

Right

Right

I'd have to say right is best looking IMO

I love the Middle one, expessally the 3D look of if. I feel the one on the left is too washed out and the on on the right has less definition than ths middle one.

Right, then middle. Left just doesnt have that pop to it.

Right. 100%

Right

The middle and right ones are better; the left one doesn't really stand out in my opinion

Veronica Martinez

Right

Right, by a large margin.

Tenori

Middle

Right.

I like the middle and right ones.

DitzyBat


More Creators