“Like Warm Apple Pie”

Moving away from your parents for the first time is, understandably, anxiety-driven for most people; especially the younger ones moving into a new home by themselves. Matthew was one of those people.

For him, moving out of the home he shared with his parents was a huge step in his life. The biggest worry for him wasn’t even the responsibility of owning a home, but rather the thought of living alone. All he hoped for was to meet new people and not be so alone every day and night.

After a few days of settling into his new home, all the boxes had been emptied and the items within them had been tidily placed around the house. His brand-new bed was set up, all his clothes were in the wardrobe and drawers, the bathroom essentials were displayed across the sink, and his large collection of movies and video games were stacked on the shelves. It felt weird for Matthew to be sleeping alone in his own house and not having someone to wake up to — not his mother, nor his stepdad.

When sitting down and just watching YouTube on his TV, he was thrown off by the sound of a doorbell. Someone was knocking? Who could that even be? Perhaps it was his mother visiting to see how he was holding up. But then again, he knew she would’ve texted to let him know beforehand.

He stood up from the couch and made his way towards the front door. Upon opening it, he was surprised by the sight. It wasn’t his mother at all; in fact, she was a complete stranger.

“Well, hi there, neighbour!” Greeted the woman.

She was a reddish-brown mare with wavy red hair, who wore a green checkered shirt that was tied to make it look like a crop-top, along with a pair of blue jean shorts that didn’t even come close to the top of her knees. He was surprised to see how broad her shoulders were, and she seemed rather thick around some other areas of her body, especially what was contained within that shirt of hers. He tried his hardest not to stare and kept his gaze on the woman’s Crystal-blue eyes.

“Oh, uh…hello!”

“My name’s Rain, I live next door. I couldn’t help but notice you just moved in and so I thought I’d bring over a little housewarming gift to make you feel welcome!”

In her hands was a freshly-baked apple pie. The smell of it was magnificent; it was so nice that even though he already had breakfast, it made him wish he hadn’t.

“Well, my name’s Matthew. Pleasure to meet you, Rain!” He said politely. “Would you like to come in and have some tea?”

“Oh, I’d love to!”

Once settled down, the mare had placed the pie on the table and leaned back slightly into the couch as she rested her body.

“So how was the move, dear?”

“It was fine, thanks. I was pretty nervous, though, since this is my first time moving into my own home. Gonna feel really weird not having my mum around all the time. I’ll miss it.”

“Oh, so you’re a momma’s boy, huh?”

“Yeah, a little, haha.”

“Aww,” the mare adored. “But you’re okay now, yes?”

“Absolutely! I’m just a little concerned about meeting new people ‘cause I’m quite awkward, heh.”

All she did was let out a small giggle.

“Well, now you have me to talk to! And you’ve been very well-mannered so far. If you ever need anything, I’m right next door.”

“Thank you. That means a lot.”

The pair smiled at each other as they took a sip of their tea.

“So if you don’t mind me asking, what do you do for a living?” The wolf asked.

“I’m actually a baker around here! My store’s just down the street.”

“Oh wow!” He responded. “No wonder how you managed to bake such a gorgeous-smelling pie, haha.”

“Well, thank you, hon! I made it with extra love.”

For a moment, Matthew looked at the pie and out of nowhere, he came up with an…interesting idea.

“Y’know, it actually makes me wanna watch American Pie tonight.”

All Rain did was laugh at the comment.

“Ha! A classic! Been a long time since I’ve seen it, though.”

“Yeah, your pie made me think of that movie. ‘Specially that one scene where the guy’s friend tells him that third base felt like ‘warm apple pie’ and he goes ahead and sticks his—“

“You thought about doing that to my pie?” She looked at him confused.

Embarrassed, he attempted to respond and explain himself, but all he could do was say, “N-no!” which sent the mare into a fit of laughter.

“I’m just messing around! Your reaction was priceless, haha. Pretty cute, too.”

Matthew sat back and wiped his forehead as he let out a quick sigh of relief.

“I never did actually know if that’s how a vagina felt, though.”

Immediately after hearing those words leave his mouth, Rain sat up a little and turned her body towards him.

“Wait,” she started. “You don’t know what it feels like? Have you never had sex before?”

“Uh…no, heh.”

That topic about work suddenly changed real fast. However, Rain didn’t seem opposed to it. In fact, she seemed rather intrigued by his confession.

“That’s unbelievable! How can a young guy like you still be a virgin?”

“Like I said: I’m a pretty awkward guy…” his ears lowered a little due to his shyness.

“Well, you’re really sweet and well-mannered, and I love men like that.”

Hearing those compliments from the woman made his ears perk up once again, a little redness flaring up in his cheeks now.

“You think so?”

“Absolutely. In fact…” she shuffled herself a bit towards him. “I do like younger men, too — especially the shy ones~”

He was shocked to hear that come from her as he saw those piercing eyes looking right back at him; an older woman not even close to his age seemed to be flirting with him. Not just that, but she was also his new neighbour.

“R-really? Uh…you gotten a lucky find?”

“Potentially,” the mare replied, meanwhile her hand was moving slowly up his thigh. “And he just moved in next door~”

“O-oh…”

A soft, seductive giggle followed afterwards. Every way he responded to her words and actions was pushing her buttons, and she couldn’t get enough of it.

“Y’know what? How about you save the pie for later, and instead, we make a new pie together?” She asked as the distance between them closed with every second.

“Oh? W-what kind of pie?”

Upon the mare placing her hand on his crotch, she already knew what his answer was without even saying it, and he most certainly approved.

“You’ll find out~”

Shortly after saying that, she moved in closer and pressed her warm lips against his, bringing him into a deep, passionate kiss. The seductive hums coming from her mouth were extremely arousing to him — so arousing that she felt his member already begin to tent underneath those jeans. He slowly wrapped an arm around her waist as they went further into the kiss, hums from the wolf soon following Rain’s as his bulge became more sensitive to her touch by the minute.

After a while, their lips separated as she looked into his ocean-blue eyes, the wolf panting slightly from the intense, intimate moment they shared together. However, she didn’t let him have a breather for long — she had already begun to make her move.

Rain’s hand that was resting atop of his crotch was soon unbuttoning his pants to let his growing bulge roam free before pulling them down immediately after, soon beginning to shed off her own clothing, too.

“Mmm, I can already tell you’re gonna be a lot of fun~” stated the horse in that seductive tone while the wolf eagerly took off his vest. Upon removing said vest, he noticed the mare was untying the knot that was keeping her shirt up like a crop-top. Immediately after getting it undone, the parts of the shirt that were tied in the knot fell onto her thighs along with her breasts. He was surprised to see that she wasn’t wearing anything underneath, and boy, what a surprise it was.

He knew her boobs were large just from seeing them rest in that shirt, but he was not expecting them to be any bigger than they already looked. They were so big, that even the slightest movement would make them sway and jiggle; he couldn’t take his eyes off them.

“Here,” she reached out her hand and guided his towards herself. “Give ‘em a feel~”

Upon first touching them, he was mesmerised by how wonderful they felt; he couldn’t even fit all his hand around each one despite having a decent size for himself. Her boobs were soft, yet firm, the perfect blend for such a large pair. Most women’s breasts were saggy when it came to a size like Rain’s, but fortunately, not for her. She very much enjoyed the sensation of the wolf’s fondling, a nice, firm grip, but still gentle. He even managed to get a soft hum to escape her mouth.

However, she thought he had enough time to feel her. Now it was time to feel him.

While she let him continue to play with her boobs for just a little longer, she made no hesitation to sink her fingers into his waistband and pull down his boxers to reveal the package the garments were hiding.

“Oh my~” she let out, a wide grin on her face. “A big boy in both ways, I see~”

Rain let the shirt she was wearing slip off her shoulders and tossed it onto the floor before repositioning herself and leaning down towards his hardened meat, wrapping a hand around the shaft.

“Lemme get a quick taste…”

The mare took her time with him. She made it a priority to keep her eyes up at the wolf so she could watch his reactions of his first time; she wanted it to be an experience for him to remember.

With no sign of the wolf wanting her to stop, she went ahead and brought his cock to her lips, letting his shaft sink deeper inside. She looked up to see pleasure fill up his face, his cheeks reddening as he let out a soft and soothing moan. The same hand she used to line his dick up to her maw was now cupping his soft, heavy balls, fondling them gently as she went to town on him. He tasted amazing when the pre coated her tongue — a perfect mix between bitter and sweet.

Matthew’s moans grew louder consecutively after one another, his eyes now closing as he leaned his head back. He rested his hand on her lower back and began running it up and down slowly as the speed of her head bobbing picked up. Despite only wanting to just have a little taste, she couldn’t stop there; she wanted more.

After a few tender minutes of her devouring his meat, she finally brought her head up with a huff following shortly after. The feeling of Rain’s warm saliva remained glistening on his cock as the fresh air brushed against it, slowly becoming less immune to its coolness. However, it wasn’t for long; things were about to get even warmer. As much as she wanted to keep sucking, there was someplace else she wanted it more. And she was certainly eager to see the look on his face once he was in there.

“Now for the best part…”

The mare suddenly stood up from the couch and began to unbutton her jean shorts before pulling them down from her hips, along with the panties she wore underneath, and kicked them off her hooves. Matthew couldn’t help but stare at the slit between her thighs, and she giggled as his jaw dropped. She then eagerly lifted a leg across his side, straddling his lap with her now towering over him.

“You aware of how mare pussy works?” Rain asked curiously.

“Uh…” clearly from that word alone, he had no idea what she was talking about.

The mare giggled. “Don’t worry, you’re in for a treat~”

While resting on his lap, she began to move her hips back and forth while his schlong was pressed in between the flaps of her vagina. He was surprised to feel how warm it was; pussy being warm was to be expected, but not as warm as he thought it was going to be. It was beyond that — hot, even.

The equine cooed above him as his member throbbed in between her lips, watching as the young wolf shivered with anticipation, his face redder than ever.

“You ready, sugar?~” she asked while caressing the young wolf’s cheek to comfort him, keeping his gaze on hers.

He eagerly nodded in response, unable to speak due to disbelief of what was going on in that moment.

Once Rain finally gained his approval, she raised herself up with her hand braced around his meat, stroking it gently, and aligned it to the entrance. He then watched as her body began to lower slowly, a warm ring of flesh greeting the head of his cock, and it was at that moment when the reality hit Matthew like a pile of rocks — he had lost his virginity.

She sunk her body lower ever so slowly and welcomed his cock inside her mare pussy, sweet, gentle moans coming from the wolf underneath her, as well as her. But suddenly, something odd happened — at least odd to Matthew; her muscles began to wrap around him and squeeze his flesh. The deeper he went, the tighter it became, her walls were clenching around him and hungrily kissing his meat. He had no idea that mares’ vaginas had the ability to adjust to any sized penis that penetrated them, making for the perfect cocksleeve for any male who enters. Now it was clear what she meant by the fact he was ‘in for a treat’.

The sensation of Rain’s walls tightening around him made the wolf’s moans increase in volume as his own grip tightened around her sides in response.

“Getting tighter, huh?~” she asked with a seductive grin, knowing what his answer would be.

“Y-yes…” he replied, unable to get many words out after that.

“Mmm, thaaat’s it, baby — let me embrace you…”

His eyes forced shut out of pure bliss while the mare just watched, smiling at how pleased he appeared to be from the sensations he was experiencing for the first time. To comfort him even more, she wrapped her hand around his neck and pulled him towards her chest, burying his face into those large breasts of hers.

The feeling of his face nestled in between her boobs felt amazing; they felt like a pair of pillows because of how big and soft they were. He could’ve probably slept on them if he rested his head there long enough.

As soon as she pulled Matthew towards her, she lifted herself up slowly until his head was barely popping out of her and then forced his whole length back inside, causing a louder, more passionate moan to escape his muzzle.

“So…t-tight…”

After the first squat, she proceeded to do another, the cute noises coming from the wolf encouraging her to do them again, and again, and again. However, while she was busy riding that fat cock of his, she couldn’t help but desire his hands to be at another area.

“Here, sweetie,” she grabbed hold of his hands while she stopped her riding for a moment, guiding them to her thick rump where she let them rest. “Hold momma just like this~”

Momma? Did she just call herself momma? Looking back at when he admitted about being a momma’s boy, it made sense why she said that; she must’ve liked the idea of having her own ‘son’ to play with and show affection to. He didn’t know what to think of it at first, the idea of her being a mother-figure, but in the moment…it was kind of a turn-on for him. And since he didn’t respond to her comment and kept on moaning, she knew he wasn’t opposed to the idea.

As soon as his hands were rested on her round, red ass, the riding proceeded, this time with the pace slightly faster now. He continued his intimate grunts in between her breasts as her vagina massaged his cock lovingly, their moans harmonising out of pure lust and pleasure. She liked the feeling of his cock inside her so much that she didn’t want to wait any longer to pick the speed up even more. She was practically craving for his meat.

At that point, the living room began to echo the slapping sounds of their hips colliding together along with their moans. The feeling of Matthew’s cock sliding in and out of her pussy at that speed was amazing. In fact…he was beginning to feel a tingling sensation which only intensified by the minute, and he had a good idea what was going to happen next.

“Ohh, fuck…I-I think I’m gonna cum…”

“Mmm, do it, baby,” she ordered. “Give mommy a creampie~”

She kept the pace of her riding consistent as she listened to his moans grow louder and louder every second, the walls of her vagina becoming even tighter than before. His hands squeezed her rump and every muscle in his body began to uncontrollably flex while his soft balls tightened up and his ears went back, the tingling flowing through him at light speed and sending him over the edge. The feeling somehow felt much stronger than usual than whenever he masturbated, though; whenever he expected it to stop, it went on even longer. He never knew when it was going to end, until eventually—

“OHH, FUCK!!!”

Immediately upon howling those two words, his cock erupted with warm, thick semen, painting Rain’s walls white as she continued to bounce on him. Even when the build up of his ejaculation finally released, Rain refused to stop there; she loved the feeling of his dick throbbing hard inside, and she insisted on riding out his orgasm.

“Ohhh, yes, Matthew…Let it allll out…”

The persistence of her riding made it even MORE pleasurable for Matthew, his body stiffening out of instinct. The pace became much slower as it calmed overtime, though; she wanted it to be an experience he’d NEVER forget.

Once his orgasm fully calmed, she sunk herself onto him once again, taking his entire shaft inside and keeping it there, making sure it was nice and toasty as it spurted out its last drops of cum.

“There’s a good boy,” she whispered into his ear, pulling him into another passionate kiss soon after, a brief one this time.

Once the kiss was broken, the mare raised herself up and let him slide out, his freshly-shot cum spilling out of her vagina and onto his drained cock.

“Oh my~” said Rain as she felt the warm fluids leak out, the poor wolf still exhausted from the climax. The mixture of her hot juices still coated on his schlong, along with the fresh breeze brushing against it since it was now out of her pussy, was a surreal sensation.

“Here…let mommy clean you up…”

The equine climbed off of Matthew and got on her knees in between his legs, grabbing ahold of his shaft once again before she started gliding her tongue up from knot-to-tip. Despite his orgasm ending, his cock was still rather sensitive; the feeling of her tongue and maw massaging him once again after sex only sent him into a deeper state of pure ecstasy. He could barely get any words out — only grunts and moans managed to escape his winter muzzle.

*buzz…buzz…buzz*

After hearing a sudden alert coming from her phone, the mare pulled herself off his cock and quickly got up on her hooves again before reaching down to her clothes on the floor.

“Okay, sweetie — I gotta go; got some food in the oven that needs to come out,” she stated, rushing to button her shirt back up.

“Oh, okay…”

The wolf watched as she bent over to pull her jean shorts back up, her bare red ass just inches away from his face; he swore he saw just a little bit more of his seed leak out from between her flaps, and he couldn’t help but smile.

“But,” Rain continued, “considering you’re British so you’ll understand this…you can put your sausage roll back in MY ‘oven’ anytime~”

His cheeks turned rose red after hearing those words come out of her mouth, causing his limping dick to barley twitch with excitement despite being exhausted from the constant pumping.

Before she went, the mare gave him a soft-passionate kiss on his lips once more before heading out the front door.

“See ya later, sugar~”

And there Matthew laid on the couch, still naked from his encounter with the horse. He reflected on what had just happened moments prior and he could barely believe it himself.

“Did I really just lose my virginity? Did I actually fuck a mare, let alone one that was a lot older than me? Did I kinda like it when she referred to herself as mommy?”

Well, one thing was for certain: while watching American Pie later that night, he was definitely going to be thinking about her.

________________________________________

This SPICY pic was drawn by the amazing Jailbird!

Rain the horse belongs to my wonderful friend, Rainstorm from FA!