It started with shaving underarms - Part 1

OTHER PARTS | ALL STORY LIST

His smooth skin was a secret he kept. He would feel it during the day, like when he reached for a file or stretched after sitting. It was a brief brush of fabric against his bare skin. This sent a quick feeling through him. What was that feeling? Was it worry? Guilt? Or a strange, secret excitement?

He started looking closely at people on the subway. He wasn't looking at women in a sexual way, but with a strong, careful curiosity. He studied a barista’s clear skin, the slight shine on a businesswoman's eyelids, and the perfect shape of a coworker’s eyebrow. These features were not just natural; they were accomplishments. They were the result of hard work and skill.

The internet learned what interested him and became his teacher. His social media feed was full of videos about changing your look. He saw videos of bearded, tough faces becoming soft and beautiful with makeup. He learned the difference between a beauty blender and a brush, and between setting spray and primer. The words were new to him, but he learned quickly.

The urge grew from a small idea into a strong need. He had to try it.

He told himself it was just to see. Just to learn how it worked. It was like research or a mental test.

Buying the products felt like a secret mission. He made a new, secret email account. He used a private browser window. He spent an hour on a website that promised "plain packaging." His finger was shaking over the "Checkout" button. This felt much more risky than shaving. Shaving was just taking something away. This was adding something. This was creating something new.

He ordered a “starter kit” from a brand for all genders: a light tinted moisturizer, a concealer slightly lighter than his skin, and a clear setting powder. The description said it would create a “natural, no-makeup look.” It sounded safe and easy to hide.

The package arrived three days later in a plain, brown box. He felt like he was handling something illegal. He waited until nighttime, after his last text with Chloe, when he was sure no one would find out.

In the bright light of his bathroom, he placed the items on the counter. They looked small and harmless. He read the instructions on the back of the tinted moisturizer, focusing hard. This was more difficult than he had thought.

He started with the concealer. He patted a small amount under his eyes with his finger, just like a video showed. He blended it in, pressing and smoothing. The dark circles from staying up late seemed to disappear. It was… effective.

Feeling more confident, he squeezed a small drop of moisturizer onto the back of his hand. It was cool and smooth. He put dots of it on his forehead, cheeks, nose, and chin, then began to blend it. It felt like a strange, gentle face massage. His skin, which he usually just washed, was becoming a canvas. The product smoothed out his reddish skin. It hid a small scar on his chin and the leftover redness from acne. His skin looked calmer and more even.

Finally, he dipped the soft puff into the setting powder and gently pressed it over his face. This locked the makeup in place.

He finished and stepped back, his heart beating fast.

The man looking back from the mirror was… him. But a better him. A him who had gotten eight full hours of sleep. A him with clearer skin and a more rested, clean look. The changes were small, so small that no one else would notice. But to Alex, they were life-changing.

The noisy, judging voice in his head—the one that was always comparing him and telling him to do more—became quiet. For the first time in a long time, his mind was silent. The face in the mirror was not a disguise; it felt like he was correcting something.

He leaned closer. He didn't see a man in makeup. He just saw a face that looked… right.

This wasn't strange. This wasn't shameful. It was useful. It was self-care. He easily found a reason, which calmed the last of his worry.

He spent the next fifteen minutes just looking. He turned his head, watching how the light hit his new, even skin. A small, real smile touched his lips. This was his. A secret skill. A hidden protection.

The sound of his phone on the counter was a sudden interruption. It was a video playing loudly. A man was shouting about “MAXIMUM MUSCLE GAINS” and “SHREDDED ABS IN SIX WEEKS.”

The sudden return to his normal life was like a physical shock. He jumped.

He looked from the shouting, very masculine face on his phone to his own calm, slightly improved reflection in the mirror. The two images could not exist together. They were from different worlds.

With a sigh, he picked up a tissue. He wiped the concealer from under his eyes. He scrubbed off the tinted moisturizer until his skin was back to its normal, flawed state. The magic was gone, removed as easily as it was put on.

But as he got into bed, the feeling of that quiet mind and that sense of being "right" stayed with him. It was more than just curiosity now. It was a strong desire. He had found a small, hidden switch inside himself. He had learned, with a scary and exciting certainty, that it turned on the light.

The good feeling from the makeup experiment was like a ghost that wouldn't leave him. It changed everything. It shifted how he saw the world in small, confusing ways. The world was not the same world with a new filter; it was a completely different world. He was now studying a culture he had only ever watched from the outside.

The gym, his safe place for strength and confidence, felt different. The crash of the weights, the grunts of effort, the smell of sweat—it all felt like a performance. He watched the other men, their faces tense with effort, their bodies huge with muscle. He saw the silent competition in every heavy barbell. He saw the social ranking based on the numbers on the weight stack.

He was on the leg press, pushing a weight that would have made him proud a week ago. Then he saw a woman across the room. She wasn't lifting heavy weights. She was doing a series of smooth, controlled movements with a kettlebell. Her body moved gracefully from one pose to the next. It had a flow to it, a mix of strength and flexibility that looked less like a fight and more like a dance.

A memory came back: a video of a dancer, whose muscles were long and defined, not bulky. The words had said, "A dancer's body shows practical strength, not just size."

The thought stayed with him, stuck in his mind. Later, back in his apartment, he didn't search for "bulking routines" or "mass building." His fingers, almost by themselves, typed "Pilates for a slim body" into the search bar.

The videos were amazing. They were quiet. The instructors spoke in calming voices about "using the core," "making the muscles longer," and "finding flow." There were no grunts or screams. It was about control, accuracy, and the subtle, burning effort of holding a position. He found a beginner's video and rolled out a towel on his living room floor.

It was hard. The movements, which looked so easy, made his muscles shake in ways heavy weights never did. He felt clumsy, disconnected from his own body. But there was a spark of something—a focus, a mind-body connection that was brand new. He wasn't just lifting weight; he was learning how to move.

His YouTube recommendations, always helpful, started suggesting yoga and barre workouts. He became obsessed, fascinated by the search for a different kind of body: not huge, but toned. Not size, but shape. He started doing a secret Pilates routine in the morning before work, his body learning a new way to move.

This change in focus changed how he acted in the world. Walking to the subway, he found himself watching women. Not with the cold, judging look he'd used before, but with a sharp, almost professional interest.

He noticed the way a woman in a fitted skirt walked, the controlled, confident swing of her hips. He saw the graceful curve of a wrist as a barista handed him his coffee, the careful way fingers tucked hair behind an ear. He saw the quiet confidence in a woman’s posture as she held the door open, the easy elegance of a well-made blazer on a slender body.

It wasn't like he was judging them as objects. It was a deep wish.

He was studying a language he desperately wanted to speak. He was breaking down a thousand tiny movements, poses, and habits. He had been taught to ignore these or see them as only for "others." Now, they felt like pieces of a puzzle he needed to solve. The way they crossed their legs, the tilt of a head while listening, the soft sound of a laugh—it all seemed to hold the key to a way of being that felt more true to him than the tough, chest-out performance he’d mastered.

One evening, he saw his reflection in a store window. He saw his wide shoulders, his strong stance. By habit, he started to puff his chest out, to take on the "alpha" position that came naturally. But it felt stiff and unnatural. It felt like a suit that was too small.

He let his shoulders relax. He softened his posture, letting one hip drop slightly. He didn't look powerful or threatening. He just looked… like himself. A more open, less guarded version, but one that felt much more real.

A group of women walked past him, chatting and laughing, their energy a bright, shared current. He watched them go, feeling a deep sense of loneliness. He wasn't one of the guys in the gym, and he wasn't one of these women on the street. He was in a middle place, watching from the wrong side of the glass.

He was learning a new language for his body and a new way of seeing the world. But with every new word he learned, the sound of his isolation grew louder. He was no longer just hiding smooth skin and makeup; he was hiding a whole new way of seeing, and the scary, exciting wish to be seen.

The internet videos and the private world of his bathroom were not enough anymore. The curiosity had become a physical pain, a need to feel the change not just on his skin, but covering his entire body. The idea of a silk shirt was nothing compared to the reality of its touch.

The idea of buying women's clothes was a huge, scary step beyond ordering makeup. Makeup could be washed away. Clothes had a presence. They took up space in his closet. They were proof.

For a week, he fought with the urge. The internal battle played out in the quiet moments of his day. He would stand in his closet, staring at the straight rows of grey, navy, and black. The polo shirts, the chinos, the stiff jeans. It felt like looking at another man’s clothes. A capable, successful, but completely empty man.

The moment he gave in was a video of a non-binary model, assigned male at birth, who spoke about their first time buying clothes at a thrift store. "It’s a safe place," they said, their voice calm and certain. "No judgment, just racks and racks of possible new selves. You can try on a personality for five dollars."

A safe place. That was the word that convinced him.

The following Saturday, he found himself on the train, heading deep into Brooklyn. He got off at a stop he had never visited before. The air smelled of fried food and distant traffic. The thrift store was located between a small shop and a laundromat. Its windows were filled with a messy collection of lamps, books, and clothes.

His heart was beating very fast. This was crazy. He felt like everyone on the street could see what he was doing, as if it were written on his forehead. He almost turned back three times, his feet frozen just outside the door.

Safe place, he repeated in his head, and pushed his way in.

The bell jingled, a normal, cheerful sound that felt strangely loud. The inside was a maze of full racks. The air was thick with the smell of old books and light, floral laundry soap. An older man was looking through records in a corner, and a couple of students were laughing over a rack of old band t-shirts. No one looked at him.

He moved, stiff and nervous, towards the back. The women's section exploded in a mix of color and texture. It was a strong difference from the dull sea of men's clothing he had just passed. He felt like he didn't belong.

His hands, slightly shaking, touched a sleeve. Silk. It was a blouse, a deep emerald green with a subtle pattern. The fabric was cool and incredibly soft. It slipped through his fingers like water. He pulled it from the rack, holding it up. It was cut differently—with folds at the chest, a narrower shoulder line.

This was it. This was the feeling he had been chasing.

He grabbed a few more items without thinking: a pair of black women’s tight jeans, a simple black tank top with delicate lace trim, and a soft, cashmere blend sweater in a pale grey. He did not allow himself to think. He just moved, like a hunter gathering his find.

The fitting room was a single, private stall with a curtain and a full-length mirror. His hands were sweaty as he struggled with the lock. Inside, the space was small and dark. He hung the clothes on the hook and looked at himself. He saw his familiar, worried face on top of his wide, masculine body in a t-shirt and jeans. The contrast between the man in the mirror and the delicate fabrics next to him was almost funny.

He took a deep, shaky breath and started to undress.

He started with the tight jeans. They were hard to pull on. They stuck to his thighs and calves in a way his loose-fit jeans never did. He sucked in his stomach to button them. The fit was a huge change. They made his legs look longer and hugged his shape. They made him aware of the form of his body in a completely new way.

Next, the tank top. The silk was a whisper against his skin. The lace trim gently touched his collarbones. It felt luxurious and forbidden. He looked in the mirror. The man was fading away, replaced by something… else. Something less clear.

Finally, the emerald blouse. He slipped his arms into the sleeves. The silk made a soft sound as it settled on his shoulders. It was tight across the back and chest, pulling in a way that was clearly not made for his body. But he didn't care. He buttoned it up, his fingers clumsy. The color made his eyes look brighter and his skin warmer.

He stood back and looked.

The person in the mirror was a clash of worlds. The masculine jaw, the short hair, the faint beard shadow—all of it fought with the elegant drape of the silk, the delicate lace showing underneath, and the feminine cut of the jeans that showed the shape of his hips.

He didn't see a man in women's clothes.

He didn't see a woman.

He saw a truth. A complicated, difficult, and amazingly beautiful truth. The clothes didn't feel like a costume. They felt like a return home. The stiff, performing shell of "Alex Rossi" seemed to break open. For a brief, wonderful moment, he could see the person who had been trapped inside all along.

A noise outside the curtain—a laugh—pulled him back to reality. The moment was over. Panic rushed through him, hot and sharp. He quickly scrambled out of the clothes, his hands shaking. He stuffed them back onto the hangers as if they were burning.

He bought all the clothes, his face red as he paid cash to a bored-looking teenager, who scanned the items without a second glance.

Back in his apartment, he hung the blouse and cardigan in the very back of his closet, behind a row of his own shirts. He folded the jeans and tank top and tucked them into a drawer beneath his sweaters.

He had crossed another line. He had covered his body in a new truth. Now that truth was hanging in his closet, waiting. The journey was no longer just in his mind or on his skin. It had taken shape. It had a texture, a color, a weight. And it was the most real thing he owned.

The secret in his closet was a living thing. He would open the door just to look, his fingers brushing against the silk of the emerald blouse as if for comfort. It was a clear promise of a self he was only beginning to be brave enough to imagine. But the real world, the world of Alex Rossi, was getting closer. The tension between the two was becoming too much to handle.

It started with Chloe.

Their date night at Mario’s, a traditional, red-and-white-tablecloth Italian place he had once loved, felt like a scene from a play he no longer enjoyed. He was just saying the words, going through the motions. He ordered the steak, medium-rare, and a strong red wine because that’s what Alex Rossi did.

Chloe, bright and lively in a little black dress, talked about her week, about a friend’s engagement, and about planning a trip to the Hamptons with another couple.

“You’ll love the guys,” she said, sipping her wine. “They’re very manly men. They like fishing and cold beers. Just your type.”

The words “manly men” hit him hard. He saw a quick flash of the thrift store mirror—the silk, the delicate lace, the way the jeans hugged his hips.

“Yeah,” he managed, forcing a smile. “Sounds great.”

She leaned closer, her voice dropping to a secret tone. “So, I was thinking for the trip… you should get that navy blazer from Brooks Brothers. The one we looked at. It would look so good on you. It makes your shoulders look even bigger.”

Every word was painful. She was lovingly and excitedly building the prison of his identity. She wasn't just dating him; she was carefully choosing his look. The man she saw was a project, a collection of desired, masculine traits. He felt like a show dog being prepared for a competition he never wanted to enter.

He was quiet on the walk back to her apartment. The city lights blurred into meaningless streaks of color.

“You’re quiet tonight,” Chloe said, wrapping her arm through his. “Is everything okay?”

“Just tired,” he mumbled, the lie feeling like ash in his mouth.

“Work problems?” she asked, her worry a gentle pressure that felt choking.

“Something like that.”

At her door, she turned to him. She expected the usual goodnight kiss, the confident, possessive pressure of his lips. He paused. The fake passion felt wrong. It felt wrong to both her and himself.

He gave her a quick, closed-mouth peck. “I’m just really exhausted, Chlo. I’ll call you tomorrow.”

Her face looked disappointed, a moment of confusion and hurt in her eyes. “Okay… well, sleep well, I guess.”

He walked away, feeling her eyes on his back. The weight of her disappointment added to his guilt. He was letting her down. He was failing at being the man she deserved.