SamSuka
The Caretaker
The Caretaker

patreon


GRECO-ROMAN MAGIC - NOV/1/2022

BEFORE WE TALK ABOUT MYSTERY CULTS, WE HAVE TO TALK ABOUT PYTHAGORAS

The ancient greeks loved triangles, couldn’t get enough of the things. In terms of human beings most associated with triangles, Pythagoras is right there at the top. He was also a magical practitioner who ran what could be called a “math cult.”

Pythagoras was a pre-socratic, meaning he existed before Socrates. This is important, because pre-socratic philosophy was notably weirder than its descendants. Philosophy and mysticism have a complicated relationship, but for many of the pre-socratics, magic and mysticism go hand in hand.

Pythagoras existed around the 5th-6th centuries BCE, and never wrote anything down. Because of this, much of the information about him comes from “The Life of Pythagoras” by Diogenes Laerius, and its descriptions of Pythagoras are tantalizingly steeped in legend and mysticism. I will maintain that the best magicians have an air of legend around their lives, and the process of combing the man from the legend is always an exciting process for the modern occultist. It is an opportunity to attempt to find out how a magical idea related with reality, to see how The Magician is constructed from the ground up.

Very little is known about Pythagoras’s early life. Some accounts [which ones?] say he traveled to Egypt to learn their secret wisdoms (read: probably geometry). This is an ancient example of a pattern we will see repeated going forward. “The wizard traveled to a mystical land and returned with occult knowledge.” Though, in this case, it is entirely possible. The mediterranean was a busy place, travel between Egypt and Greece was not uncommon, and one could in fact learn geometry in Egypt.

When Pythagoras was around 40, he moved to Kroton in what is now Italy, and started his cult. Here, he became famous as a sort of wonder-worker and sage, not a mathematician. Stories abound of his legendary magical feats like teleporting, appearing in both Croton and Olympia at the same time, and being possessed of golden thighs, a mark of divinity.

This begs the question: What did Pythagoras actually teach? The man was a bit of an innovator. He taught that the soul is distinct from the body, and survives after death. This was very unusual for the time, as the soul was considered something closer to a footprint one left on the world, and that remained after death. This is also an idea that may have been inspired by Egyptian conceptions of the soul. In addition, he taught that when the body dies, the soul is reborn into a new body. Reincarnation! Life of Pythagoras says: “Once they said he was passing by when a puppy was being whipped, and he took pity and said “Stop, do not beat it; for it is the soul of a friend that I recognized when I heard it screaming.”

Unfortunately, we know relatively little about his conception of reincarnation, but we do know that he was seen as an expert of sorts on the soul, and it seems clear that the soul was central to the sort of magic [endonym] he practiced. Specifically, it seems that his magic was based around manipulating his own soul. Little is known today about how exactly Pythagoras’s magic was supposed to work. However, if you were to ask Pythagoras how he was able to perform such wondrous feats, he would probably tell you it was a result of how he lived, and recommend that you follow his teachings.

Pythagoras had followers who followed a specific “Pythagorean” way of life, and this was likely how his followers were known to the wider public. We do not know many specifics, but according to Life of Pythagoras, we do know that Pythagoreanism involved:

Life of Pythagoras describes many of these teachings being delivered in the form of little sayings or fables akin to zen koans. Phrases like “Step not over a balance, i.e. “don’t be greedy”, or ‘poke not the fire with a sword’ i.e. “don’t piss off a guy who is already mad.” There are many more of these sayings and stipulations. Modern scholars are still in the dark as to what many of them actually mean. If you are curious as to why Pythagoreans must abstain from beans, Life of Pythagoras has a few theories:

As silly as this all may sound, it is important to note that “Pythagoreanism” was not proposed as an alternative to existing Greek religion. Pythagoreans participated in ordinary Greek religion just like their countrymen, but with some additional rules and stipulations. (i.e. it is forbidden to sacrifice a white cock) Looking back through the lens of history, they’re quite the mysterious bunch, and this mystery was likely by design. Initiates into the Pythagorean way of life were forbidden from sharing the secret teachings with outsiders. Because of this, Pythagoreanism is often referred to as a Mystery Cult. More on that later.

Earlier, I described pythagoreanism as a “Math Cult.” This was an eye-catching misrepresentation of the historical reality done for the explicit purpose of breaking down the concept and discussing its nuances, a technique that seasoned occultists like myself call “lying.”

Pythagoras is still to this day associated with mathematics. There has been a tendency among later occultists to look at some magical idea from the ancient world, see math, and immediately shout “Aha! This is Pythagorean!” Many Greek philosophers wrote on sacred mathematics, and it is important not to mistake one’s Plato for one’s Pythagoras. Unfortunately, there is very little evidence that Pythagoras himself engaged in sacred mathematics, but that doesn’t mean the ideas weren’t there.

The trouble is, and I am truly sorry to break the news to you dear reader, Pythagoras is dead. We can learn from this. If you’re the head of a magical/mystical/religious group, and you’re thinking “Man, my followers are just too ideologically united, what we need is some sort of big schism.” Try dying!

Its thought that after Pythagoras died, his followers split into two camps, the Acusmatici, who followed the rituals that outwardly characterized the movement, and the Mathematici, who focused more on the mathematical and philosophical elements of his teaching. So while Pythagoras is often associated with sacred mathematics, it was his pupils, writers like Archytas and especially Philolaus, who set the foundation. Maybe they got their stuff from a secret, esoteric teaching from Pythagoras himself, but there’s no way to know for sure.

[Maybe do a summary of Philolaus here]

There is an additional wrinkle here. Some time around the 4th century BCE, this legacy of pythagorean thinkers vanishes. Around the 1st century BCE they re-emerge as the Neo-Pythagoreans, a loose group of philosophers who hold Pythagoras as a central figure in the history of philosophy.

ON THE TERM “CULT”

LETS TALK ABOUT MYSTERY CULTS

Like magic, the term “Mystery Cult” is difficult to pin down. They are generally built around a central deity, and defined by initiatory rituals, meaning rituals that were required to be completed in preparation for some more important ritual.

often existed across broad geographic areas and time periods, so drawing similarities between any two mystery cults is hard.

PYTHAGORAS

THE ELEUSINIAN MYSTERIES

ORPHISM

Janko - The Derveni Papyrus ("Diagoras of Melos, Apopyrgizontes Logoi?"): A New Translation - https://www.jstor.org/stable/1215469

Papadopoulou - An Introduction to the Derveni Papyrus - https://chs.harvard.edu/ioanna-papado...

Betegh - The Derveni Papyrus: Cosmology, Theology and Interpretation  - 978-0521047395

Conference - THE FIRST COLUMNS OF THE DERVENI PAPYRUS - https://youtu.be/eKssxZcWnGU

THE PGM

Betz - The Greek Magical Papyri in Translation - 978-0226044477

https://archive.org/details/TheGreekMagicalPapyriInTranslation/page/n31/mode/2up?view=theater

Ankarloo and Clark - Witchcraft and Magic in Europe vol II - Ancient Greece and Rome - 978-0812217056

Ogden - Magic, Witchcraft, and Ghosts in the Greek and Roman World - 978-0195385205

Waston - Magic in Ancient Greece and Rome - 978-1788312981

Harris - Ancient Egyptian Magic - 978-1578635917

PORPHYRY AND IAMBLICUS

DIONYSIAN MYSTERIES


More Creators