SamSuka
NittPicc Reacts
NittPicc Reacts

patreon


BAND-MAID - Giovanni (Album & White Room)

The album version is great. Amazing, really...

This sound took me down an emotional journey. I wasn't sure if the song was going to be slow or fast or really heavy or light. It took so many turns that musical ideas I thought I could predict weren't possible here.

...and then I listened to the instrumental. There was more happening than I thought was there. Kanami's part was so much more than I could fully hear. Misa's lines that would shine through here and there. Akane's beautiful builds of intensity. Then Miku creating a strong strum pattern creating the overall chord progression sound and the sustained notes within the soloing sessions.

Amazing.

BAND-MAID - Giovanni (Album & White Room)

Comments

MISA MISA MISA!!!!! MISA MISA MISA!!!!! Nittpicc Nittpicc Nittpicc!

David Cook

“Just when I thought I knew what to expect… “ kind of like “Just when you thought it was safe to go back in the basement” when listening to Band Maid! 🤣🤣🤣 We all get put on our back foot!

Happy Freight Dawg

19:20 that 'what the f###k' face is priceless!! made the same on the first listen of the instrumental too...

Sawzar

"About Us" is another song which deserves a white room instrumental. Kanami's soloing underneath is almost completely drowned out.

Eno L

What a fantastic job, logically explaining chaos. Ever thought of going for a physics degree. (Smile) Kidding aside. This has been a favorite of mine but it took several listens to appreciate the composition. What a fantastic job by Kanami and the Maids! Plus, with Giovanni and Black Hole there should be no doubters as to Miku’s guitar skills. Wow!!! I would like to hear you comment on whether the musical training by the members is part of the reason for Band-Maid’s unique compositions - THAT WORK!!! And, as stated by others thank you NittPicc for you analysis using your musical training. Also, thank you for the flute addition at the end - Loved it.

Rebecca Haigh

Without holding back next please

Minchorules2809

Love the flute bit at the end and I really enjoy when you break the scorebook out. I will say that after hear the instrumental version, I subsequently hear Kanami much better in the studio version since my ears know what to listen for.

Roy C. Russell

So I've been wondering for a few months now, is that an SNES above your light switch? And if so, why?

Subscriber 555

I really enjoyed AMPs experience with this one too. https://youtu.be/1Sg6wC80sc0?si=7TAy0x544XxO-Fwq

Bandmaidfanatl

This was an absolutely phenomenal comparison/reaction. Thank you once again! I'm so happy you're enjoying the white room instrumentals - I've always felt they were so enjoyable because it's like a constant jam session for the instrumentalists and is so much fun to watch and just amazing to hear. I'm glad Giovanni blew your mind in the white room - your expressions were awesome 🤣✌️💗

picti_pixie


More Creators