I love this episode. I can't believe I'm saying this but I feel bad for Tim. And Lindsey. Jamie with the team is the cutest. I love Mia too Kate Voegele's voice is gorgeous.
Leora Nechama
2020-10-21 01:20:32 +0000 UTC
I have to say this...So many people down Lucas for trying to be everything to all his friends and family. He grew up in a town where everyone knew he was the son of someone who made it CLEAR, he didn't want him. The man literally told Lucas he wished he was an abortion. Lucas has a need of acceptance from all of them, for that reason. Does he do the right things....no...he lives by his feelings. Also Love makes you do things you wouldn't normally do, not because you want to hurt anyone, but because you don't see anyone or anything beyond that feeling. When you lose a love like that, it is like death, the feeling is the same, trust me I know. All those other fish in the sea can just go drown, worse thing to say to someone who lost a loved one.
WillAlwaysLoveClark
2020-07-21 18:31:23 +0000 UTC
Unpopular opinion, but I like dan and I feel bad for him.. lol he deserves to be in jail yes, but I don’t think he deserves to be shut out everyone has a chance to repent and be forgiven and I think he has proved by turning himself in that he can be. But that’s me 🤣 Clearly many people don’t believe him and think he’s the devil but I don’t necessarily agree with that whole narrative
Lexi
2020-06-29 13:26:10 +0000 UTC
Yeah, since we had the time jump is easy to forget but it’s true. While Haley knows Peyton and Brooke for longer, she’s been friends with Lindsey at this point for longer than she was friends with either of them at season 4. So, that’s why she feels protective of her as well. Lindsey may feel like an interloper for Peyton but she’s been there for a while now.
Dove
2020-06-27 18:13:25 +0000 UTC
Rewatching this reaction cause I’m bored on a Saturday morning and already want more OTH from Juli.
Nathan
2020-06-27 15:39:56 +0000 UTC
One of my favourite episode in S5. Sorry but once again I find Peyton really annoying. She's childish af
Juliette
2020-06-27 11:58:19 +0000 UTC
Yes, Eri, yes.
Nathan
2020-06-27 01:32:00 +0000 UTC
juli can make anything and everything gay and we are here for it lmaoo
fry
2020-06-26 20:14:17 +0000 UTC
They ain’t gay girl lol 😂 it doesn’t happen ever 😂😂
Lexi
2020-06-26 15:28:59 +0000 UTC
Yea Lindsey and Haley have been friends for two maybe three years at this point in the show. Lindsey has also become friends with all of the other people in Lucas's life as well.
J
2020-06-25 22:51:34 +0000 UTC
you don’t have to forgive! it’s your opinion and it’s all good about it !!
Enzo
2020-06-25 21:50:57 +0000 UTC
I love your reactions Juli and forgive me for saying it, I didn't really like Peyton this episode but I understand. I actually like Lindsey a lot and I still love Lucas, because he is flawed, he's not perfect, he does make stupid decisions, but I do feel like everyone in this show at some point has made a stupid decision!! It's so good!! (I wouldn't mind seeing Peyton and Linds falling in love!!)
Daniel French
2020-06-25 21:16:07 +0000 UTC
I honestly like Lindsey better than Lucas lol. But, I don’t mind Peyton as much as others here, I get her and I get Lindsey. Tim was sad but this was the first time that I actually cared for him. Poor Brooke, wanting her mother to love her and taking everything she can just to see her interest in her now as true caring. I like Mia but I feel she was a little harsh since she doesn’t know Brooke personally and that was a very personal remark she made to Brooke.
Dove
2020-06-25 18:51:27 +0000 UTC
Yes, I love her honest reactions and I wouldn’t want her to change her opinion based on everyone else’s. I’m just glad we can have open and honest conversations here. 😊
I think we all take these shows seriously as if we know these characters personally lmaoo 🤣
Tyler Powe
2020-06-25 16:07:27 +0000 UTC
That was when Lucas and Lindsey first started dating. They have been friends for at least a year an a half if not a bit longer.
Nathan
2020-06-25 15:00:41 +0000 UTC
yes i understand it too but I just don’t know if she’s been with her a lot or not because of the « I wanna know everything about you » thing, 3 episodes ago.
Enzo
2020-06-25 14:55:30 +0000 UTC
Thank you for saying that! I was thinking the same. I know we all are saying our opinion in a polite & respectful way but I just hope she continue to have her owns
Enzo
2020-06-25 14:54:05 +0000 UTC
Julie I just wanna say that I love your reactions. I want your honest reactions and I don't care if you like a character I like, or if you hate a character I like (in this case I had the same reaction to Lindsey when I first watched it). I just see a lot of comments going of here and I just hope you don't change your opinions because of it. I have followed lots of reactors that forces another opinion on themselves when receiving lots of comments like these. And anyways it's just tv-shows, everyone will have different opinions always :)
And btw in case anyone haven't said it yet, the hot bardernder is Joe Manganiello (you may have seen in magic mike ;)). Take care <3
AnnaBanana
2020-06-25 14:35:07 +0000 UTC
I love this episode, but Peyton annoyed the hell out of me. She was bitchy, childish and pitty. Peyton has always been the one who takes the high road, and her acting like this just really disappointed me. Lindsey wasn't a saint either this episode yes, but Peyton was the one who started the trashtalking. She never even gave her a chance. Back in the beginning of this season all Lindsey did was trying to be nice to her and I'm not saying they should've been best friends, but the fact that Peyton was straight up horible to her from the beginning is uncalled for. She really bugged me this season, but this episode in particular was a low point. She actually annoys me just as much as Lucas does at the moment. I am however glad Lindsey and Peyton got to talk it out in the end.
Anna
2020-06-25 13:21:12 +0000 UTC
That's true, I forgot about that! I don't mind the friendship though. Haley was without any of her friends for four years, I don't begrudge her for starting a friendship up with Lindsey. If I was in Haley's situation I'd probably feel the same way. Obviously a matter of opinion though:)
Ellie-Jane
2020-06-25 12:48:28 +0000 UTC
wasn’t Haley going out on a restaurent with Lindsey to know more about her?
their friendship come from nowhere to me, it’s just annoys me everytime Haley pretends her as her best friend
Enzo
2020-06-25 11:55:02 +0000 UTC
she’s not. both of them said horrible things this episode.
Enzo
2020-06-25 11:53:45 +0000 UTC
Gosh Peyton really disappointed me this episode. When I first watched the show I remember being irritated by Lindsey because she was an obstacle but now I'm older I really feel for her. She deserves better than Lucas not gonna lie. On another note I really like Lindsey and Haley's friendship, I feel like people forget that Haley was without Peyton and Brooke for four years so it's nice to at least know she was friends with Lindsey for some of that time.
Ellie-Jane
2020-06-25 10:49:44 +0000 UTC
Yeah but sometimes you get biased towards a character so it’s understandable lol
heather
2020-06-25 07:10:50 +0000 UTC
I like Peyton but it bugs me that Juli takes her side even when she's clearly in the wrong. She was such a bitch in this episode.
Vanessa Navarro
2020-06-25 07:03:18 +0000 UTC
I love how many comments OTH fans put and long dept conversations. I love reading it
izzy
2020-06-25 05:35:31 +0000 UTC
I just realized Leyton can be seen as a completely different thing lol - Lindsey x Peyton
Rubi Moon
2020-06-25 05:10:55 +0000 UTC
Peyton was wrong? in this episode Lindsey knew everything she was talking about, Peyton didn’t. She would have never make fun of her dead father if she knew, especially when her mom died from cancer. Lindsey knew due to the book that Peyton almost died and got a bullet. but still made fun of that. so that’s not because we are Peyton fan that we don’t see the bad things of her! I do sometimes. But the situation with Lindsey is just so cringy. The way Lindsey wants so bad to be friend with Peyton is just so unrealistic and could be understandable that Peyton isn’t trusting that.
Our love for characters doesn’t reflect our vision of them. It’s just that there’s so many excuses that makes us understand the character. I guess we have differents angle to see from idk 🤷🏼♂️
Enzo
2020-06-25 03:46:08 +0000 UTC
people defending Lindsey like she was a saint. they both said horrible things. peyton may have said it about the ring but lindsay said about the shooting thing even though she wrote about it, has been investigated about that. so they both have been awful to each other in this episode.
Loved seeing Tim btw!
Enzo
2020-06-25 03:35:15 +0000 UTC
the storyline in season 6 are better than S5
Enzo
2020-06-25 03:32:19 +0000 UTC
and episode 12 is a even bigger one. 🤯🤯
Enzo
2020-06-25 03:32:00 +0000 UTC
unpopular opinion I guess but I may have hated some things Peyton handled in the past seasons but in this one I didn’t. Honestly I may be the only one to think that but Lindsey is so annoying my god, that way she pretends every. damn. episode. knowing everyone because of the book is like, please you‘ve been there 5 minutes ago stop pretending you know everyone and the way she overreacted at the beginning of the episode is like 🙄.
Glad she and Peyton moved on from this because Lucas doesn’t deserve to be fight for. But still never was a fan of Lindsey. Maybe I’m too harsh but I would have done the same Peyton did. Lindsey wasn’t just polite, she tried too much to be friend with Peyton because of that girl from the book but she forgets it’s still Lucas’ big love and the friendship is not something you can get by pushing is way too much. All the « just know that I’m here » and stuff like that is too cringy to me, sound so fake and unrealistic. and I can see why everyone see the bitchy side of Peyton but I see it as another angle. You have to be really in love, to understand that point I think. Idk it’s really easy for me to understand because I relate to Peyton a lot, it’s like she is a part of me.
Enzo
2020-06-25 03:29:56 +0000 UTC
this to me seemed out of character for Peyton, she was not a bitch to Brooke and she tried to be her friend after confessing the truth and she only got bitchy when Brooke slapped her and was throwing her mothers deaths at her. Idk this season just seemed out of character of Peyton and I didn't like it. Even as a Leyton fan, Lucas is not shocking me but Peyton shocked me the first time I watched this cuz she always took the high road and became friends with Lucas, even after season 1 when they had a thing and didn't work out but she developed a friendship, even season 4 when he wanted to try to get Brooke back, she wasn't being bitchy even when she was in love with him during it. Yes I know Brooke is her best friend and she wanted her to be happy but in the past seasons no matter what situation, Peyton tried taking the high road and took being friends with Lucas rather than hatred or not having him in her life. Like Lucas wanted to be in a relationship and it scared Peyton and the moment she went back to him regretting not being with him, he got with Brooke, peyton wasn't a bitch to Brooke or mad at Lucas after, she was hurt and tried to take the high road, obviously kissed him and hurtbbrooke but the point is, to me this whole season seemed out of character with peyton attacking someone Lucas loves. The cheating between the two is not shocking lmfao
izzy
2020-06-25 03:26:51 +0000 UTC
Peyton really is so terrible in this episode. She made her choice and has to deal with it, but instead she chose to be awful to Lindsey, who did nothing other than to accidentally fall in love with a guy who is too scared to admit he loves someone else. Peyton and Lucas are the villains here, not Lindsey. Don't get me wrong, I love Leyton, but I think the way they handled their relationship this season was so awful, and it took me watching the show a few times to really see it that way, but once I realized my bias towards Leyton, I realized this whole situation was their fault.
sandrinegeller
2020-06-25 03:11:45 +0000 UTC
What Peyton has said to Lindsay and how she acted has been overboard. However, I think she showed the audience in this episode that she doesn't really feel that way about her. She actually thinks she's a great person. She knows Lindsay brings out the insecurities in her and that she acted in the wrong way. She took ownership for her mistakes and apologized. It wasn't driven by the fact that Peyton is a mean person. I can understand how people would not like her words an actions. But I think it's about truly paying attention to what she's saying and how she's feeling. There's so much history and hurt there. Just like as a Peyton fan I can totally understand that Lindsay is a great person and didn't deserve to be treated in that way. I just think it's about trying to analyze and look at things deeply and from both sides. That's all. :)
Dydra Arnold
2020-06-25 03:04:37 +0000 UTC
Wow 😳🤣🙄.
I could barely get through the reaction due to the remarks that were made. Had to pause it a couple of times, felt myself getting upset. Lmaoo
But I don’t get why people hate on Lindsay so much. She’s not saying Peyton let’s be besties. Peyton is back home and it’s a small town, why make it weird and uncomfortable being around each other when they’re going to run into one another because they’re going to be in the same social circle. Peyton doesn’t have to like her, but at the end of the day shes being petty, childish, and immature. What is the problem with Lindsay wanting to be cordial with her?
Put that anger, hurt, pain and frustration out on Lucas, not her.
I guess I’m a different breed because I handle my situations differently, so to each it’s own. 🤷🏽♀️
Tyler Powe
2020-06-25 03:00:42 +0000 UTC
For the record I will say it out loud and I know we're clearly on opposite boats on this one.....But I really don't appreciate the way Peyton is handling things. I would consider myself pretty impartial because I don't love or hate Peyton, I truly like her character in the moments, but I'm totally with Lindsey on this...I'm sorry but it's my opinion that Lindsey has done NOTHING wrong, if anything she was admirative and nice to Peyton. But Peyton has to hate her because she's with Lucas. She can be angry at Lucas but it literally has nothing to do with Lindsey I can't understand at all why Peyton stirred up some shit with a girl that clearly loves Lucas sincerely, what did she do wrong. And what did Lindsey ever do to her? For Peyton to overtly do and say what she does? I know you're a Peyton fan and honestly it's my opinion this sorta clouds your vision, coz if you looked at the actual picture very impartially you would see things screwed up with the way Peyton is acting, not the other way around
Lucas
2020-06-25 02:51:12 +0000 UTC
Sorry, but Peyton was a bitch for telling Lindsey that Lucas proposed to her with the same ring. I absolutely hate that Peyton did that. And honestly Peyton’s been an overall bitch to Lindsey. I feel bad for Lindsey because all she’s taken is Peyton being mean to her, Lucas cheating on her, and she was also claustrophobic which means her feelings were heightened as well. Peyton crossed a line in this episode. Period. And no Lindsey shouldn’t have said those things, but she lashing out as well.
Rubi Moon
2020-06-25 02:44:40 +0000 UTC
I have a lot of issues with Peyton this episode, I get that she’s upset about her and Lucas being engaged but it doesn’t give her the right to be a total bitch to Lindsay.
Claudio Cristovao
2020-06-25 02:33:15 +0000 UTC
her and paul got divorced a long time ago he’s married to someone else now
fry
2020-06-25 02:17:08 +0000 UTC
that was way too much. I can’t stand the way Lindsey just think she knows everyone because she is a nice saint girl that knows the characters from the books, she wants to be friend with everyone & that’s freaking weird especially with Peyton, I would have reacted the same because she basically said to Peyton she was there for her but like ????? she met her like 3 minutes ago that sound really cringy and fake
Enzo
2020-06-25 02:16:25 +0000 UTC
Juli did you know Nanny Carrie is the wife of Paul Wesley(AKA Stefan Salvatore from TVD) Well now ex wife.. lol You remember her from TVD when she played Dr.Meredith for two seasons right? i don't know if we've ever touched on that forgive me if this is rehash lmao
Lucas
2020-06-25 02:15:44 +0000 UTC
OKAY HERE WE GO THIS EPISODE IS SO GOOD !! can’t wait to watch your reactions.
Enzo
2020-06-25 02:12:03 +0000 UTC
I know there's four season left but IM GONNA MISS THESE REACTIONS. IM SO REWATCHING AFTER lmfao
izzy
2020-06-25 01:50:44 +0000 UTC
Do you mean that I hate Lindsey? Bc I don’t
JuliDG
2020-06-25 01:50:28 +0000 UTC
I’m aware she is not mean. She really did tried and I wasn’t trying to be mean to her I do like her and I think she deserves better than be lied to
JuliDG
2020-06-25 01:49:39 +0000 UTC
Yeah that was mean. I shouldn’t have laughed either way they were both wrong. Sometimes I’m too biased towards Peyton.
JuliDG
2020-06-25 01:48:28 +0000 UTC
I don't really get all the Lindsay hate when Lucas is the real asshole in this situation
Christopher Nicholas
2020-06-25 01:41:12 +0000 UTC
the only person peyton has a right to be mean to and hate is lucas imo
fry
2020-06-25 01:36:15 +0000 UTC
i don’t understand the lindsay hate tbh i would act the same way if i tried to be nice to someone who clearly hates me for no actual reason other than i’m with a person they like, peyton was mean to lindsay and lindsay tried to be nice but peyton didn’t accept it so idk not on peyton s side on this one
fry
2020-06-25 01:34:00 +0000 UTC
Ugh. I really dreaded this. Peyton and Leyton stans have always been super harsh to Lindsey despite the fact that she tried so hard to be nice to Peyton. Peyton never gave her a chance. I thought this would be different considering you were nice about Lindsey all season but suddenly you're acting like she's the worst person alive. Sigh. It's so unfair
Asaunte
2020-06-25 00:56:26 +0000 UTC
How can you be mad that Lindsey called her bulimic right after you laughed at Peyton calling her fat? I get you love Peyton but cmon...
Asaunte
2020-06-25 00:44:43 +0000 UTC
Episode 10 ..... buckle up!!!!
Michelle
2020-06-25 00:40:42 +0000 UTC
I would have no problems if you wanted to do one more OTH episode. LOL. Can't wait for episode 10. Thanks for the binge Juli.
Dani
2020-06-25 00:25:31 +0000 UTC
Peyton and Lindsey is the love story we deserve😖 Half way through the season!! Excited for your reactions to the last 9 episodes... it’s a roller coaster lol