PRODUCE 48 Episode 10 | CONCEPT EVALS...BIG TWISTS

Hello, im a new patreon and i just finished binging your reactions for produce series, and i love them makes me feel that im not the only one who cried during the time that i watched this show. All concept songs really stood out for me especially when you got to see all their struggles, but i think the one that i vibed with the most was I AM followed by Rollin Rollin and Rumor!

For me Rumor has my heart, but I really liked Rollin performance and totally understand the 1st place. It's crazy how Sihyun had it hard being a badass and now she's in everglow which concept is kind of similar, she grew well 🥰

kawash

Urrggggg Freaking Miru..... PERFECT.

Unpopular opinion here - Rumor is my least favorite of the songs. I watched Produce48 live while it was airing, and when it blew up everywhere, it got way overplayed and referenced and it exposed more about it that just didn't work for me. No offense at all to those who like it, though. They are all good songs for sure! Also, it's sweet you're taking to Miyu. She does have a solo song in Korean, btw. It's a pre-debut single. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hYJ37-p57Rw She also has a youtube channel that Mystic lets her run called MiyuTube.

Blair (Rinzler)

I’m new to the patreon page so if I babble too much let me know & I’ll dial it back. I’ve been binging on this & your Queendom reactions since I joined. Before my rankings let me just say that I wasn’t sure how I’d feel about watching the show again post vote rigging scandal. But I’ve been able to push that aside and have really enjoyed your journey...glad I came along. I’ll also say now that I’m so much more familiar with so many of the girls it’s been even more emotional this time around! Let me preface this by saying all the performances were really good this is just me knit picking..... 1. To Reach You- so this is where my prejudice unapologetically shows through. Chaewon & Gyuri are easily 2 of my favorite idols. I kinda fell for Chaewon the minute the Woollim girls first appeared, then she sang Into The New World & I was done...& have been done ever since. I didn’t know Gyuri’s story prior to PD48 but I quickly became very “protective” of her when I realized the producers were going to exploit her story instead of celebrate her courage. I mean imagine auditioning for a kpop label, then imagine doing it on national television, THEN imagine doing it on national television, in front of a group of trainees, many of whom know your story & all of whom want the spot you may take....mind boggling if you ask me! Like most of the trainers during their rehearsal, I want to put Nako in my pocket, she just makes me smile. Along with Eun Chae & Haeyoon, Go Eun is one of my favorite participants that didn’t debut in Izone.....I can’t tell you how excited I am for Purple Kiss’s official debut, they have been killing me for months now. And Yuri...I love her voice, & her determination. 2. See you again- not necessarily my style of music but it was just so good & well.....Yiren. Also Haeyoon was one of my favorite vocalists on the show. 3. Rumor-it was a great performance! Eunbi is a pros pro! I must admit I’m still a little salty about Chowon. Also, I read somewhere awhile ago that Sian was possibly going to debut with a group from HappyFace but haven’t heard anything lately. If someone has some info on that I’d very much appreciate it. 4. 1000%- I felt so bad for Chaeyeon...& all of them really, but my god, I actually felt her angst! The pressure she put on herself was crazy but just imagine how she must have been feeling during their rehearsals after a couple of failed attempts on competition shows...another pros pro! And Minju is so cute. 5. Rollin Rollin- it could have been a really good song but for me it just feels disjointed...can’t really explain beyond that. 6. I Am-I love this song but like others here, for me the performance fell a little short. The only reason I have it 6th is because I was expecting so much more. As I mentioned, Chaewon is my Izone bias but Yujin attacks me everyday with her over abundance of self confident charm.

Davids12345100

To Reach You is definitely my favorite. Imo, it's the only performance where the girls actually look like a real group. It looked and sounded really polished. I understand why I AM ranked so low. Sexy and cute CANNOT go together. That song, the outfits, the choreo...it gave mixed signals all along. I think Rumor is second imo. Let's meet again didn't sound good enough, it felt really generic...

Jay

This just proves that people have majorly different taste lol. My ranking would be. Song wise: 1. See You Again 2. To Reach You 3. Rollin' Rollin' 4. I AM 5. Rumor 6. 1000% And whole performance wise: 1. See You Again 2. Rollin' Rollin' 3. To Reach You 4. Rumor 5. 1000% 6. I AM

Inoue

It's so interesting for me to see how people rank songs, cause sometimes they're really similar to mine but then others are totally different from mine. For me, song wise: 1. To Reach You 2. I AM 3. 1000% 4. See You Again 5. Rumor 6. Rollin' Rollin' (lol you can totally see my song type preference) But performance wise, as in how they performed it here in this episode, not just the song + choreo alone: 1. Rollin' Rollin' 2. To Reach You 3. Rumor 4. See You Again 5. 1000% 6. I AM (oh wow I just noticed, it's basically the same as the on-site ranking)

For me: 1. Rumor (by a mile...this song is so good) 2. I AM 3. Rollin' Rollin' 4. See You Again 5. 1000% 6. To Reach You I can see why Rollin' Rollin' won though. That's a real crowd pleasing performance. Also, it's unfortunate that the I AM team seemed to have a disagreement on what the song should be--producers wanting it to be mostly cute while choreographers and stylists apparently thought it should be sexy.

Pog reaction as usual. Appreciate the sadboi and simp hours hihi #stonks. All the songs for this concept eval are really really good. This show has some really great producers. It's honestly difficult ranking these coz I love all these songs. But my ranking would be just my preference. Song-wise: 1. IAM 2. 1000% 3. Rollin' Rollin' 4. Rumor 5. To Reach You 6. See You Again PD48 Performance-wise: 1. Rumor 2. Rollin' Rollin' 3. To Reach You 4. See You Again 5. 1000% 6. IAM Lookin forward for the next episodes since we're nearing the end :( luv u Lach <3

J2dmax

Also y'all, let me know what your song rankings are below! I'd have to say for me it goes: - Rumor - I AM / See You Again - 1000% / To Reach You - Rollin' Rollin'