Once Upon A Time S1 E6 The Shepherd
Added 2021-02-28 04:59:24 +0000 UTCOur prince?
Comments
You have got to be the 1st reactor who can split the past fairytale character from the present characters in the real world. Just because Regina was the evil queen in the enchanted forest, does not mean that Henry is not her son now, and Emma is super in the wrong butting into the life of the child she gave up in a closed adoption! I cannot stand Emma for this reason. She is NOT Henry's mother. She doesnt even believe Henry about the cusrse, so she is staying, and encouraging what she herself believes is a crazy imagination of his, allowing him to disobey his real mother, why? Because she saw saw the boy she gave up and now wants him back? Way too late for that! Or because she asked Regina a question when Regina is upset from her son being missing and deffensive about her son's birth mom showing up, and actually believes that Regina doesn't love her son? I dont buy that! Emma is just being a selfish little sh** starter.
Lucile Byrd
2024-04-29 19:40:54 +0000 UTCYep!
Heidi Elizabeth Marcum
2021-05-23 23:37:14 +0000 UTCI never caught that about them not calling him by name, very clever!
Jessie Dobbie Reactions
2021-05-23 20:19:36 +0000 UTCThe Shepherd- Thank you so much for another fantastic reaction for Once Upon a Time, Jessie!!! I really enjoyed your reaction for another of my favorite episodes from season one too. So many twists and they're brilliant!! First, here is a little information on Charming's name... Charming's mother never actually spoke her son's name at all throughout the episode. She actually only ever calls him "my darling boy", or something to that effect. Nor does King George or Rumplestiltskin. The only time a name for him is spoken throughout this episode... is when King George and King Midas calls him by the name that belonged to his twin brother, the Prince who died. James. When Charming agreed to King George's and Rumple's agreement to pretend to be his brother, Charming takes on the role of Prince James, pretending to be his brother in a ruse to con King Midas for his gold for the sake of George's kingdom. Charming doesn't wish to be a part of it, but then George darkly threatens to kill Charming's mother and to destroy their farm if he refused. So he becomes Prince James, as he's pretending to be when he first meets Snow and therefore introduces himself to her as James. Charming's true actual name, which will be somewhat cleared up in a very strange, yet entertaining kind of way in future episodes, is not actually revealed yet. I just won't say which episodes to avoid spoilers. For now... you can call him simply Charming like Snow White calls him in the Enchanted Forest upon giving him this nickname, and in Storybrooke... he's David Nolan. Now... I absolutely love the scenes between Charming and Rumplestiltskin, who is always brilliant, and the scenes between Charming and King George, who I love to hate. We have this episode's biggest twist when Prince James is killed, and we learn that he had a twin brother no one knew about except for Rumple himself, and of course the twins' parents. Not even Charming knew he had a brother, since they were babies when Rumple made the deal with his parents to save them and their farm. I love each of these interactions... between Rumple and King George, as well as Rumple and Charming before he becomes Prince James. I absolutely love this big twist with Charming having a twin brother, and seeing how Charming comes from being just a shepherd to rising up a Prince. Brilliant! :) As for why Rumplestiltskin made a deal with Cinderella for her first born child back in the fourth episode, The Price of Gold... it's so Rumple could make deals with people in such a way as he had done with King George within this episode. When George asks Rumple to procure him and his wife a child when he learned they couldn't conceive a child of their own, Rumple every now and again makes deals with other parents in exchange for their children. This is only one reason for Rumple making deals in exchange for children. Other reasons will become clear in later seasons. Robert Carlyle is always brilliant in his acting of Rumplestiltskin, as well as Mr. Gold, both characters who have their hands in pretty much everything that goes on in our characters' lives. Both in the Enchanted Forest and in Storybrooke too. He's very clever and conniving, and like I stated before... he has a reason for doing everything he does. Then, Rumple and King George convinces Charming to take on this ruse for King Midas so that George's kingdom will be replenished and so that Midas will give King George all the gold he desires. And yet Charming isn't meant to kill the dragon himself, only to pretend to have done so while George's men go into the cave to do so for him, seeing as he's nothing more than a shepherd. Little does anyone realize how good Charming is and how skilled he is at being a shepherd, as he charges in to try to protect the men's lives, then soon slays the dragon himself despite what everyone believed him to be capable of. I love how brave he is, and while the graphics like you pointed out might not always be so great due to this show having a low budget overall, I really love this battle between Charming and the dragon. The sets themselves are quite spectacular, and the graphics for the most part are pretty good. Even if they're not... I can easily look past the graphics, or green screen effects that aren't so good because I love this show, its storylines, music, and especially its characters so much. Now... I feel that my favorite scenes throughout this episode are definitely those between Charming and his mother. I love your thoughts regarding Ruth (Charming's mother) paying the price for her deal with Rumple so many years earlier that cost her the first of her twins, now causing her to lose her second twin son as well. You are absolutely right. And it's so, so sad. Such a tender and heartbreaking moment as they say goodbye to one another, as Charming is forced to agree to George's demands in order to protect his mother. She's so sweet and loving, and I love that she gives her son her ring and states that it will lead him to his true love, which it does as we see in the end when it shows Snow waiting in the tree as the royal carriage with Charming and Abigail drive past, leading into the beginning of Snow White's and Prince Charming's love story shown in Snow Falls. I also really love how Charming's mother tells him that she shared True Love with his father, and with him as his mother. So beautiful. And I love the beginning scene with him and his mother when she's trying to set him up with another woman, then his mother gets upset with herself for trying to set her son up in a marriage she knows he would never be happy in. These scenes show how much she truly loves her son, and how close she and Charming are with one another. As far as why Charming states they can't be together... it is purely out of fear that he will come to be guarded at all times upon taking on the role of the Prince and now being engaged to Midas' daughter, that George would have his mother killed and their farm destroyed, just as George threatened to do should Charming refuse to play the role of his son. It's tragic and I hate that they can't be together any longer. Next... I enjoy this show's take on King Midas, as well as seeing that Kathryn, whose true name is Abigail in the Enchanted Forest and is Midas' daughter, is sweet and kind, while Abigail is quite the opposite. And yet, there's more to her than meets the eye. And in his own fairytale, King Midas is known as the man with the golden touch. A man cursed to turn everything his hand touches into gold. It sounds great at first, but the price of this magic is steep. And I absolutely love the parallels between Charming and Abigail being brought together within the Enchanted Forest, to David and Kathryn being together in Storybrooke in the false belief that they're actually married, yet struggling to connect. It's absolutely brilliant! As for the present day storylines... First, with David and the windmill when he sees it in Gold's shop... Because Charming was unconscious upon being severely wounded when the curse fell over them, in Storybrooke he's found in a coma and once he awakens, the curse hasn't affected him fully yet because of his unconscious state as the curse reformed everyone's memories, including his. Just as Henry has figured out. That's what the curse has done for everyone from the Enchanted Forest brought over into Storybrooke within the curse, except for Regina because she's the one who cast it and created a way to keep her own memories intact. The curse alters everyone's memories... taking pieces from everyone's true lives and manipulating them in such a way so that everyone is truly miserable, and everyone's happy endings are simply gone. For David... because he was briefly engaged to Princess Abigail in the Enchanted Forest, the curse made both him and Kathryn believe that they're married in their cursed lives here in Storybrooke. However, that they are also in a rocky marriage. But then again, because David was unconscious when the curse hit him, his false memories didn't work on him like they instantaneously did for everyone else. He simply has no memories of anyone or anything whatsoever. Which is why he is confused by his true love for Mary Margaret, who he is really married to like we saw from Charming's and Snow White's wedding shown in the Pilot episode, and his false love for Kathryn he can't remember. Until of course Regina leads David to Gold's shop, where she has neatly put the windmill into place to help implant the false memories permanently within David's mind, so that he will remember feelings for Kathryn he never actually had. The windmill being a symbol of the false love David and Kathryn shared for one another. The windmill is definitely used to help trigger his false memories memories. In a sense to hypnotize David in a sense so that the false memories can flood through his mind like they have for everyone else. I know this isn't really explained in the show very well, so I thought I would try to explain what I feel it might have been done to David. I hope all of this makes sense to you. Also... in case you didn't recognize the unicorn mobile hanging up in Gold’s shop that drew David’s eyes, making him feel drawn to admire it... it is the same mobile that once hung up in Emma’s nursery above her bassinet inside their castle before the curse swept everyone away. It was meant to be for Emma, although she never got to spend more than a few moments in their castle or in her nursery, before Charming put her into the wardrobe to save her from the curse. David felt some feeling of familiarity with the mobile, until he shrugged them off the moment Gold interrupted as he teased David’s true self by uttering “Charming”, then immediately goes on to say that he meant the mobile to be charming and delicately crafted. As for the end scene between David and Mary Margaret once he remembers his false memories and then comes to find her down by the troll bridge... this scene was beautifully acted by both Ginnifer Goodwin and Josh Dallas, and you can feel Mary Margaret's heart shatter upon being crushed when David tells her he wants to do right by Kathryn. And to be honest... I'm not so sure which is worse... for him to break Mary Margaret's heart, or Kathryn's heart. It's crushing either way. Because Kathryn doesn't deserve this anymore than Mary Margaret does. But oh... I just felt so bad for Mary Margaret. David too. It is wrong that David led Mary Margaret on, but he didn't intend to hurt her. He was very truthful about how he feels about her. Their relationships are definitely complicated. As for the scene between Emma and Sheriff Graham... it's meant to help make you feel there's something more going on between Emma and Graham, which explains why she's angry over his deception and him having sex with Regina while Henry's asleep in the house and having to work the night shift. Emma has been slowly opening herself up to him, more so than she's ever opened up with anyone in some time, which is why she's really so upset. I suspect she's slowly starting to have feelings for him, so she's more angry with him for learning that he's been having a toxic affair with the woman who Emma has come to hate ever since her arrival in Storybrooke because Regina has done nothing but try to make hers and her son's lives miserable. And lastly... we have the end scene between Mary Margaret and Dr. Whale. I do not like them together. And I got so frustrated when he asked if he could buy her a drink, and she said that he could buy her two. Clearly, this leads us to believe something more might happen between them and yikes... they are not good together whatsoever. Overall... I love this episode and I loved getting more of a brilliant backstory with Charming and his twin brother, Prince James. I also enjoy David's constant pursuit of Mary Margaret, as he struggles to convince her that he wants to be with her, not Kathryn, even though it all ends in tragedy. I love how he states that he never chose Kathryn, only the man he couldn't remember had because he never was him. He was only ever a man who loves Mary Margaret and is drawn to her because they are one another's True Loves. The twists are great and the acting is top notch. Thank you so much!!! I can't wait for more, so until next time... Sincerely, Heidi
Heidi Elizabeth Marcum
2021-05-23 04:48:45 +0000 UTCDefinitely! Not only was it a TV show, but it was on ABC or some thing right? It’s not like they had an HBO Game of Thrones budget in 2010! Lol
Jessie Dobbie Reactions
2021-03-27 21:51:30 +0000 UTCA lot of people also give this show crap over the special effects and I tend to get so lost in the story, I don't notice that much (and I don't think they are that bad anyway). But the costumes and the music (notice how each character has their own theme song?) make up for any lack what people consider dramatic special effects. It is a TV show after all and they have 8 days per episode to whip them out. I think they do pretty good with what they are given.
Keebles
2021-03-27 21:16:43 +0000 UTC
