Help me pick a limited spooky series!

Not me. It's in my top 10 list and I didn't vote for it. It ain't scary.

David

Everyone who has watched DARK will vote for this series!

Metehan

Doesn't look good for WWDitS. Hill House started out interesting and turned into a yawner.

Josh G

Just remembered that October is the perfect month to watch the BLADE movies!

Roland

You have to do dark guys it’s amazing 😭😭😭don’t sleep

Che Arnold

Do Scream Queens 🤣

Ben Wheeler

The first season Of Hill House was good, The second not so much,

The Heathen Jay

discovery is our most basic drive mate.

Cripkie

The way they incorporate lines from -redacted- from the book into other parts of the show was fantastic.

Nicholas Hentges

Because spooky not moody.

Nicholas Hentges

If you do only 1 season, you should really do Lovecraft Country. The show as been canceled so no worry for miss the rest. And it's so freaking good!!!!!!!!

Daniel Vezina

I keep voting for the ones in second place. Oh, well. At least I'll get to know about shows I haven't watched before.

Molly K

Lovecraft Country is so good!

Axl Jones

those who have watched dark will know its the best outta the bunch

AO

Dark is amazing though not necessarily spooky… is a must watch

Gomi

In regards to What We Do In The Shadows, movie first, then show (both excellent). Really doesn't need to be part of Natmares though, could be viewed at any time during the year. It's FAR more comedy than horror.

Brian Jones

The Haunting of Hill House is a brilliant show but I suggest you watch its second season as well - The Haunting of Bly Manor. It's a brilliant season and you will probably like it.

Navjot Singh

Why not True Detective Season 1?

Joseph Didiano

So you never watch the twilight zone while growing up? Damn. You’re really young

Philip

Love Dark but Hill House is more appropriate for the spooky season.

Dooly

As others have said, Dark is not spooky, so I went with Hill House, even though Dark is by far the best of the shows listed.

Cristian Pires

Dark is not scary, but is the best from those for me. I voted Hill House for this poll

Victor Radoi

I was hoping you’d do hill house it’s such a great show, so pumped just to see it up here!

Ryan S

What We Do In The Shadows is great, but you need to watch the film first, it establishes the tone.

Sinewmire

It really was one of a kind. So sad it was cancelled too. 😭 I’d definitely love to watch it again and am interested to see Nat’s reaction to it.

AshicallyMe

Dark is not "spooky." I mean, the premise starts out that way, but it quickly is not.

Nathan Dickson

Dark is an amazing show. But not a spooky show. So I picked Hill House.

David

Slasher ?? new story every season so

Brandon Jensen - May the force be with you

I like Dark, but she would have to watch 3 seasons of it or she would go crazy. Plus it needs a few viewings to understand the story, I think

Christopher Boscarino

Don't know Haunting Hill, but I hope that What We Do in the Shadows will win nonetheless. Because: hilarious vampire comedy!

Laro

Hill House if you're looking for spooky but What We Do in the Shadows is probably the best comedy on TV right now. Holy shit do yourself a favor and watch it at some point.

Mike Api

I am sad it isn't going to win. It was a phenomenal show to experience.

NobleSon32

Hill House is AWESOME

Aman Jaiswal

Can we describe them by TITLE, please, and not by spoiled wrist ending?

Eric Janssen

Wheres the love for What we do in the shadows!!!!!???? She’s gonna be scared all month with y’all movie suggestions. Let her have SOME laughs!!!

Hippyjosh

Hey Natalie! You really should watch Band of Brothers. It's a war series containing only 10 episodes. It's concidered one of the best short series ever made. really captures the second world war on a personal level and the comradeship between the soldiers of the 101st Airborne.

SebastianTheCourtious

What We Do in the Shadows is a romp to enjoy in ANY season! They aren't Vampyres just in October! I suspect you will fancy the show as i have. The same title started as a short film, and then a feature -- both set in New Zealand. The TV series in my opinion is the very best of the brilliance, but the feature would make an outSTANDing NatMare watch!

—thoughtstorms—Keith—

The Haunting of Hill House is an incredible show from beginning to end and for being a horror type show it's also incredibly emotional.

Kayla

Joe D. MacGuffinstuff

Honestly if Hill House hadn't been on the poll Dark would have gotten my vote.

BJ Stephens

Big ups for the Penny Dreadful nod, underrated show.

BJ Stephens

really shouldn't post info like that about the ep, kinda takes away from discovering it yourself.

BJ Stephens

I wouldn't bother, it's rather meh, especially compared to some of the shows already in the poll.

BJ Stephens

The second season is pretty good, but Hill House is incredible, I've watched it 3 times, once was enough for Bly imo.

BJ Stephens

brb gonna go buy stock in tissues before Nat reacts to Haunting of Hill House

Vincent Valentin

I'm glad Haunting of Hill House is winning. But for you in particular, I think you would enjoy the "2nd" season even more, so I hope that gets on your watchlist as well at some point.

tezster

It's not a popular show for reactions I'm assuming because of the direction season 2 takes, but it really is a fantastic show, and I wish more YT reactors would watch it.

tezster

I'm glad Dark isn't winning, it's a complete story planned and executed in 3 seasons... and not a spooky show... Odd one in the bunch... it's an awesome show though..

Krystal

The crow could be a good Natmares movie, just saying....

Daniel Vezina

Can I do a right in for season 1 of Westworld? Please? I guess not.

Cody Steele

The haunting of Hill House is amazing... But I'm honestly not sure you can take it Natalie. So I gave a vote for Lovecraft country as a backup. Good luck!

Cody Steele

Nat, if you choose Hill House, you're going to be bawling your eyes out. It's scary but it's sad too.

Zack Stewart

You should consider Stephen King's Rose red. It's like a 3 episode miniseries, and I vaguely remember it as a spooky movie, but not TOO terrifying.

devin flynn

Hannibal is also a great spooky series. At times, it feels like it could be an HBO show, and it should have been, but it's pretty dark and scary for a major network show.

Joe Blankenship

Love Haunting of Hill House so I'm very excited that it's winning. I've been looking for a reason to rewatch it & now I have one 😁.

Anthony Willis

Dark is so fantastic. I bet if it were in English it’d get more love. It’s not really scary though.

Travis

One of the most underrated tv shows ever was "The River" it got cancelled really fast but so spooky, anyone else enjoy "The River" tv series?

Baron

Dark is fantastic, but it's very hard to follow on the first watch. There's just so many names to remember.

Lorenzo Turner

You should watch DARK some other time as well. Amazing show whose creators were given more Netflix money to create another upcoming series (1899) based upon the success of DARK. Only concern would be if you watched it dubbed over the original German. Idk if you would have an issue watching with subtitles but it should be watched in German to get the most out of it.

SillyWolf

Can’t really pick a bad series there…Hill House might be a better reaction series. Idk

Charlie Keeler

Hill House is 10 of the best episodes of any series I have ever seen. I’m not sure you can handle it lol but if it wins I can’t wait to see the reactions…

SillyWolf

Nat, stock up on tissues if Hill House wins....

My Randomology

The only thing I recognize is the Twilight Zone.

Doug Watson

I'm not familiar with any of these but haunted of Hill House sounds awesomely terrifying 😅

Ahadi Gitau

YES

Dave M.

I agree!!!!!

Dave M.

You obviously don't watch enough vids or read the comments Carlos, resuming November.

Paul G

YESSSSS!! So happy about The Haunting of Hill House. I hope it wins the poll. 😈

Dave M.

What does that have to do with Horror month?

WackySwacky

I know it’s not a horror movie per say but I’d love to see you react to Shutter Island with Leonardo DiCaprio if you haven’t or have seen it before !!

Morgan Mccallion

Where’s X-Men First Class?

Carlos Aranda

LC sort of has a definitive ending. Doesn't really need a season 2. But anyway I thought it was a mixed bag. Can't say I'm sad it got canceled.

WackySwacky

Didn't HBO axe it, did it finish at a ending of sorts?

Paul G

There is a real chance we end up with an empty chair and Nat under the couch though.

Paul G

I'd love for her to watch those in October! I watched them not expecting much, but then ended up loving all 3

Matt Adams

Can we make “Fear Street” on Netflix an option?

Valentin torres

Hill house is actually terrifying. And that's coming from a horror fan. But it's also a fantastic story, so it definitely has my vote

collegeguy6377

Hill House is such a good well rounded show. Fantastic story, I will always recommend!! Can't wait!

Angel

What we do in the shadows (my vote) isn’t really scary, but it’s freaking hilarious! It’s pretty dark humor tbh, but it still might be a nice break from being scared every time you watch something lol

Chris Moon

Looks like Hill House has a commanding lead…get ready to grab some tissues, Nat.

Casey Walker

Twilight Zone is an any time show. Even the "bad" episodes are worth watching...

Cory Silver

Surprised you haven’t seen it yet, Dyko. Surprised the heck out of me. Masterful storytelling and cinematography!

Dante

Would love you to watch brand new cherry flavour. It’s sooooo weird and eerie

Ross Stewart

OMG Natalie NEEDS to watch Haunting of Hill House. She is going to LOVE it.

Dante

I voted Hill House, Lovecraft Country, and WWDITS. There are a couple of points in WWDITS where you might get a reference from the movie, but if not you won't know you missed anything.

Kevin Mowery

Movies, I recommend the conjuring series ♥

Jayson Phillips

Haunting of Hill House is amazing, just don't watch it right before bed Nat!

David Spriggs

What We Do In The Shadows is ABSOLUTELY incredible, though a wee bit less spooky. If you like Taika Waititi, you will love it.

Maxwell Hunter

If Lovecraft Country doesn't win, definitely save it for BHM of next year!

AshicallyMe

Dark feels like a thing you would have to complete from what i've seen of it. Still good though

Kelvin

The movie is so great. I've wanted to watch the show for a while now.

WackySwacky

Yes i totally agree, such an genius and fantastic show, very disappointed that it won't win😔

Mannou B

Hill house, lovecraft country, and what we do in the shadows are all incredible!

XadeChronos

Yeah, but…hate the John Landis segment all you want, it’s the only part of the Movie that actually RESEMBLES the classic series, while Spielberg, Joe Dante and George Miller were goofing it up.

Eric Janssen

Honestly any of these except Lovecraft Country. I've heard nothing but good things about Hill House so my vote is for that.

WackySwacky

I voted for The Twilight Zone mainly because it could end with a movie like Firefly does. Watch 10 episodes and then Twilight Zone: The Movie (1983). With all the voting for favorite episodes we'll all be invested in whichever ones you watch. The movie is really good, so that's a plus for a fun ending to the series.

Pete Bowers

[no spoilers here] I've said it before, and I'll say it again. Haunting of Hill House is the Godfather of ghost stories! It jumps decades (in a good story telling way). It has compelling, strained, family dynamics. A great ensemble cast. And a multi layer story that rips your heart out, says "Boo" to it, stuffs it back into your chest cavity, and stitches closed a y-incision.

Gerald Corona

Don't think Dark has ever been featured in a poll on here until this one

Danishprince

She has already seen Breaking Bad before she started doing reactions so that's not possible :)

Danishprince

Haunting of Hill House is amazing!

Obie Brown

Dark is sublime

Nic Benham

Greatest television show ever made, to me anyway.

Kaden Stanton

Haunting Hill all the way...

LarryJ nyc

Hill House was beautifully haunting.

Ryan Pascall

Have not seen any of these so im curious and looking forward to any of them that we watch! Voted for Haunting of house hill since I love the paranormal.

LightsCameraJake

Hill House .......

Aman Jaiswal

The haunting of hill House PLEASE........ You'll not regret this one.

Aman Jaiswal

Evil because we know it's going to scare the poop out of her... but still good patrons because it is an amazing show and I'm sure she will love it by the time it is done.

Thomas Yanez

Twilight zone is such a good show. We really haven’t had anything near that level outside of black mirror.

James Kelly

“The Obsolete Man” also has a freaky nightmarish quality to it, but a good stinging Rod Serling message. “Come Wander With Me” is also super creepy, but takes a few viewings to figure out—Explanations on request. And how many felt like “The Midnight Sun” during the first weeks of the Lockdown? 😓

Eric Janssen

OMG Haunting is on the list, yes, yes, yes!

Ana Fox

The Twilight Zone episode called "Long Distance Call" was one of the creepiest things I watched on TV or film when I was a kid. It may have been because I loved my grandma so much and the grandmother in this episode reminded me of mine.

Ian Cano

WWDitS!

Garren Haskell

Go with the Twilight Zone, strait horror is all well and good but Existential Terror is better.

Ryan

Dark is amazing and I would have voted for it but it's an all-or-nothing deal. Watching only season 1 would be a travesty. Edit: To clarify, it would be a travesty because plotlines begin in season 1 and end in season 3.

Sean

Come on, people. What We Do in the Shadows is the obvious choice.

G. T. Blackwell

I voted for what we do in the shadows, but I would hope anyone watching it has already seen the film first.

Robert Reichle

The Obsolete Man should be included as well as Time Enough At Last.

Ryan

Voted for Hill House, because it's not even a contest.... However, I don't think Nat's seen the movie of What We Do in the Shadows. She should definitely include that in her movies for the month (as a break from the scary). Also, she shouldn't watch the series without watching the movie first....

Holly R

At least hint at why, for those of us who've seen it?

Peter Yocum

Twilight Zone.

Adolfo Acosta

Can't really go wrong with any of these! Hill House is amazing, and Dark is a masterpiece... but it's a show people love or hate IMO.

JayyDTR

If you get a chance, check out a show called "Glitch" on Netflix. Fantastic show for the first season or two.

Jeffrey Haas

The movie I really want to see her reaction to is Sleepwalkers (1992). That movie is batshit insane in a glorious way!

David Sumner

Same, it got my vote. Haunting of Hill House is good and very well done as a traditional horror type of show, but LC was highly original, epic in scope, and starred Kang the Conqueror.

Peter Yocum

Dark is not a scary serie, but it's a master piece and you need to watch all the season, I hope dark wins 💚

Luis Camacho

What We Do in the Shadows is not scary at all, but it is the funniest show on television, so it gets my vote.

Robert C

"Please don't pillage me!"

Todd Sonnier

The Abominable Doctor Phibes

Daniel Ketchum

WWDITS!!! It's spooky themed but it's a mockumentary comedy. The Office with vampires

Todd Sonnier

Oh we have to do the Shatner episode!

Paul Gibbons

I wish Lovecraft Country would win 😪

Ray Riddle

Haunting of Hill house is winning... we are evil.

My Randomology

When you say The Haunting i hope you mean the 63 version as that's ace.

Paul Gibbons

After your next series, I’d love it if you considered LOST if you haven’t seen it already.

Grady Jaymes Smith

Lovecraft Country is so good guys

Ray Riddle

HILL HOUSE IS S OO GOOODDDDDDDDDDDDD

soggytacos

Dark is fantastic! But, if you only watch the 1st season you end up with way more questions than answers.

Benjamin Preston

Damn lovecraft is sooooo good and freaky, i wish i wins but it doesn't seems like it will :(

Heliastein

These are all good and I’m glad you’re likely to watch Haunting of Hill House as it’s fantastic. But Dark is easily the best show in your list, it’s the best show I’ve seen in years, an amazing and mind boggling piece of science fiction that deserves so much more recognition! Please keep it in mind for future.

Matthew Pratt

Spooky stuff not really my thing - gonna skip whatever you choose.

Anders Johansen

Haven't really watched any of these except most of Twilight Zone (old and new, Outer Limits in the same vein). Excited to see who wins

Steve J

I will say, I’d rather see more film reacts on this channel. It seems lately we’re getting TONS of TV reacts and not as many films any more. Shows just take up so much time, films are a nice simple one and done experience

mrhalfbit

I’ll not only suggest Twilight Zone, I’ll GIVE the 10 greatest episodes on request: Starting with “The Monsters Are Due on Maple Street”, William Shatner in “Nick of Time”, my annual Christmas sobs to “Night of the Meek” and “Changing of the Guard” (😭), the set-up twist of “Five Characters in Search of an Exit”, and the chillingly prophetic COVID metaphor of “The Old Man in the Cave”. (Yes: A little taste of the days when Classic TV was about EPISODES, not “shocking season-arc finales”.)

Eric Janssen

The Haunting of Hill House, followed by What We Do In The Shadows movie... then TV series? 😀

Marc Ammundsen

Hill house is a no-brainer. Not only does it have great writing and great performances, the filmaking is a technical masterpiece. So many great panning and following long takes. Episode 6 is 5 one takes. You should definitely watch The Making of Episode 6 Featurette after you finish the season.

Jeff Szymanowski

What we do in the shadows is HILARIOUS! If it doesn't win at least watch the movie!

Christopher French

Honestly really hard choice. I voted for What We Do in the Shadows but I’m not opposed to rewatching Hill House, or at least my favorite couple of episodes.

Jason Gillman

Hill House is amazing. What we do in the Shadows is still worth watching, but that's more comedy. Maybe to calm down from Hill House.

Wilhelm Keidel

"The Haunting of Hill House" will probably scare the pants off you, and yet be one of the most rewarding television experiences you've ever had. You may think that you know what this show is, but you don't. But, that's okay, because nobody else who watched it did, either.

Thomas Yanez

The Hunting, i want her to freak out

Ariel Conde

YES to What we do in the shadows. Might wanna see the movie first

Tiger Chu

I've never commented before. What we do in the shadows is the greatest shown in TV history.

Ruben Sanchez-Alvarez

Hi Nathalie! I hope you're doing well 💛 I was wondering if you could react to Venom. I think it's the only sony/mcu film you have not seen yet! Venom is a character from the marvel comics under sony just like Tom Holland's Spider-man. Also, Venom 2 will be released within a few weeks so it would be nice to hear what you think about it! Have a nice weekend 💛

Len

Also, in general, I would suggest anything by Mike Flanagan. He has a very “Stephen King” feel for horror

Richard Welch

I absolutely loved Lovecraft Country. Episode 3 is probably the scariest thing I have ever seen tbh.

NobleSon32

PLEASE what we do in the Shadows at some point!

mrhalfbit

I've been meaning to watch What We Do in the Shadows anyway, so that's what I picked.

Joe Blankenship

The haunting of hill house was FANTASTIC I can't wait to see how you react to it!

john collins

Absolutely voting for the Haunting of Hill House.

damage3245

Geeze, this is a tough one because you should honestly watch all of the above. I did go with What We Do in the Shadows just for laughter's sake. Dark is a close second, but it really should be watched in German, and it's hard to follow at first between multiple characters thrown at you, and dealing with subtitles took me a while (shortish attention span me), but damn what a great show. And the Twilight Zone is so classic that select episodes are a MUST watch. I'd also add Penny Dreadful in the mix if you've never seen it. Great show.

Tony Sanson

This show is sooo amazing!!! But never seems to win any polls

codenamewitch xx

Ugh looks like Dark won’t win but it is such a fantastic show!! I highly recommend to all of you who haven’t watched

codenamewitch xx

Can I just put another idea your way some of the early X Files episodes are very creepy like first season TOOMBS and ICE

RebRox65

Oh I COMPLETELY agree with this! Its SOOO good!

Lisa Tosti

This is a poll I've been waiting so long for. Hill House is one of my top favourite series. Going into it I was a bit skeptical and was nervous it was going to ruin the original story for me. But Mike Flanagan and the entire cast do such an amazing job that I've probably watched this almost ten times already and it never gets old. It's got a few great jump scares but the story telling and the cinematography are absolutely breathtaking.

Ryan Nielson

Great choices, it was hard to pick! What We Do in the Shadows would be a nice gentle (and hilarious) intro to the spooky season, but Hill House is a great scary choice. I personally thing Bly Manor is a better intro to the anthology series, and is more moody spooky than scary spooky--very Gothic horror--but mileage may vary based on what you want in your horror. Those looking for solid scares will like Bly Manor less, but if you like the atmospheric romantic aspect of spooky stories, it's a excellent show!

Christopher Cifani

OMGOSH if we end up going to Hill House, then we've GOTTA visit Bly Manor next, we just gotta!

Mister Lou

What We Do in the Shadows is funny. Very funny.

Baron Imhoof

I love twilight zone, but not all the best episodes are "spooky".

Christopher Boscarino

Haunting of hill house is great. Would love to see The boys after spooky season

Jerry Gonzalez

Hill House is definitely the most rewarding out of all of these. Watch out for the tears though. I see them starting about episode four. Episode five if you’re strong.

Richard Welch

I'm torn Lovecraft Country and Hill House. I loved Lovecraft Country, but I'm not sure if Natalie would enjoy it (can't say why because spoilers). On the other hand there's the racism history element that I think more people should know about. I've never seen Hill House and have heard good things about it and would love to watch it with Natalie.

Graht1

You should check out the new Netflix Sabrina series. It's a wild ride with a pretty cool world to get lost in.

Sixstringaxis

Please pick What We do in the Shadows, Miss Natalie. Hearing you laugh is like music to my ears and this series would produce a symphony.

Ragnar Miersch

The signpost up ahead. Your next stop The Natmares Season.

Darryl Low

I voted for Twilight Zone but you should check out Brand New Cherry Flavor. It’s a recent limited series and, IMO, one of the best things Netflix has ever done.

Aaron

Please do dark at some stage it's a phenomenal show

Owen James McBrearty

I do hope you react to the other seasons of Stranger Things one day! (and maybe throw in S1 for good measures anyway;) )

Danishprince

Never seen any of these except What We Do in the Shadows and The Twilight Zone. That said, I think you'd probably want a break from the actual scary so the spoopy comedy show is probably your best bet.

The Golgothan

That was a tough one, as they are all good. I went with Lovecraft Country.

UngawdlyJish

There was another series by Rod Serling that was scarier than Twilight Zone. Night Gallery it ran from 1970 to 1973. It's on NBC and Amazon.

Wesley Eskildsen

You can never go wrong with ‘The Twilight Zone’, but I know it won’t win.

Danny Miller

For scares, Hill House. For laughs, What We Do in the Shadows.

Jomero

hill house 100% its only one season anyway and its fantastic i know you will find it fascinating nat it will make you jump yes but at least no zombies lol

Ian

Please please please be what we do in the shadows!!

Nexus6

Hill House is best for the season, but my god is What We Do in the Shadows funny. I haven't laughed as hard at anything in a while.

Śéáń

My best friend loved "Lovecraft County" so I voted for that. Just haven't gotten up the energy to watch yet - I'm hooked on DC's Doom Patrol!

This_Jedi_crafts

"The Haunting of Hill House" got my vote on this. 😊 I really enjoyed that one. And since "The Haunting" is one of my favorite movies, it was interesting to see a different take on the familiar characters.

Randee Carreno

Gotta be hill house. And completely ignore the shit sequel series, Bly Manor

ButtyOh

Lovecraft Country is amazing but it does feature a level of gore and nudity far above anything else in the poll. A lot of its scares come from the gross out factor. Hill House to me is the best and most scary of these selections.

Frankie Crews

Haunting of Hill House is an amazing series. Dark is also amazing. Lovecraft Country is gory but not especially spooky or scary .

Ben Violette

FFS, y'all suck...sigh

WellNo

I've heard good things about Haunting of Hill House, but I've been itching to rewatch Lovecraft Country, especially after seeing Jonathan Majors and Wunmi Wasaku in Loki.

Tony Johnson

It's not really Halloween like but you definitely should watch Dark in the future though.

THE LORE!!!

What We Do In The Shadows is hilarious. Same kind of humor as in Thor: Ragnarok. Same writer/director.

Nick of Time

Haunting of hill house. This is an easy choice

Louis Melendez

What we do in the shadows is the best

Def should watch the What We Do in the Shadows movie first. It’s not necessary, but I think it’s a good introduction.

Jesse Arnold

What we do in the shadows!

Christian Fierro

Dark!!!!

Hrayr Azizyan

I did Lovecraft country, both book and show last year with the Nerdist Bookclub and.... no spoilers but it fizzles a bit. What we do in the Shadows is better

Nathan Swapp

Lovecraft Country is a FANTASTIC horror show that has supernatural/sci-fi elements while the characters are also struggling with the horror of white supremacy in the Deep South of mid-20th century America! Highly recommend! Plus the actor from Loki who played He Who Remains is the main character and his acting is so much better in that season of Lovecraft Country than what he gets to show off in Loki.

Lil B

I really wish you would do American Horror Story, I feel like that would be right up your alley 😁😁😁

Jayson Orlando

What We Do In The Shadows but you should watch the movie first! If you haven’t already seen it of course.

Neverender

If you want something real spooky watch Chernobyl

Tyler Boyle

Have you seen the what we do in the shadows movie yet? That could be a fun October watch

Rey

Watch Breaking Bad ! 😭😭

Sunnyd1200

Hill house!! One off the best horror shows ever

Gustavo Rodrigues

What we do in the shadows is soo funny.

Alex Lerma

DARK!!!!!

ISeeTrees ofGreen