$4k Milestone Show Slot Poll!!

Could you add the Monogatari Series on the next pool? Its a really amazing show and my second favorite of all time right after Code Geass:)!

Irimu

They haven't and that's good! There are so many things that they still need to watch and Re; Zeros priority level isn't that high.

Irimu

You guys haven't watched re:zero yet right? O_o

I somehow missed this poll. :(

Irenesharda

Yessss Ancient Magus Bride!!!!!

Life Legacy

yay made in abyss in 2nd place! :) with just 2 vote vs ancient magus

Charles Casem

Well, I totally want to see you guys watch Berserk eventually, but given these votes it seems like an underdog for now. Maybe later!

Ace of Blades

Only reason why I didn't vote for Your Lie In April is because I don't want to cry again along with two grown men.

Alistair Dreamer

Love Your Lie on April and love Death Parade - especially DP's opening!

miss_hopefulsnail

Quite a few good shows on the list. I hope Made in Abyss is able to compete against Death Parade.

hokidori

I'm sad that it looks like Showa Genroku Rakugo Shinju won't win the poll this time. Though I guess it isn't too surprising since no one has seen it really. I really hope they get around to it one day though.

Add Shokugeki no Souma in the next poll pleaseeee!! :3

JManuelRM

Damn, the Made in Abyss and Ancient Magus are in a tough fight in poll

Charles Casem

I'm surprised that Parasyte is not on the list😭

Clear Lime

Is there a place where I can post recommendations? There’s a great short series I’d like to recommend SOS, and others to watch. Whether it’s reacted to or not. I noticed Zankyou No Terror (Terror in Resonance) was not on the MAL.

Lil Bit

I'm amazed that Showa Genroku Rokugo Shinju is even on the poll, but it doesn't stand a chance. That's the best series that no one has seen.

Silver Bard Games

I'll just choose something both of you haven't seen. It's more interesting that way. Can't wait to see more of your reactions.

Lazy_Scorpio

Ohh...totally forget to mention Orange

Morten Eland

Other great, short shows, that I didn't see on your my anime list, I think is worth checking out is plastic memories and miss kobayashi's dragon maid

Morten Eland

YOU DEFINITELY SHOULD WATCH “Tokyo ghoul”

Man your lie in april is not getting alot of love in the comment section. To bad you have already watched madoka magica...would have loved to see your reaction to that

Morten Eland

I would highly recommend for you to do steins;gate in one of your reaction series.

GodShatteringStar

I suggest you to consider Gyakkyou Burai Kaiji for next poll. It is the show about mind games and gambling. And it is the best one.

Rivory

I think Made in Abyss has to be watched at some point, its too good a show to be passed up and is still fresh in everyone's minds. Especially since it exploded in popularity after the anime aired. The Ancient Magus's Bride is also amazing but it has a following even before the anime and will come up again in the future. Hence do Made in Abyss! XD

Ashalesth

I know this would be odd but I would have loved the option to possibly have a extra day dedicated to more longer shows like Jojo for example

Fing3rP0P

Just a suggestion, but you could also do double Haikyuu eps XD

ugh

Tony

Death Parade is fun.

RemnantRyku

okay 3 more vote guys for Made in Abyss and it will tie up to the 2nd, or we will become irredeemable LOL

Charles Casem

hmm Wished Re:Zero was on this list

Norberto Rodriguez

Gonna have to go with Death Parade on this one. I would have gone with Your Lie in April if it wasn't for the fact that Jacob has already seen it. Also hope to see Zankyou no Terror (Terror in Resonance) on one of these polls these days. :)

Damn guys come on!, Let them experience Made in Abyss!! :) :) or they would become irredeemable lol

Charles Casem

Oh well, if they like Sweetness and Lightning, Barakamon for me is more engaging slice of life than Sweetness and Lightning. But hey, here for more genre of anime. Cheers!

Yeah, I'd really love to see them react to Shin sekai yori, but those 3 animes leading atm are all great, so no problem with those from my side.

Drust66

I'd love to see Noragami or Shin sekai yori (From the new world). They would have such a blast with the world building of the latter.

I second Parasyte being on future polls. I'm watching it right now and it's great! :)

SqueakyNarwhal

There's tons to react to and discuss in Berserk.

Princess Paladin

I sincerely hope you guys get around to watch Made In Abyss at some point, it is an incredible piece of work that deserves attention.

Valtivi

I have been watching Ancient Magus Bride and it is absolutely beautiful and something I think you guys could really dig into. So I voted for that. But, I also voted for Made in Abyss. I've heard nothing but good things about it and I've been wanting to watch it, so if you guys end up reacting to it, it will motivate me to finally watch it lol

SqueakyNarwhal

I suggest Kekkai Sensen or Parasyte for future polls.

Thuxhunt

possibly parasyte, or triple hxh slot or double jojo slot

Kamolak

Not a big fan of most of these, was hoping for maybe rick and morty, korra maybe, Bakuman, Akame Ga Kill, Re:Zero, Inuyashiki, or Kings Assassin

Kamolak

First 14 episodes of Sword Art Online were good. If they just stop there, then they should be fine.

Princess Paladin

Tanya not getting enough votes, yo. Made in Abyss too.

CastSenpai

you guys gotta put yuri on ice in the polls, its so different you very good too

Liam Kelly

Rakugo is kind of an underlooked show, lot of people didnt watch it when it aired. I dont expect it to win, but maybe one day it will.

RedBoi

I think it's because that Monster has 74 ep and they only want to add <25 ep anime this time

Alas. Not dying to see any of the choices this time. Guess I'll just... Choose Berserk again. But I'd rather double JoJo.

Princess Paladin

No choice for 'Monster' this time? :(

Kenju Storm

Omg THIS

Smoked Ham

So glad when I saw Showa Genroku Rakugo Shinju in the poll but then after I voted it's not even close.

Aaawww I wanted double Haikyuu to be on there..

Johanna Gustavsson

...That is a great point. Caleb does need to see those bloopers :3

Semblance of Sanity

Lucky Star: No, no, the best way to eat cake is by scraping off the frosting first, and then eating the corners of the slice, and then...

Semblance of Sanity

It's so simple, but so sweet!! As far as episodic shows go, I'd put S&L as an example of totally episodic show that is absolute gold :D

Semblance of Sanity

Forces *is* bloody amazing. Yeahhh, Caleb needs to experience Berserk.

Semblance of Sanity

Dawww, stahp it you :3

Semblance of Sanity

Why no double JoJo? When is that going to be a goal?

KingKien1

Most likely

Semblance of Sanity

You get warm and fuzzy feelings! You get warm and fuzzy feelings! EVERYONE GETS WARM AND FUZZY FEELINGS!!! -Jacob

Semblance of Sanity

Feel like Berserk is something u should watch on your own. Not really for reactions.

KingKien1

I'm so happy that Death Parade is in the lead so far, one of my favorite anime for sure and it would lead to some nice discussion as well.

Jaime Soto

Whatever you pick, I win! I love seeing your reactions to things I've already seen, but it's also very enjoyable to watch things for the first time alongside you two. I've never heard of this Death Parade so if that wins I'll be curious to see what it's all about.

Rhiannon

Sword Art Onli-... I’m joking. But I’m all seriousness Made In Abyss is really good, I’m surprised it doesn’t have more votes for it tbh

Waluigi

DEATH PARADE PLEASE! It’s concept is so creative, and powerful. Not to mention it’s short, and you guys already have quite a few long running shows going. It would be quite the refresher.

Lil Bit

While I am among those who wishes that doubling down on JoJo would be nice, I will vote for Berserk because it's just so good. if it wins will it be sub or dub? because the dub is really good.... and has those epic bloopers.

Frederick Jaskowski

Could you please add Sense8 to the poll. Its the kind of show that would go perfectly with you thought processes and discussions

Burooj Ahanger

Yeah same here, I thought Made in Abyss would win for sure :/

Zacke

I wish

August Kralovic

Pretty surprised by the dominance of Death Parade and how Made in Abyss is not winning this by a mile.

lu

Oh man you guys would LOVE Death Parade. Nice and short but incredibly powerful, and a LOT of stuff to analyze. If it wins I'll for sure be looking forward to rewatching it alongside you.

I'm not super into any of these shows, though I like them all well enough (well, actually I love Maguc Bride but for some reason it's not the type that I makes me excited for reactions about it) However, it's good to see the SS bros adding new slots.

How about an extra day for hxh ;)

Griffen

OOOHH!!! IF ANCIENT MAGUS BRIDE DOES WIN, I HOPE THEY REACT TO THE OVAs AS WELL SINCE THEY ARE CANON AND GIVE MORE BACKSTORY TO THE MAIN FEMALE CHARACTER

Janice Marie

I know it's not going to win, but I'm voting Rakugo anyway

Lord Snail the Slimy

These are simply no bad choices here. This is basically just an incredibly sweet looking line-up of very artful cakes that you'd all love to stuff into your mouth at once :D Ancient Magus Bride, Made in Abyss and Showa Genroku Rakugo Shinju would be the ones I'd be most interested in to hear your thoughts on, but anything on here is good in my book <3

You should add in Classroom of the Elite. It's a nice and short 12 episode series that I'm sure you guys would have some good discussions over.

Blasian62

same here, looks like i'll be watching whatever wins with them or end up marathoning it.

Kyle

I'd like another jojos slot, given it's so long

Kanem Magobet

Sweetness and Lightning is so amazing. It probably won't win the poll, but I highly recommend it to everyone. It hits hard in the feels.

Pumbloom

For a loooong time berserk was my favorite anime. Was a teenager when I watched it two decades ago. And at the end of it, it haunted me for a good week. Couldn't stop thinking about the events that transpired. It also has my all time favorite anime music track (Forces). Voting Berserk 97', like to see how you guys would react to it.

Pronto (SK)

For once I haven't seen any of these shows so this is super exciting!

Cody Enos

Berserk!!

Ryan H

C'mon people vote for Ancient Magus Bride or/and Made in Abyss... pls... Your Lie In April is a valid choice as well but since Jacob already saw that it's not that high on my priority list. I sadly never really got into Death Parade even though I loved the original OVA but I dropped the Anime after 3 or so episodes. It just wasn't my cup of tea for a long running concept. I guess I will give it another chance and watch it if it wins though. And tbh I would prefer it if you didn't even include shows that you're not both blind to because having someone who has already seen it rewatch it always robs me of this feeling of awe and wonder when I see someones reaction to it.

SmilePlease

Yas Yassssss!

Ryan H

My vote is Death Parade. Even if it doesn't win, I hope you revisit it later~ Don't let the opening fool you, this show is intense.

Phyllis

Man, I will vow for Saga of Tanya the Evil, I really hope you will watch that one in the future. One show I would also give you a recommendation for, that is not on this list, is Drifters, that show is just great fun.

Michael

Death Parade needs more reactors.... and what's better than to get the best reactors to watch it?

Brandz

What happened to Rick and Morty? Also can we please add a second JoJo slot. Hunter got a chance so JoJo should at least be given a chance.

Yunus Ahmed

3rd hxh episode per week! lol

GOD DAMMIT PEOPLE THEY NEED TO KNOW THE GREATNESS THAT IS BERSERK !

Are you going to be watching the sub versions?

AM1355

Not for now no, we're expanding our viewing range atm.

Semblance of Sanity

Boom, boom, boom, dancing through the skies 🎶

NobleGryphon

Absolutely enjoyed the manga of Ancient Magus Bride and The currently releases episodes are coming along stunningly - so much lore too. Really hope you give it a chance!!

Cricketmilk

Voted for Rakugo, but Death Parade is one I have wanted to watch for a while. If it wins it will be a good opportunity to watch it.

bennydelon

No JoJo choice? Without a 2nd episode per week, it will take years to get caught up. Guess I'll settle for Berserk.

Memetic Hazard

Yeah Jacob and I are really excited to see which one gets picked :)!

Semblance of Sanity

Noragami is already on our shows list, but it's not very high as of now.

Semblance of Sanity

Can I recommend something else TT? Noragami

Eren Jaeger

This is a tough one

DasFriggimon

SWEETNESS AND LIGHTNING

Jackson

Ancient magus bride LETS GO!!!

kiel

These are all great choices

Jojrre

Little sad that there's still no Kuroko no basket on here

Chimpman