Monogatari Replacement Poll

Kinda sad that every time a shounen or new hit seasonal is on a list they always get picked, at least the options this time were some of the better ones. Wish the voters would broaden their horizons on genres/choices to make it less blatantly predictable whenever a shounen or seasonal hit comes up.

Levi Blair

Nooo dude, why are all English speakers so adamant about dubs when the rest of the world prefers subs...

KaregoAt

Noooo I missed it!! Would've voted for Golden Kamuy, it's so good!! Hope it gets another chance.

KaregoAt

A bit short of time for voting, missed it. :c

Yaana

And YYH won after Ouran? awesome

Zen Reacts

Pls English Dub for Yu Yu Hakusho top 5 dub

melo

I haven't yet watched YYH but I feel like the solution is easy. Just watch the show, enjoy it, and then you'll have bros reactions to it for 2 years easy game easy life

SAL

Welp god forbid we get a good anime in that slot for 2 years and 8 weeks -.-

RussellSD

Time for the most 90s dub of all time.

Ty Arnold

Man, really wanted to see them react to Great Pretender :(

CY

Y’all better watch YYH in dub. Dub is superior to the sub

Janice Marie

Welp, see you all in 26 months for the replacement of YYH

Brandon J Ruth

Well pretender, see you next poll hopefully. (lets goooo YYH!)

Almost Pretendah...

Andres Lozano

YYH DID IT!

Rustle My Jimmies

come on, great pretender! let's go!

oosutoriajin

Let's get Great Pretender in there, a great series that needs way more love!

Irenesharda

Lets go Yu Yu Hakusho, this is super tight!

gugestein .

Yuu yuu hakusho is only one vote away

Sunny Morgans

I've been holding off watching Yuu Yuu Hakusho so I could watch it with the bros. Has the time finally come?

Raven

Yuu Yuu Hakusho is waaaay too long @_@ I prefer Great Pretender since I haven't watched it yet and it would be awesome to experience it blind with the bros

Mikon

Where the space brothers shills! Two brothers watching Space Brothers match made in heaven

KyleRuggles

Hopefully they do the Great Pretender in dub if that wins I think they did well and the show fits well with it

Andres Lozano

been shilling yu yu hakushou to the bros for 3-4 years, would love to see things come to fruition, especially since the dub is a possibility.

lancer081292

Please lord be Great Pretender

Brandon J Ruth

Trying to get more people onto YYH. If it wins they gotta use the dub.

Julio Medina

Great Pretender and Katanagatari. Both of them are such good discussion fuel!

Neutr0n

GREAT PRETENDER COME ON LETS DO THIS

bromoment1

I just voted Great Pretender because It always looked Interesting but never got around to watch it, would be fun with you.

Jason

Must be dub! I will take it no other way!

Irenesharda

If you guys do Yu Yu Hakushou (which I am hoping for you!), this is one show in which the dub must be experienced.

Cameron Utz

Katanagatari would be sick! It's not gonna win here, but at least I know it's on their list now.

Dank Bum

Man, I really want great pretender, but YYH too! And you have to do dub YYH!

Irenesharda

Omg if they do YYH I would be so happy but Great Pretender is good too 😌

xperax

I'd say check the anilist links they provided and then just vote for whichever one seems the most interesting to you then.

Marika Pauley

Don't know any anime on this list so no vote for me

Alex Jesaispas

Golden kamuy deserves it ;_;

Friendly Neighborhood Totally Not Creepy Old Man

GOLDEN KAMUY IS SO FUCKING GOOD

Loken

can i throw some suggestions in? Even if you don't consider them, I just wanted to throw them into the comments here since i would enjoy a reaction to them. Kokoro connect Symphogear Gosick Kemono no Souja Erin

Fusssel

one these days :)

Golden Kamuy please win

renren

One day Bakuman will win. One day.

Zaj

Hm the great pretender is really high in the poll and i have literally never heard if it before. Maybe I will take a look

Yuion

There are two slots on Thursdays, so you have another show too

Rustle My Jimmies

There goes every Thursday for two years :)

すもも麻子

fruit basket,.one day will be your time sweetie

lis

Oh wow a poll with something interesting... didnt expect that Going for Golden Kamuy for comedy and Yuu Yuu Hakusho because togashi. I honestly dont understand why it wasnt voted on after HxH but as long as it wins now im fine

Yuion

ik this isn’t how the tuesday slot works but it’s be perfect after run with the wind. Or hajime when they finally finish lol

Master Detective

It's a shame about Katanagatari, maybe it will do better on the next poll it appears on. I really do hope they react to it eventually, Togame is an absolute delight.

Marika Pauley

Oh man I didn’t even think of the option of sub! I automatically assumed dub since that’s how I saw and it was incredible

Kroa Mega

Dub of yuyu? Its really good

Jonathan baez

Me seeing where Fruits Basket is at and thinking it has a chance. Then seeing Yu Yu Hakusho lolll 😭

pandacat

Reading this list, at first I was thinking; “Man, this might be another close one.” Then I saw Yu-Yu Hakusho. Congrats to whoever comes second, cause I have a feeling I know the outcome of this poll.

Canadian_Caesar

Great Pretender is incredible tbh. Potential AOTY

DrWomanRespecter

Man, I would loooove to see the bros react to Great Pretender. Not a super long show and so much fun. If it wins, I'd be expecting some awesome discussions

CY

It won't ever win but... Katanagatari is a masterpiece that must be known and watched so i cast my vote on that. Sad the winner will probably be a more popular show rather than a more cult one like katanagatari

Leo

Is there a theme for this poll? haha it does seem random.. Well just wanna to recommend another oldie but goodie.. Honey and Clover =D

Ben.jajaja

Trust me... it's rather mediocre. I'd give it a 7-8, it had a 9/10 arc though

terminator6969

If the anime was actually, *animated* I'm sure it would have been a lot bigger... then again the subject matter and presentation style already cemented it as niche.

terminator6969

so sad how golden kamuy isnt winning there’s literally no good reactions for the show 😭

Ym

i havent seen any of these and dont plan to except for the great pretender im planning on watching that so i hope thats the one that wins

DodoBird25

Guess I am finally going to have to watch Yuu Yuu Hakusho... Wish Golden Kamuy was doing better, that show is much better than people give it credit for. Also still no Chihayafuru, going to bring it up in every poll until it finally gets it's rightfully deserved spot

RandomThorn

I would love to see a reaction of Great Pretender (even though it's probably not gonna win). It's a great and fun show

alex.

Yu Yu Hakusho is up there with some of the greatest dubs of all time! Lets go Chris Sabat!

I feel you! Fruits basket is so awesome, I really want them to see it.

Come on fruits basket. Ouran finally won it's poll now I just need you to win 😭

Ronnie

Ayo slap JJK on some future poll perhaps, ty ^^

Flashzie

This slot wont be open for another 2 years if yuyu hakusho wins, give the shorter shows some love.

Classic? Check. Battle shonen? Check. Winning? Check.

BeesKnees

Fruits basket lesgoooo

rrayzy

Lmao bye

DrWomanRespecter

Bakuman would be great so underrated no one ever reacts to it

Why is Yuu Yuu Hakusho even on this list? It's a damn Shonen.

TheStruggler

Katanagatari had no chance and its the best follow up to this show. What a shame.

TheStruggler

AAAAAHHHHHH Great Pretender is SOOO close!!!

DAW

Come on, Golden Kamuy! Such a good show, and so criminally underrated.

Pyrrhus65

“He says, as the show from 1992 is winning the poll”

DrWomanRespecter

This poll again shows that the recency bias is hard to fight against. R i p. Would love to see a great reaction channel react to Golden Kamuy lol.

Mojo

“Flavor of the month” LMAO yeah alright kid

DrWomanRespecter

I have a feeling the bros will like Bakuman the most, but I doubt it will win any polls so at this point i’m just hoping for a tuesday slot

shibapark

Not YYH.......... please.... the anime doesn't do most of it justice.. Much rather watching 100 eps of Gintama than this X( X( X( X(. **ALSO SECOND PLACE RN IS GREAT PRETENDER? OH GOD more flavor of the month.... it was an okay show but come on........ PLEASE GUYS get better taste X(** Voted for Bakuman at the very least the bros will learn about the industry

terminator6969

This is one of the best polls so far. Wouldn't mind any of these winning. But looking at it again,it does seem kind of unfair to put Yyh on this list. It's a completely different kind of show from all the others on the list and is a classic so it has an unfair advantage.

Shloppy

Yu Yu Hakusho has been one of my dream picks for ya'll to see for a while! Togashi tells some great stories! Hope it wins but I wouldn't mind starting Great Pretender or Fruits Basket either, great lineup this time :)

AustinMyB

What about JoJo, LOTGH, Hajime no Ippo, HxH?

Rustle My Jimmies

Oh *c'mon*, Yu Yu Hakusho is like f*cking 120 episodes long. Ain't no one got the time for that

MoodyBlue

100% this

Maximilian Mellen

Fruits Basket is SUCH and amazing show. I'm really just amazed at the quality and content of the 2019 reboot. I hope you guys watch it sometime even if it doesn't win now❤

BriBri

So next season we get S2's of Slime Issekai, Promised Neverland, Doctor Stone, and Beastars. Will these shows be entering polls or will they be added one at a time to a single slot or multiple slots?

Zeemod

Rip Bakuman

KC

They mentioned their reactions would come back in a few weeks on a previous Patreon comment

Sebastián

Do you think Re:Zero will ever get into the poll eventually? Or will they wait for the second half of season 2 to come out?

Loro Lukic

I know not many people agree with me on this but if Fruits Basket 2019 does hopefully win I would love it if you watched it in the Dub because I think it is a great one voice acting wise.

Supermonaman

Ikr? There's a lot to analyze and theorize about!

katanagatari is the perfect follow up to monogatari

Chriz1406

Man, looks like Golden Kamuy is behind, maybe one day it will win a wild card slot or something. 0

Brendan Horn

Yuu Yuu Hakushou is a classic, i hope it wins =)

lancer081292

I’m still shook that Fruits basket still hasn’t won after all this time it’s literally perfect for y’all. You could discuss it literally forever. Counting down til the day it finally wins 😭😭😭

Summer Akers

2 Space shows already won a poll (Dandy, LOTGH) Can we get a triple?

Rustle My Jimmies

And that's why it won't win :(

Rustle My Jimmies

I hope either Bakuman or Katanagatari wins, so underrated tbh.

Zenden

Bakuman is amazing and super underwatched

Gavin

PLEASE VOTE BAKUMAN

Ezutess

I can think of a reason to not vote for it. Nana and or Space Brothers :)

Matthew B

Bakuman is obvious

Daniel Tenorio

Katanagatari all the way with this one, it's one cour, it's by Nisio Isin and having seen it I can say it's *really* good. Really no reason not to vote for it! *Cheerio intensifies*

Marika Pauley

Never thought I’d see Yu Yu Hakusho in a SOS Bros Poll, please let it win

melo

I am the Great Pretender. Please watch the English dubbed version.

Roma

Pleaseeeeeeee fruba

Juniper

It isn’t going to win but Nana is the best show on this list...☕️

Master Detective

GO FRUITS GOOOO

Jess5_11

There's old stuff that holds up, and old stuff that doesn't. Yu Yu Hakusho doesn't.

Juniper And Sage

The Great Pretender! <3

Steve Tu

Agreed!!! So much to dive into. Greats story telling, characters and emotions.

WuXian Suibian

Come on y’all get great pretender in

Great Pretender doesn't get enough love cuz its trapped in Netflix hell

yellownart

Man, if fruits basket gets the win I would be unbelievably happy. Perfect show for the bros to dive into.

BeesKnees

They would absolutely love Space Brothers. Not only is it super good seinen slice of life like you said, but it also has one of the most riveting, intense arcs to an anime I think I've ever watched.

Kirathian

Yu Yu Hakosho is hilarious especially with the dub

Ty Arnold

Holy shit that's a lot of good series lol. Umm Golden Kamuy or Fruba. But at the same time...space bros would be perfect for u guys.

Alba Zawa

Come on fruits basket

Pacific Caleb

Yet again, no Kaiji or Texhnolyze...

R_K41

Definitely Yu Yu Hakusho and one of the few shows I'd recommend the Dub for, mainly because it actually does have a different feel to it.

Yolo Samurai

Same, it's one of my favorites but it doesn't have much chances of winning a poll.

bennydelon

Yuu Yuu Hakusho all the way baby! And do the dub please!

Matt

People are generally less likely to vote for longer shows if they’re not interested them. The whole logic of “if a shorter show wins then we’ll get a new poll sooner”

BeesKnees

Fruit basket please <3 people are gonna probably ride the Yuu Yuu Hakusho train out of nostalgia but I can say with certainty it doesn't live up to the hype, when it was created it was probably amazing but now it's a below average anime.

RussellSD

i love golden kamuy so much but how can i vote for anything other then space brothers i need the bros to experience space brothers!

Erinna

space brothers gang F

Erasurehead

Bros you got to watch Space Brothers. One of the BEST slice of life seinen out there. No one's going to choose it since most haven't seen it but it's a must watch.

Drax

One of the best dubs out there, had most of the English VA heavyweights

gugestein .

I would hope Golden Kamuy, but Great Pretender is awesome too.

2Ker

Katanagatari (and Kubikiri Cycle/Zaregoto) are a must watch for more NisioIsin greatness after Monogatari

Are you kidding me? Great Pretender over Yu Yu Hakusho? Are you all crazy?

Argo2Unitard

Same

Schleep

I want Golden Kamuy to win so much but i know it wont cuz not many ppl watch it

Amasian

Wait, yall aint seen Yu Yu Hakusho? And hopefully you watch the dub.

Argo2Unitard

yuyu hakusho is not the best show but it holds much nostalgic value to me and I also get to rewatch it with the bros? lets goo yuyu hakusho babyyy

sacombankmonkey

Yu Yu Hakusho is fantastic

M Ark

I need a Great Pretenders reaction. It's such a good watch.

Blacklightning

This poll makes me weirdly sad. Monogatari has been an absolutely legendary reaction series.

Kirathian

Great pretender? Hell yeah.

Caleb

Come on Great Pretender... We can do this!

Hope they throw Jujutsu Kaisen in the next poll, seems like the shounen they would like

L0ken

Lets goo Yuu Yuu Hakusho!!!

gugestein .