To Your Eternity Replacement Poll

It was actually 3rd in one of the earlier polls, but then they included some mainstream stuff in a "niche genre" poll unfortunately.

Damiester

I feel you. I don't think Girls' Last Tour has gotten out of the bottom two in any of the polls it's been in

Evione

lol it's rough how Girl's Last Tour and Shinsekai Yori are constantly underrated in this community.

Damiester

I’d like you to react Golden Kamuy next time😭

Recency bias at its finest

OMG!! Banana Fish T_T

Cilenita79

golden kamuy, banana fish is good also but gk ... i feel so sad

StreetFighterII

Ahhh GK is narrowly passed again :( Hopefully we'll get it one day, I'm so sure they would love it!

KaregoAt

and GK, one of the top5 shows of the last 5ish years got shafted again

jogurtowski

Time for an emotional and action-packed ride, y’all! Super happy about the BF win but would still love to see Shinsekai Yori and GK reactions (and Ghost in the Shell SAC and Utena reactions if they get a chance to be in future polls again). If they like Utena, hopefully they’ll check out more Ikuhara shows too

matchasketch

Yess!! BF won! 🎊

The time has finally comes for the brothers to watch Banana Fish. I couldn't be more excited and happier than this!

dumbling

Banana Fish gang rejoice!!!

Fede Krauch

Let's go! We did it, Banana Fish peeps ❤️

Sebastián

Hi bros next time please vision of scaflowne, jojos Ovas, maisson ikkoku and serial experiments lane, for your channel thank you!!

If it was a one time thing, sure, happens if both fanbases are equally passionate about it, but it just feels a bit weird to see it be like this two polls in a row? Though in the end, the one that was in the lead for the last several days won so I guess it's alright either way.

Sera

o7 Golden Kamuy

Stinsfire

omg yes I was so scared at the last minutes but it made it!! Banana Fish! Can't wait!!

Kenzo

We finally won! Great job everyone, now go get some rest

iris

Feb 27th gonna be a great day

Wow, so close! Banana Fish deserve this. I can't wait. I hope someday GK or Shinsekai yori win the poll. Not in this poll but I also hope Revolutionary Girl Utena...

KEN K

lets go banana fish enjoyers!! super excited to finally see it win

Prism

Okay, while I'm happy that BF won, I suspect that people in the last few hours are purposefully creating drama with the close call, something that the Bros have addressed with the last poll. There have been times that BF would lose a vote or two while GK continue to gain traction, closing the gap until the very last minute where they are fighting for first place. You think I'm being dramatic, look at the previous polls, none of them have ever had two shows get this close of a call until the last poll. It's a little annoying, to be honest. I think some people are not genuinely voting for shows that they want them to react and are intentionally voting, or even switching votes, to create unnecessary drama. I understand that this sort of thing can happen, but seeing with my own eyes how it constantly be this close, especially in the last hour, people need to be careful because I can see the Bros dropping the polling altogether and just pick the shows themselves.

Brian Wilder

I'm a big fan of Golden Kamuy and Banana Fish but I like Banana Fish just a tiny bit more. I heard the Manga for Golden Kamuy is a lot better.

BriBri

Yay Banana fish for the win. I can’t wait for the discussion portion of the videos.

xperax

I'm going to finally rest and come back to make sure these results are real

banana fish tHANK GOD gotta get my early access again

TrianaNero

Well, you win some, you lose some I guess

Rustle My Jimmies

Well, Banana Fish had a good run while it lasted, it almost made it

Banana Fish deserves

GK PLEASE

neromxxn

whoaaa last 15 minutes with 1 difference :O this is so intense

jm.

Yo s a m e

This is the longest 16 minutes of my life

BriBri

Banana Fish is my favorite anime! Really hope it wins

Please let golden kamuy win

Cameron Hall

Banana Fish!!!!

Gk for the win!!!

neromxxn

Rlly hope banana fish wins they'd love it

Kai Leon

this is gonna be a long hour! I believe in us BF fans

iris

please 3 more votes for gk!!

neromxxn

Banana Fish plzzz

Kenzo

Please let Banana Fish win the polls this time!!! It’s so close to winning!!!

matchasketch

Give Banana Fish fans a chance please!!! It's been in the poll 5 times already!!!

CandykOh

Banana Fish fans waited long enough.......

TrianaNero

I Hope Golden Kamuy, but Banana Fish is also great. I love this close game.

KEN K

😂 same. Can't sleep til it's over

Dunno2000

I haven't slept yet, gotta see these 3 hours to the end ( Rooting for Banana Fish )

Gk fans please aaaahhh help

neromxxn

Banana Fish and Shinsekai Yori (for a future poll)!! These would be awesome for the bros to discuss.

matchasketch

banana fish fighting !

Carter

Catch up, Golden Kamuy!

BirthdayParty

Then we need to see if we can get No.6 into a poll

Not trying to pick a fight, but if you haven't even seen them I don't really understand why you care what other show might or might not win?

Sera

keep it up banana fish!! 13hrs left

iris

Lets go!!! Banana Fish

Really hope Banana Fish wins. There is so much to talk about with that show.

Mabel

Sadly another poll where Bakuman has basically no chance to win. But at least Golden Kamuy has a chance still, so it's only fitting for me to say this in Ainu: "Golden Kamuy" sekor aye anime iannokar yak pirkap ne wa! (tl.: "I hope the anime called "Golden Kamuy" wins!").

banana fish you're doing amazing sweetie! 🥺 less than 24 hours left, hang in there!!! if (or when 😉) banana fish wins, we'll have given and banana fish! hope the bros are emotionally ready for both. i can't wait! 💙

jm.

girl's last tour is amazing.

Dian

C'mon GK..make this four quid a month punt worth it ;)

Jamie Hemming

It pains me to see the two shows I want to win the lest to be in the lead. I haven't watched bakuman, shinsekai yori or girls last tour but from the synopsis and what I heard other people say they sound great

Zairaner

You know you can vote for multiple shows in this poll? There is no choice to make

Zairaner

Banana Fish pull through! Just 2 more days!

CandykOh

Girls' Last Tour AND Banana Fish?! An impossible choice to make! Honestly I don't think Girls' Last Tour is going to win a poll any time soon, so I hope you guys just decide to pick it for yourselves someday! It's an incredibly interesting show for discussion, I'd love to hear your thoughts on it :)

Colin Jordan

Chitatap time baby!!!

Hammi

only two days, hang on Banana Fish!!

Kenzo

Maybe there are just better shows on this list? Lol?

neromxxn

How does Shinsekai Yori have such little votes? What kind of ass backwards voting is this

antgeezy

It seeems it's not the time for it

neromxxn

Please watch shinsekai yori. It’s been on polls for years!

Zecxel

You guys are either too young or crazy if you don’t want to see the boys react to Shinsekai Yori. The level of discussion/theorizing would be on par with Attack On Titan! Caleb, Jacob! I’m begging you. Make this your executive choice, please! lol.

The Great Santini

oh no comrades, Golden Kamuy is losing. Pls!!! Someone bring in the cgi bear reinforcements

Amasian

Since Banana Fish (my second choice) is doing better than SK8, I hope it wins! I really enjoyed the first stage play and will certainly watch the second that just finished so if it wins, it will get me to finally watch the anime!

Star

in the garbage pile

neromxxn

Banana Fish & SK8 🙏🙏🙏💕

What is with the second seasen of slime ?

Luke349 6

Banana fish or sk8 please

Anna Lena Ciplajevs

wow super close

Jimuel

Pls pls pls golden kamuy

banana fish pls!!!

jm.

Banana fish I believe in you 😭

Carter

Please do Golden Kamuy!!!!!

BANANA FISH IS IN THE LEAD LETS GOOOOOOOOOO

Francesca White

Theres really so much to talk about in Banana Fish really hoping they finally react to it!!

jules

Come on Golden Kamuy!!!!@@@

BreaRose

Damn it banana fish lose,come on gokden kamuy

Charlie baker

pull through banana fish 😭

iris

Come on Banana Fish, pull through 🙏🏽 It’s been on the polls for so long

Tanya

Deadass joined just to vote for Banana Fish

If Banana Fish doesn't win this time I hope they'll just give it a slot instead of continually putting it in the poll. It's been on the poll for a very very long time and even though it comes close to winning it usually doesn't. It's a great show, you guys will greatly enjoy it but at this rate who knows when you'll react to it. :(

Heather Sanders

GIRLS' LAST TOUR. PLEEEAAASE.

Youmu Senju

Banana Fish, come on!

This gives me Beastars/AssClass flashbacks

Fede Krauch

Banana Fish please omg

Peach

AAAAAA GOLDEN KAMUY MY BELOVED, though I would be fine with SK8, or Banana Fish too, it would finally make me finish it.

KaregoAt

Omg I really wanna see them react to banana fish!!

I know not everybody here loves banana fish but man will I be unapologetically happy if it wins!!!!

Bishi4life

Man this is one of does times when Golden Kamuy and Banana Fish have a chance due to not being against recent/popular anime. Would love to see both but Golden Kamuy is just too good.

Mojo

became a patron just for banana fish. praying it wins 🙏

Kay Edwards

Admittedly, I've only seen Banana Fish and Girls' Last Tour and just started watching Shinsekai yori. I just only got into watching anime a couple of years back. Still, I think their reactions and discussions for BF and GLT would be great and interesting to listen to as I think they are both fantastic. I'm rooting for BF given how close it is to winning and while GLT is currently in last place, it is almost matched up with the other three shows that I think it'll slowly do better in future polls, provided that no new "hype" show overtakes their attention.

Brian Wilder

Banana fish home stretch lol

Kiyotsugu

Banana fish would be so awesome

Infinteginger

cgi bear time

Golden Kamui is really perfect for this channel

shamefur display

Every day we're one step closer to Bakuman, although I'm afraid the day has yet to come.

Zaj

yesss link click!! i also think they would have so many amazing discussions with this show.

dumbling

BANANA FISH OH MY GOODD

dumbling

Bakuman is a classic. Such a fantastic tale of the manga industry.

M Ark

Shinsekai Yori isn't winning this time, but would be cool to see them watch that and Girl's Last Tour one day. They'll get their chance one day I'm sure.

Marika Pauley

I know Shinsekai Yori won't win, but man is it so good.

Chapt9

Show Bakuman some love :3

Syres SX

Please Golden kamuy oh my god

neromxxn

Please, please, please watch Shinsekai Yori

BANANANANANANANNANA FIIIIIIIIIIIISSSSHHHHH

Bobby Hanson

BANANA FISH PLEASE!!! I'M BEGGING 😭😭😭

CandykOh

Imo the animation gets really good in the 3rd season , even with a bit of sakuga sometimes

neromxxn

One of these years bakuman will make it..... one of these years

epicnarken

But sadly not much love for Shinsekai Yori it seems… right now third place but very far behind the second :(

Fusssel

Ooof, this is so close! Can't express how much I hope Golden Kamuy wins though. It takes a couple of episodes to get going (mostly due to some low-budget CGI effects work early on), but once it kicks off it gets WILD. It's got a bit of JoJo's to it, but with better character development (IMO). ...and a surprising number of recipes for bits of unusual wild animals.

Asteroidea

Golden Kamuy, Shinsekai Yori, and Banana fish have been on polls together so many times. These are the best options in my opinion.

Zecxel

None of those really interest me at all but golden kamuy was ok for the few episodes of it i watched

MASTER VOS

Are you guys gonna continue watching Demon Slayer?

Kevin Xiong

I was just re-watching Girls Last Tour and it‘s on the list!! Guess that means I should vote for it 😂

Joey

One day Girls Last Tour or Shinsekai Yori will have a chance

hokidori

I'm rooting for Golden Kamuy. It's literally one of those animes that just gets better every season. I think the Bros. would really enjoy it.

slipHAZARD

hang in there banana fish!

iris

pls banana fish pull through !!

Carter

Oh please let Golden Kamuy win. I know Banana Fish is good, but the insanity of Golden Kamuy would fit SO well with a reaction.

Aye Jaye

I will always vote for Shinsekai Yori, but I know it will never get first place.

B C

Banana Fish ~please~, it’s a gold mine for discussions and only one season!!

TrianaNero

*Crosses fingers for Golden Kamui*

BirthdayParty

Banana Fish let's gooooo!!!!

Shadowcam

I’ve been waiting for the bros to do banana fish forever😭😭

OMG BANANA FISH ITS ONLY ONE SEASON

GK GK GK

Alba Zawa

HAS to be the Sun, otherwise how will they ever know the glory of “Skateboard All Might”? 😆

CaffieneKitty

Both Sk8 and Banana fish are a must watch for different reasons. Sk8 is fun and comedy gold but I’d like to see their reaction and analysis on Banana Fish

Lily Broyles

Golden Kamuy or Shinsekai Yori would be my choices

Yuion

hope I'll get to see them react to Bakuman...... someday, I hope :).

Please Golden Kamuy, I would love to give it a re-watch with the bros

RandomThorn

Sk8 the infinity is on a poll?! Oh my GOD yes!!!

Jackie D.

…maybe one day, Bakuman.

Ray walker

I’m so happy to even see Sk8 the Infinity on a poll! It’s such fun cheese. 😊

CaffieneKitty

Sleep

Adrian

oh my god an sos poll where the two shows I like are leading???

Talulabelle

Compare the rank in popularity of it and Golden Kamuy and you'll see that's not true about attention.

Dale Cooper

lets go, golden kamuy!

Erinna

Come on man, Golden kamuy needs to win this, it's such a funny and good show

Melker Linderoth

Golden Kamuy is criminally underrated, let's fucking go. Also probably the best historical fiction anime out there

Pyrrhus65

PLEASE LET BANANA FISH WIN THIS TIME!!!!!!!!!!!!!

OMG SK8!!!!

Banana Fish Or Golden Kamuy

JT

Please let Banana Fish win!!!! It's soo good and I'm excited to see the theories crafted by the bros!!!

BriBri

I wish banana fish wins, it’s such a great show and not enough people pay attention to it!

Cy Palmer

I'm voting for Banana Fish, but Golden Kamuy aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah. It's just because GK Manga>>>>>anime (still good tho)

AndreaLorenzi

Yess Banana Fish! these are all great choices tbh

Isabelle

Dear lord let it be banana fish

EvAnn

Banana fish PLEASE!! It’s been on the poll for so long...😭

I am overdue another shinsekai yori viewing. I think the discussions could be interesting and is perfect for this format. It also has an amazing soundtrack.

RYAN

voting for Shinsekai yori. The bros' definitely need to take notice of this show, They would have so much to talk about.

GOLDEN KAMUY PLEEAAASSEEE. LETSS GOOO!

Isaku Saito

I love how split this is between GK & BF… PLEASE GOLDEN KAMUY

Ranking of Kings should have BEEN on the lists

Drax

Golden Kamuy plz

Zenden

Banana fish PLEASE

Hoping Banana Fish can finally win this one

DAW

Gk or BF... I do prefer BF as an anime and GK as a manga.. Decisions decisions...

Nours

tough in these streets for a Bakuman and Shinsekai Yori fan…older shows deserve some love

Master Detective

I haven't watched it but really wish it would win this, it sounds really interesting!

Zairaner

and link click

neromxxn

Please let Golden Kamuy have this W

jogurtowski

Ahhh I hope they watch Banana fish I was honestly not expecting much from it but I was left empty by the end of it .

xperax

Banana Fish and SK8 on the same poll, perfect since they both have the same director. Actually, Utsumi also directed Clannad and K-on. Hope you'll consider Link Click in the original Chinese (Mandarin).

WuXian Suibian

Omg it's so close between Banana Fish and Golden Kamuy, I'm PRAYING for Banana fish

Francesca White

Would you guys consider adding Ranking of Kings to a poll sometime? :3

Devilline V. Raven

It's my favorite story in fiction so it really is a shame that Girls' Last Tour will probably never win one of these polls.

Evione

🍌 🐠 please

LilxxBit

Golden kamuy is a must watch ,chitatap chitatap chitatap

Charlie baker

Dammit I voted Banana Fish but would I have the mental strength to watch it a second time lmao

Kenzo

I better see banana fish wins this time

Mo Moradi

Banana fish pls..It’s been on the poll for so long😂

Kiki Varas

Sk8 the infinty was so unbelievably fun

Pierce Trent

i know a lot of people will be voting for golden kamuy but i hope you’ll keep sk8 in consideration regardless of how it does on the poll. Its short and sweet and well worth the watch for the characters alone (and the animation itself is gorgeous).

Patch

Yeah the bulky men are great

neromxxn

pls Golden Kamuy PLS !!!

Amasian

GOLDEN KAMUY IS PERFECT FOR THIS CHANNEL PLEASE

Tyler Kennamer

Can we get K-On on a poll sometime *Copium*

Jesse Vincente

i will sell all of my organs for banana fish

Leonie

omg yess SK8!!!

shu

YES LINK CLICK

neromxxn

Praying to the ancient gods for Golden Kamuy to win

Jessica Bestel

Wait omg banana fish has a chance?? Didnt think I 'd see the day 😭

Chi

Going with Golden Kamuy this time. Also, I hope you put Link Click on a poll in the future, I’d love to see you guys react to that

Patrick

Bakuman ♥️ I Hope see Sayonara Zetsubou-sensei in a poll again...

Morringhan

Send the prayers to the Tuesday slot picks haha.. because that's unfortunately the best chance GLT will get. Despite being such a top tier show.

Kirathian

Cmon Golden Kamuy, there not enough reactions to this amazing show

Sunny Morgans

Woah! Didn't think I'd see SK8 on a poll! Nice!

Star

Wow golden kamuy and banana fish this is too much of a hard choice

neromxxn

SK8 is amazing and definitely worth checking out.

XWF Outlaw

banana fish pls we’ve suffered enough

cornflakez

me too! and I think sos bros will love this show as well

Eren Jaeger

Girls’ Last Tour got me out of my feelings of despondency back in 2020, and got me back into anime and manga. Well worth a watch!

Craig from Omaha

Golden Kamuy or Bakuman

Jesse Vincente

shinsekai yori!

Eren Jaeger

Banana Fish would get such amazing reactions and really interesting commentary! Banana Fish may be one of my favorite animes but I really think It'd be something really interesting and quite different from what the bros as used to.

Rub

Banana Fish 🐆🥺❤️

SufferBoi

Yooo! Golden Kamuy have a chance!

KEN K

There's so much to chew on with Shin Sekai Yori so I really hope it wins.

Bercin Boutet

If sk8 gets chosen, idk if the dub or sub is better. Both have their own perks. I think I'd lean towards the dub though if pressed.

AmbiguousCake

SK8 was my comfort anime last year, so I'm excited y'all have this on the poll! And Banana Fish is one of my all-time favorite anime/manga so I'm SO excited it's on the poll as well; definitely a must-watch.

Romaniablack

A lot of good choices here, but Golden Kamuy is sooo underrated and good. And I really think it would fit the brothers' style of analysis and theory-crafting.

Nathan Grenawalt

they already watched it before starting the channel

zeid c

Golden Kamuy might actually have a chance. Am I still asleep right now?

Kirathian

Omg Sk8 yaaas

Jess5_11

Oh shit, SK8! Didn't think to see that here.

AstroSeedP

banana fish is back!!

Prism

I shall pray for girls last tour

The Lonely Wolf

Its in the lead so far, so fingers crossed!

Stuart Hanmore

Sk8! Though really want to see ranking of Kings in a poll soon, it's so good.

kingofshibainu

✨BANANA FISH supremacy✨

Sebastián

I hope you guys will consider Madoka Magica in the future!! It’s a great show seriously, and the animation is very unique.

Really hoping the boys at some point watch Golden Kamuy, but I doubt it's going to win this poll.

Senpai