[MashUp] Ch 42: The Tragedy

— — — — — — 

While everyone was still basking in the joy of victory and marveling at the mysterious "Hero's Mark," the little dog-shaped fairy guide clapped its tiny hands again.

Its soft, bell-like voice drew all eyes toward it.

"Congratulations, brave ones. Your courage will be remembered forever by the Candy Kingdom."

"But," it added, "our pilgrimage isn't over yet."

It turned and led the group—still buzzing with excitement—down a dimly lit path.

The cheerful flowers lining the road had vanished.

In their place grew glowing blue mushrooms, casting eerie light across the ground.

The sweet fragrance that once filled the air slowly faded, replaced by a damp, cold scent.

A faint aroma of aged wood and dust—like an ancient library—slipped into Anon Chihaya's nose.

Even the music changed. The lively symphony was gone, replaced by a distant, melancholy piano solo that echoed softly through the darkness.

"W-Where… are we going?"

Anon instinctively clutched Takamatsu Tomori's arm, the sudden shift in atmosphere sending shivers down her spine.

Tomori didn't answer.

Her clear, glass-like eyes reflected curiosity instead of fear.

This quiet, sorrowful world seemed to resonate with her in a way the bright, cheerful one hadn't.

...

Five minutes later, a massive structure loomed before them.

A gothic opera house, towering and solemn.

Its spires stretched into the sky, vines climbed its cracked stone walls, and stAnond-glass windows glimmered faintly in the phosphorescent light, scattering mysterious halos across the ground.

A giant signboard hung over the gate: "Macaron's Music Theater - Phantom of Opera."

"Welcome to the second dream."

The fairy's voice had grown soft, almost reverent.

"Here, there are no battles. No enemies."

"Only a song forgotten for a hundred years, and a soul waiting to be heard."

It slowly pushed open the gilded doors.

Inside was a vast underground lake, silent and still.

The waters were black as ink, reflecting the starry ceiling above—a man-made firmament sparkling with constellations.

Dozens of dragon-shaped gondolas waited at the shore, each one adorned with glowing lanterns.

"Please, pair up and board the Boats of Light," the fairy instructed.

"They will carry you across the Lake of Silence, where you must seek the clues left behind by the Phantom of the Opera."

"Only those who solve every riddle will earn the right to hear the song in its entirety at the end."

Anon, both nervous and thrilled, pulled Tomori toward one of the gondolas.

The moment they sat down, the boat swayed gently and began gliding on its own, heading deeper into the lake.

The world went quiet.

Only the sound of the boat cutting through the water and Anon's own heartbeat filled her ears.

She leaned close and whispered, afraid to disturb the solemn atmosphere.

"Tomori… are you scared?"

Tomori shook her head.

She stretched her hand out over the water, letting her fingertips skim the cool surface. Star-like ripples spread across the lake.

"It's… so quiet here." Her voice was soft.

"Like a poem without words."

Just then—

A haunting, ethereal voice drifted from somewhere deep within the lake.

"Who… is calling… that forgotten name…"

The voice was pure, almost fragile, yet heavy with a loneliness that had settled for centuries.

Every gondola went silent.

No one dared to breathe, as if afraid to shatter the fragile song.

The melody didn't stop.

It echoed, carrying over the water, sometimes near, sometimes far.

Anon's eyes darted around, trying to find the source, but the lake held nothing but darkness and stars.

"W-What are we supposed to do?" she muttered nervously.

"Is this… part of the puzzle? Where's the clue?"

As if in answer, three glowing water lilies surfaced in front of their boat, each shining with a different color:

A golden one—symbolizing Joy.

A red one—symbolizing Anger.

And a blue one—symbolizing Sorrow.

Their gondola came to a stop, waiting.

"A choice?"

Anon blinked, then lit up in realization.

"This must be the puzzle! Okay, okay, let me think…"

She propped her chin in her hand, deep in thought.

"'A forgotten name'… that sounds super tragic, right?"

"So… probably Sorrow?"

"No, wait, maybe they're angry about being forgotten? Could be Anger…"

"Ugh, this is so hard!"

Beside her, Tomori remained silent, eyes closed, completely absorbed in the song.

"No… it's not sadness…"

She repeated to herself in her heart.

"This voice… it's remembering. Remembering a brief moment that was once lit by the sun…"

"Tomori? Did you figure it out?"

Anon looked to her for help.

Tomori slowly opened her eyes. She didn't analyze the lyrics, she simply spoke what she heard.

"He's not sad. He's not angry."

"He's just… lonely."

"What he wants isn't pity, or understanding."

Her hand trembled slightly as she pointed to the golden lily.

"He just… remembered that there was once a little bit of joy in his life."

"Eh?! Gold?!"

Anon was stunned, but the quiet certainty in Tomori's gaze made her trust her instinct.

She reached out and gently touched the golden water lily.

A soft hum filled the air as it dissolved into countless motes of light.

Their gondola lurched, then began moving forward again, heading toward a fog-shrouded part of the lake.

"D-Did we get it right?!"

"Tomori, you're amazing! How did you know?!"

"I…"

Tomori lowered her head, her voice quiet. "I just… heard it. Heard what his heart was feeling."

...

Meanwhile, the other gondolas that had chosen red or blue simply spun in circles, unable to proceed.

As their boat glided into the mist, a new verse began.

This time, an organ accompanied the song, deep and resonant:

"Behind the shattered mask… lies a face never meant to be seen…Moonlight, don't… reveal my ugliness…"

The grief and desperation in the voice made Anon's chest ache.

Tomori pressed both hands over her heart.

The song was no longer just the Phantom's—it had become her own hidden monologue, her private confession no one had ever heard.

When the song faded, a new puzzle appeared before them.

Three glowing shapes floated above the water:

A shattered mirror, symbolizing facing the truth.

A locked diary, symbolizing sealing away secrets.

And a wilted rose, symbolizing beauty that has passed away.

"..." Anon swallowed.

"Seriously… another choice already?"

Anon felt like her brain was overheating. "The lyrics said not to look at his ugly face — so we should avoid it, right?"

"So… the diary? We seal it away?"

She turned to Tomori, only to see her staring straight at the mirror.

"Tomori?"

Her voice trembled slightly, but her tone was firm.

"He says, 'Don't look'…"

"But deep down, more than anything, he's hoping someone will see through all his masks… and embrace the ugly truth of who he really is."

"So, it's the mirror."

Anon didn't quite follow that logic, but she trusted Tomori's instincts unconditionally.

She reached out and touched the mirror.

Crash—

The mirror shattered, scattering into stardust that lit their gondola's way forward.

Finally—

After solving five riddles in total, the boat passed through the last barrier of mist.

What awaited them was a grand, lonely circular stage floating on the water.

Anon glanced back.

She was stunned to see that only about a dozen gondolas had made it through the fog.

Almost everyone else had been lost in the mist… or in the song itself.

At the very center of the stage sat a lone figure, back turned to them.

A sheep wearing a half-white mask and a black tailcoat.

The source of the song.

Macaron — the Phantom of the Opera.

Sensing that the true listeners had arrived, Macaron stopped playing.

He turned slowly, and the eyes visible through his mask swept across the few gondolas that had reached this place.

"Welcome…"

His voice carried both relief and warmth. "Welcome, those who truly understood my song."

"As a reward — and as thanks…"

"I will now play for you the full version of Tears of the Star."

He placed his hands back on the organ.

A second later, the music roared to life.

No longer fragments. No longer just lamentation.

This was a complete song — a sweeping epic telling of a century of loneliness, endless waiting, and the final redemption of a soul that had finally been heard.

As the music swelled, visions appeared across the surface of the lake:

A shattered mask.

A lover walking away.

A rose withering in the dark.

A sky overflowing with starlight.

Countless images whirled around the gondolas, pulling everyone into the Phantom's inner world.

Anon was completely entranced.

Beside her, Tomori's eyes were already red with tears.

She wasn't seeing Macaron — she was seeing herself.

A lonely soul, longing to be understood through song.

When the piece ended, silence fell over the lake.

Macaron stood, turned to his small audience, and bowed gracefully.

For the first time, joy — quiet, relieved joy — shone in his eyes.

But at that very moment—

"There you are, monster!"

A furious shout rang out from the far corner of the theater, shattering the silence.

Everyone spun around.

An NPC in an ancient royal guard's uniform stood there, eyes blazing with fanatic hatred.

In his hands was a primitive-looking magic rifle, its barrel glowing with a dangerous crimson light.

"A cursed thing like you doesn't deserve a song! You don't deserve to be understood!"

"Disappear!"

Boom!

A beam of scarlet light shot across the lake like a falling star.

Macaron's body jerked violently.

He looked down at his chest, where the beam had pierced straight through.

No blood spilled from the wound — only countless glowing notes, the very ones that made up his body, streaming out and dissolving into the air.

"Aaah…"

A cry of pain tore from his throat. He fell to his knees.

"Why…"

He looked toward the gondolas, his voice breaking. "I just… wanted to be heard…"

He reached out, as if to grasp the fleeing notes, but his hands closed on nothing.

Then his whole body shattered like glass — dissolving into a storm of black musical notes that rAnond down as ash.

The entire lake went deathly still.

The NPC guard let out a deranged laugh before vanishing in a swirl of black mist, leaving only a pile of ash on the stage.

And a dozen gondolas of silent, numb passengers, hearts crushed by grief and anger.

Ding.

The soft chime snapped Anon out of her daze.

She looked down and saw that next to the candy-crown stamp on the back of her hand, a faint, dark eighth note had appeared.

Their gondola turned on its own, carrying the hollow-eyed listeners back toward the shore.

Anon glanced at Tomori, whose whole body was shaking.

She didn't know what to say.

But Tomori looked up, her tear-reddened eyes burning with anger and determination.

"Anon."

"I… I'm going to write a song for him."

The gondolas docked one by one.

The small group of "witnesses" stumbled ashore, still dazed.

Most of the other visitors, who had been stuck in the mist, were already waiting at the docks.

They crowded around, whispering and asking questions.

"Where the hell did you guys go? Our boats were just spinning in circles!"

"What happened? Why do you all look like you saw a ghost?"

No one answered.

Even Kaito, the popular streamer, had forgotten about his live chat.

He just stared at the broken eighth note on his hand and muttered to himself.

"This is insane… I know it was fake, just an act…"

"But my chest… still hurts."

"It felt like a real soul… just disappeared right in front of me."

"This park… its level of immersion is straight-up monstrous…"

He lifted his head, eyes wide with awe.

Anon's heart felt unbearably heavy.

Just then, the little dog-fairy appeared again.

Its gentle voice floated into every ear. "I know your hearts are heavy with grief and confusion."

"But remember this — in dreams, an ending is often just the start of something new."

— — —

In the control room, Takuma leaned back, smiling in satisfaction at the sight of the girl on screen — tears in her eyes but burning with creative fire.

Macaron's performance had exceeded even his expectations.

His eyes flicked to the monitor showing the two types of visitors.

One group — those like Tomori, who reached the end — bore the faint eighth note stamp.

They had been marked as witnesses, their hearts filled with grief and anger. Emotions that would linger for a long, long time.

The other group — the majority — had been lost in the fog and led away early.

They were left with confusion, and curiosity about what had happened to the witnesses.

Those who mourn would become storytellers.

Those who wonder will come back, again and again, to seek the truth.

Either way, they were all playing exactly into his plan.

Takuma's eyes returned to the quiet, introverted Tomori.

He started scheming, wondering how best to make his appearance.

How could he approach them in a way that would naturally turn this future girl band into the park's very own background music?

Recruit them openly as the park's owner?

No fun. No challenge.

Better to…

He smiled wickedly.

.

.

.