Prompt: Helping a Friend Ch. 6 (Prompt)

Summary: Cana finally plays her blackmail card, coercing both Elfman and Lucy to put on a show with her. Includes: NTR, Smut, Blackmail

---

Lucy flipped the page of her book, mindlessly absorbing the words without really thinking about them. Reading the book didn’t have the same excitement to it as it did before, but perhaps that was more her fault than the book’s?

Her sore body was a distraction, and no matter how she adjusted, she still felt just the tiniest ache in her muscles. No doubt it was because of Gajeel yesterday. The Dragon showed her no mercy, fucking her with his iron-hard cock.

Lucy had to admit, it was fun at the time, but did he have to leave her so sore? She sighed to herself, before she continued reading, trying to focus on her book.

The beautiful blonde was torn from the pages by the sound of someone knocking on her door. She rose up from her couch, a curious look in her eyes. She placed her book down and walked to her front door, opening it to find a couple of familiar faces.

Cana and Elfman stood on the other side of the door. Cana had a wide grin on her face, while Elfman seemed more subdued. A subtle look of confused could be seen in his eyes, and Lucy imagined her own expression was similar. Before she could say anything, they gestured towards her.

“Mind if we come in, Lucy?” Cana’s smile seemed to grow, as if she wanted to giggle. Elfman and Lucy both glanced at her, but neither commented on her smirk.

“Um, sure. Come on in.” Lucy motioned them inside and closed the door behind them. “What are you guys doing here? Is something wrong?” she asked, her eyes bouncing between the muscular man and buxom woman.

Cana walked into Lucy’s house, stepping into the blond’s bedroom. Both Elfman and Lucy followed as the brunette motioned to the bed.

“I think you both should sit down for this.”

Lucy looked to Elfman for an expression, but the large man just lifted his shoulders up before dropping them down. It was obvious that the man had no idea what Cana was about to say, just like Lucy.

The two sat on the edge of Lucy’s bed, watching as Cana’s hand slipped into the vast canyon of her cleavage, right under her tight top. Both Elfman and Lucy watched in silence, both of their cheeks a faint scarlet. From there, Cana plucked out a photo from under her top, holding it up to the two with that same, sharp smirk.

Lucy wasn’t sure what to say, and judging by his open mouth and hanging jaw, neither did Elfman.

The photo was simple. A picture of Lucy and Elfman fucking in the back of the dorm, hidden behind thin walls. The blond was being pounded by the giant, turned into his fucktoy as her screams rang through Lucy’s head. 

“H-how did you-?!”

“The important question it’s, what I want in exchange for giving you this picture and not showing it to your significant others,” Cana grinned, licking her lips in anticipation. 

Even the mighty Elfman seemed to be unnerved. He swallowed, throat shaking as he placed his hands on his knees. His fingers dug into his skin as he and Lucy shared a look. Their eyes turned back towards Cana as she continued.

“What I want is simple. I want you both to entertain me.”

“Like… put on a show?” Elfman slowly asked, and Cana almost laughed at the answer. Lucy shook her head, placing a hand to her forehead as the brunette giggled. 

“In a manner of speaking. A triple X rated show, with lots of moaning and screaming, and you, balls deep in Lucy’s pussy. Or I can just show your little secret to the rest of the Guild. I’m sure Evergreen and Natsu would love to see it.”

Both Lucy and Elfman froze, a cold shiver crawling up their spines as they shared a look. They looked at the other for suggestions, but what could they do? Cana had them, leaving them with no other option than to play her game.

When Lucy glanced at her female friend again, her eyes widened at just how close Cana was. Their lips were mere inches apart as she stared into Lucy’s eyes with half-lidded, bedroom eyes. The long-haired woman leaned closer, only to whisper in the blond’s ear, her warm breath tickling Lucy’s ear.

“I saw you with Alzack and Bisca too. Food for thought, Lucy.”

“Then you know you don’t have to do this,” Lucy replied, her voice hushed, hoping Elfman wouldn’t hear. A giggle was Cana’s answer, before she spoke again, her breath stroking and caressing Lucy’s earlobe. 

“Because, Lucy, this is way more fun.” The strange part was, if the positions were reversed, Lucy would probably agree. Watching her and Elfman squirm was one hell of a show.

The worst/best part was that Cana knew neither of them would fight back. Lucy glanced at Elfman, and she was relieved to see his eyes on the floor, staring a hole through it. He hadn’t heard their conversation, it seemed. 

Cana had followed her gaze, her smile never leaving her face as she spoke. “What’s it going to be, Lucy? The hard way, or his ‘hard way?’” she joked, glancing at Elfman’s crotch. “Would it really be so bad to ride Elfman’s cock again?”

Well, no, and that was the difficult part. Well, one difficult part in an already impossible challenge. 

Elfman had a huge, wonderful cock, bigger than all of the other boys’ Lucy had slept with recently. Even bigger than Gajeel. There was a certain temptation to sleeping with him again, she admitted. To feel his strong arms and firm chest…

Lucy tore her eyes away from the giant of a man to look at Cana. She raised her brow, watching the blond slowly nod her head. Lucy surrendered to the woman, accepting her deal, even as Cana pulled Lucy closer. 

A quiet moan snapped Elfman out of his thoughts, and he looked to the source of that sound with wide eyes and a low, hanging jaw. 

Right in front of the man, right before his eyes, Cana and Lucy were kissing each other, arms wrapped tightly around the other girl as their breasts pushed against one another’s. Lucy’s eyes were open wide, before she shut them and returned the passion Cana gave her. The two moaned, shuddering as Elfman could see their tongues meeting between their mouths. 

Cana pushed Lucy back, just so she could catch the blond’s tongue with her lips and suck on the wet appendage. Lucy moaned, groping and squeezing the other woman’s large breasts in response. Her slender fingers slipped under the top, pinching Cana’s nipples until they were hard and poking against the thin fabric. Lucy soon began to pull on the top, and the two broke their kiss for a moment so Cana could pull the top off of her body, tossing it aside with nary a care.

Slowly their clothes continued to come off, pulled off of their hourglasses figures by the other woman. Cana unbuttoned Lucy’s top, letting Elfman spy the blond’s cleavage and soft, pink bra. Lucy took that off herself, undoing the hook on her back as Cana kissed and licked Lucy’s neck.

The kissing was getting more intense as the two girls glanced at Elfman with knowing, curious eyes. They smiled at him, the kind of affectionate, but teasing smile that left Elfman’s heart racing, pumping blood into his cock, bringing it to life in his pants.

The mound was clear to both girls as they glanced at it. They pulled away from each other and both stared at Elfman. Cana bit her lower lip, her eyes hungry with lust and hunger as she rubbed her legs together. Lucy’s gaze was slightly more controlled, but her eyes still showed the hungry desire she had. 

It felt so long since Elfman had fucked her hard and raw. She missed the feeling of those strong hands holding her down. Without even thinking about it, Lucy spread her legs apart, licking her lips. It was like she was trying to signal to Elfman.

He caught the message, and he removed his clothes, pulling the fabric off of his body. Lucy and Cana grinned, returning to kissing one another as Elfman’s dick hardened, throbbing and growing under his boxers.

As their tongues wrestled, Elfman freed his hard cock. Lucy was in the middle of sucking on Cana’s tongue when the penis was freed, and the blond suddenly pushed her friend away. Cana didn’t blame her as both girls stared at the tower of throbbing, sinful pleasure.

Elfman wrapped a hand around it, letting both of the girls eat up the sight of him jerking himself off. Somewhere in the back of his mind, a voice told him this was a bad idea. He told that voice to man up as the two women slowly approached him, even crawling on all fours for him.

The two beautiful women served him together, kissing each side of his cock, working as one to reach the top, before dragging their tongues back down. They rose back up to the tip of his cock, kissing the bulbous head, before slapping their tongues against it, moaning at the taste. 

Elfman shuddered, placing a hand on each girls’ head, stroking their long hair as they licked and sucked on the tip. Their tongues met around the shaft, and they tried to kiss each other with the prick between them. The sight of the two gorgeous women kissing each other, with his penis between them, and the sheer wonderful sensation of their double blowjob pushed him over the edge.

The man came, and his sperm was like a geyser for the two gorgeous women. It rained down on them, splattering against their faces and even onto their large breasts. The girls even leaned back, as if trying to cover themselves with his warm, thick sperm. When Elfman was done, the two women smiled at him, his seed dripping down their cheeks, foreheads, even dripping to the ground from their hair. 

Yet they still wanted more, judging by the sparks in their eyes.

“Lucy.” Cana’s voice both Lucy and Elfman’s attention. “Show me what you and Elfman did together that day.” The two knew exactly what Cana wanted to see, and despite their blushing faces, they looked at one another with an eager smile.

They gave Cana the show she so desperately wanted. Lucy crawled onto the bed, once again moving on all four as Elfman scooted back. He laid down on the ground, resting on a pillow as Lucy climbed on top of him, sitting on her knees as her pussy hovered over his throbbing cock.

The blond slowly descended upon his dick, and she moaned as the familiar, thick shaft split her open once again. Her pussy welcomed the penis, and the tight walls almost seemed to form around it, returning to the shape it fucked her into days ago.

Lucy made it halfway down his cock, before she lifted herself up and fell back down again. She moaned loudly, shaking as Elfman grinned. The beautiful blond was reduced to a quivering, trembling whore as Cana took advantage of the situation.

Cana sat behind Lucy, placing her hands on the blond’s already large breasts. She then placed her head on Lucy’s shoulder and kissed the the other woman’s cheek. When she turned to her, Cana made sure to kiss and lick Lucy’s lips, putting on another show for Elfman. 

The show worked. Elfman had never seen such beautiful women kissing before, and his cock throbbed inside of Lucy as she let out a loud cry of pleasure. He bucked his hips, before grabbing onto Lucy’s body and holding her. His hips moved back and forth, fucking her to the point where she was bouncing in his hands.

The bouncing made it hard to kiss Lucy, but Cana certainly thought it was worth it. She could practically hear the woman’s large tits bouncing against her chest! Instead of just kissing the woman, Cana moved her hands onto Lucy’s flat stomach, slowly moving down to massage and caress the blond’s clit as Elfman’s cock pounded away.

The sight of Cana’s hands playing with Lucy like she was some kind of toy sent the burly man over the edge. He closed his eyes and groaned, releasing another flood of semen into Lucy. The flood drove the woman over her own edge, and soon she was cumming as well. The walls of her pussy squeezed tight around Elfman’s shaft, milking it for seed as he unleashed his load inside of her. 

Cana watched the two, her smile replaced with a small pout. Lucy and Elfman were still trying to catch their breaths as the brunette pinched one of Lucy’s nipples, making her cry out, a mix of pain and pleasure in her voice.

“Don’t forget about me, Elfman. I want some cum too. Why don’t you give me some, doggystyle?” she asked, her eyes gleaming as Elfman grinned.

000

It wasn’t hard for the three to get in position. Elfman was on his knees now as Cana got on all fours. Lucy laid in front of the other woman, laying on her back, legs spread apart. Cana brought her head down, licking a trickle of seed all the way back to Lucy’s recently fucked pussy. The blond moaned as Elfman made his move.

He pushed his still hard cock into Cana, earning a satisfying mewl as the dark-haired woman trembled on his shaft.

“H-holy fuck, you’re impaling me on that monster…!”

“Amazing, i-isn’t it?” Lucy asked, before she placed a hand on the back of Cana’s head. She brought Cana back down to her pussy, shaking as Cana’s tongue traced the rim of Lucy’s pussy.

Elfman could hear both girls’ moans, Cana’s muffled and Lucy’s clear as day, and they were the coal to his fire. He dug his fingers into Cana’s soft skin, trying not to hurt her, but unable to hold back the temptation he felt.

He wanted to wreck Cana’s pussy, and that was exactly what he sought out to do. Elfman shoved his entire length into Cana’s womanhood with one, solid push. She screamed in pleasure, right into Lucy’s moist pussy. The vibrations went through her nerves bringing the blond endless pleasure as Elfman fucked Cana’s cunt.

“Oh, man, you are tight!” he chuckled, slapping the dark-haired woman’s ass. He made sure to hit just a bit harder with each swing of his hand, until he left a nice, red imprint on her asscheek. Cana moaned with every blow, shaking her ass as it jiggled from each blow. She kept licking at Lucy’s pussy, lifting her hands up to squeeze and play with the blond’s tits. 

The three worked perfectly with one another. Elfman would thrust into Cana, pushing her into Lucy’s pussy. Cana would lick and suck on the other girl’s cunt, making her moan and tremble from the pleasure, and the sight of Lucy quivering like a slut made Elfman’s already hard cock even harder, driving him to pound Cana harder and faster.

Soon they were cumming, one after the other like a glorious chain reaction. Elfman came first, pumping Cana full of his seed, letting it flood her pussy until his seed was dripping onto the bed sheets below them. 

Cana could feel the cum surging inside of her, and she welcomed it. Her eyes rolled into her skull as her lips pressed against Lucy’s pussy. Cana came, and she came hard with her eyes rolled into her skull and tongue slipping out between her lips. Cana moaned loudly, letting the vibrations surge against Lucy’s slit.  

Finally the buxom blond was cumming herself. Lucy was squeezing her eyes shut as her juices sprayed all over Cana’s face, marking her just like Elfman had marked both of them. Cana licked her lips, practically slurping up her friend’s juices as her pussy dripped more of Elfman’s seed onto the bed.

000

The next position the three took was something new for Lucy. Her looking up at Cana and Elfman, both smirking down at her. She watched as Cana held up a card and conjured an item to reality. Said item made both Lucy and Elfman blush as the brunette held it in her hand, teasingly. 

“Impressive, don’t you think?” she asked, holding up the strap-on. It was like a black dildo, with even bumps on the shaft, but most importantly it came complete with some straps for Cana to secure onto her body. “Are you ready for the fucking of your life?” Cana smirked, looking down upon Lucy.

“Y-yes,” the blond moaned, trembling with anticipation. She got on all fours as Cana spanked her ass, watching it jiggle from the blow. 

Cana and Elfman took advantage of Lucy, each taking a hole from either side of Lucy. The brunette got behind Lucy, letting the blond ride the strap on. The plastic toy pushed into Lucy’s soaking cunt, making her moan and tremble on the shaft. 

As Lucy rode Cana’s toy, the brunette placed her hands on Lucy’s tits and squeezed them, kneading the large breasts against Lucy’s chest. The large-breasted blond moaned, arching her back as the strap-on pushed deeper into her, emphasizing her chest without even meaning to.

Elfman stood before the two, cock out and bouncing before Lucy’s eyes. Cana lifted one of her hands off of her friend’s chest to grab the dick’s shaft, aiming it at Lucy’s mouth. Cana began jerking his cock back and forth, as if to deliver a load straight onto Lucy’s face. 

Lucy decided to help the brunette, opening her mouth and taking Elfman’s dickhead into her mouth, sucking on it as she bounced on Cana’s toy. Neither Elfman or Cana had to move much, they just sat back and enjoyed the show of Lucy bouncing between them. When Lucy was almost off of Cana’s strap-on, Elfman’s cock was going down her throat. When Elfman’s bell-shaped tip was on her tongue, Cana was metaphorically balls deep into Lucy, hands squeezing her tits. 

“I hope both of you girls are ready for more,” Elfman grinned, looking down on the two as Lucy moaned out his name. “I’m far from done.”

Elfman pulled his cock out of Lucy’s mouth, and it bounced before both of the beautiful women as they smiled. 

“He’s impressive,” Cana commented.

“Yeah. I know,” Lucy giggled. 

Elfman stepped forward, and Lucy tilted her head to the side, licking and kissing the side of his shaft as Cana sucked on the tip of his prick. The two beauties worked together, driving Elfman over the edge within a few seconds. 

He came over the two, once again releasing his seed onto their faces and chests. His cum rained down upon them in jets and streams, splattering onto Lucy’s tits and trickling down her cleavage as another jet fell upon Cana’s face, flowing down into her mouth. 

Even after the load of cum, both women were grinning as they licked their lips. They were ready for more.

000

“So you promise to destroy the photo?” Lucy asked.

“Of course. A deal’s a deal, after all.”

“Good…” Elfman sighed in relief as water poured down on the three. It was a bit crowded for all of them in the shower, but they made it work.

Elfman was sitting on a stool inside the shower, a stoic frown on his face as the water pelted his chest. Lucy and Cana were on their knees, their tits wrapped around Elfman’s cock as they made out with each other, with the man’s penis between their tongues once more.

The man moaned quietly, his voice hidden by the hiss of the shower as he leaned down to either of his sides. He pressed his fingers against both women’s entrances, one at a time. When his fingers slipped into their pussies to tease them, both women reacted the same way. Moaning and shuddering from his touch…

Cana and Lucy pulled their mouths away from each other’s, licking their lips as Elfman’s cock stood erect between them. Their tits were still wrapped around it as Cana popped a question. 

“So, Lucy, are you still going to be sleeping around after Natsu comes back?”

Lucy didn’t reply, her mind too clouded by a fog of lust. She opened her mouth, but rather than answer, she went down on Elfman’s shaft, sucking his cock, the loud suction and gagging filling the bathroom. Cana giggled, placing a hand on Lucy’s head to push the girl lower down the thick shaft. 

As the three continued their fun, Lucy’s phone vibrated in the bedroom.

‘Can’t wait to come home, Lucy. See ya soon!’ it read. ‘Love ya!’