Prompt: The Perfect Night (Persona)

Summary: Sae and Ren have been dating for months now, and things have been perfect. They come to Sae's home after a fantastic date, and soon are making love together. Of course, then Makoto comes home. Summary: Romance and quiet sex. 

---

Sae couldn’t remember the last time she had laughed so much. She couldn’t remember the last time she had smiled this much or had such a good time. Her face actually hurt from how much she was smiling with Ren. 

Part of her still couldn’t believe that this was her life now. She, Sae Niijima, on a date with a seemingly perfect guy, and she only used the word seemingly because of her own cynical nature. 

Yet even she had a hard time ruining the perfect life she had with Ren. 

Ren really was just… perfect. Far more mature than his age would imply, more mature than any of her co-workers, kind, respectful, intelligent, everything she could ever want in a man, and everything she never knew she needed. 

“Thankfully we were able to put the woman away. She won’t be able to hurt anyone in jail.”

“Sounds like you really did the city a service,” Ren commented, as he walked his girlfriend back to her home.

The two had been dating for over a year now. Ever since he and his Phantom Thieves saved the world, and he and Sae spent Christmas together. Things just clicked together, and even when he sat behind bars, Sae’s heart yearned for the young man who stole her heart.

Of course, no one could see Sae in such a state. She had made it clear to her boyfriend that she wanted to keep what they had hidden, at least until she was ready to tell Makoto and the others about their bond. 

And Ren was okay with that, and Sae found another reason to love the handsome man. 

Ever since he returned to Tokyo, this time permanently, he and Sae had been spending almost every night together. Date after date, they enjoyed each other’s company, and Sae loved it…

She might have even loved him… No, she was sure she did. It was just impossible to utter those words.

“Yes, well… I’m no Phantom Thief, but I make do,” Sae smiled. 

“You’d make one hell of a Phantom Thief,” Ren grinned, before he stopped. He glanced to the side, looking at the door to Sae and Makoto’s home. “Well, guess this is where I take my leave. See you tomorrow?”

“W-wait.” Sae’s hand rose up, and she blushed as he looked at her. Sae’s hand fell limply by her side as she let out a small smile, avoiding his eyes. “Um... “ Rarely in Sae’s life did she show hesitation. 

Yet Ren always brought out… different sides of her. 

“Would you like to come inside? For coffee?” she asked. 

“Coffee? In the middle of the night?” Ren chuckled. “Seems kind of counter intuitive, unless you think I’ll need that extra energy for something.” His tone was clear, and it made Sae’s cheeks feel hot. It made her heart skip a beat, and her body tremble. 

He saw right through her, and that excited her. He could read her so easily, even when she was interrogating him, there was something about those eyes that stared deep into her soul. She found herself licking her lips as one of her hands began to play with her hair, a nervous habit she had picked up when she was younger. 

She couldn’t remember the last time she felt this nervous… well, except on Christmas Eve when Ren and her spent Christmas together and kissed… and did much more than just kiss. 

“Are you doing anything tomorrow?” she asked, finally turning her eyes to his. 

“Wasn’t planning on it. Were you?”

“I have tomorrow off, so…” Ren’s hand fell on her hip, sliding down her body, stroking her leg, before it rose back up and he gave her ass a soft squeeze. Sae smiled at the sensation, her cheeks a rosy hue as she stepped closer to her boyfriend. 

Her breasts touched his chest through the fabric of her dress as they smiled at one another, before they both entered her home one after the other.

---

Sae moaned as Ren’s lips against hers. Her ruby lips pressed against his, sucking on his tongue as his hands groped and squeezed her breasts. She was in her underwear by now, and he was only in his boxers and shirt as his hands explored her tits. He felt them squeezed them, and dug his fingers into them.

Sae loved the feeling of his hands on her body. Their tongues danced as his hands moved from her breasts to her back, stroking her soft skin, before finding her bra. 

With the kind of skill that most men her age lacked, Ren took off her bra and tossed it aside, throwing it off the bed as they broke their kiss. Sae was blushing, and even her boyfriend had a small blush on his face. 

“May I?” he asked. 

Ever the gentleman. Oh, how she loved that about him. She nodded her head, showing her meeker side to the man who stole her heart. He pulled her bra off of her, and she let him, helping him, before letting him see her full, supple breasts on her chest. 

She blushed as she laid back on her bed, placing her arms just under her tits. This wasn’t the first time he had seen her topless, yet Sae still wasn’t used to his eyes on her body. She gulped as she looked at him, watching his reaction.

His lips parted, his eyes widened, and he breathing quickened subtly. There was a fire in his eyes, a hunger, and it was all for her. He didn’t stare at any other girl like that. Only her. Just her. 

Sae’s heart pounded in her chest as she lifted her hands to wrap them around Ren’s neck. “I love you,” she whispered, and his silver eyes gleamed as he nodded his head. 

“I love you too, Sae.”

They kissed once more as her hands moved down his body, grabbing at his clothes now. His shirt came off, tossed down by her dress, before she hooked his hands into his boxers. She pulled them down, and he pulled his legs out to help her. 

Soon he was naked, and all she had on left were her panties. She stroked his chest with her slender fingers, tracing his muscle structure as their eyes met again.

“I love your eyes,” he whispered. 

Here she was, lying topless, almost completely naked, and that was what he said. She wrapped her arms around his head, kissing him passionately as his hard, throbbing cock rubbed against her inner thighs. 

It wasn’t easy, but Sae started to take off her underwear. It was only hard because her lips refused to stay away from Ren’s, but she managed. She felt his dick rub against her skin again, and she imagined that cock taking her once more. 

It was so embarrassing to admit, but she couldn’t lie. She really loved the way Ren made her feel when they made love…

Her panties came off, and his dick rubbed against her wet, slick pussy. She shuddered, breaking the kiss as her arms held onto his neck. 

“F-fuck me,” she begged. 

And Ren obeyed, pushing his cock into her with a gentle push. He entered her, and immediately her mind felt like it was being overwhelmed. She felt every inch push into her, and every inch sent her mind reeling. Her heart drummed in her chest as all she saw were colors and stars, a smile on her face as her stoic nature was left shattered.

“Oh, fuck…. Ren!” 

He leaned down, kissing her neck, sucking on the soft flesh so that he could leave red marks on her skin. His hand groped her breasts, squeezing her tit as his thumb pressed into her nipple. 

Ren’s penis continued to sink into her, filling her, and in return, her pussy squeezed tight around his cock. 

It was heavenly. It was amazing. It was the greatest sensation in Sae’s life. Tonight was turning into the perfect night for her, but that was when she heard something. Something that made her blood turn cold. 

The door to Sae and Makoto’s apartment opened, and a voice called out. “Sae? I’m home!” 

The silver-haired woman’s eyes shot open, wide as plates as Ren froze against her, his cock buried inside her pussy. Neither said anything, eyes wide as they heard Makoto’s footsteps outside Sae’s room. 

‘Why is Makoto here?! She’s supposed to be hanging out with Futaba!’ Sae thought with rushed, almost terrified thoughts. 

“Hm. Must still be out at work,” Makoto thought aloud. Her voice was muffled, yet still clear behind the walls of their apartment. Sae and Ren looked at one another, eyes locked as Sae placed a hand over her ruby lips. 

Ren stared at his girlfriend… and a conniving, almost cruel smile formed on his face. Sae’s heart stopped for a moment as she realized the evil thoughts brewing in her boyfriend’s head, but before she could do anything to stop him, he began to move his hips back, slowly pulling his cock out of her, only to push it all back in again.

Sae shivered, shaking from the shockwaves of pleasure running through her. She looked at Ren, placing her hand on his chest to silently tell him to stop, but he just kept moving, dragging his thick cock along the inner walls of her womanhood, sending jolt after jolt of pleasure into her. 

Sae pressed one hand against her lips, muffling her moans as the other smacked Ren’s chest. She glared at him as he mouthed, ‘I love you,’ before he kept fucking her, sliding his dick in and out again. 

It felt so good, but Makoto was literally a few feet away! But her arm wasn’t listening to her. It stopped pushing Ren, and began to stroke his chest, dragging her nails along his skin as he continued to fuck her. 

He pressed their bodies together, fucking Sae faster as the bed gently rocked from the pounding. Sae’s eyes almost vanished into her skull as Ren kept fucking her, when another sound made the two stop.

Sae’s phone rang, playing a melody. The two pulled apart, with his dick still in her, and they looked at the phone on the bed, finding Makoto’s name on it. Sae’s hand smacked against it, clumsily trying to silence it as a voice called out. 

“Sae? Are you home?” 

The older woman couldn’t run the risk of Makoto walking in on them! She didn’t even know Sae was dating Ren, and this was a terrible way for her to find out!

“Y-yes, Makoto! I was just a-asleep!” 

“Oh. Is everything okay? How was your night?”

“F-fine. Just fi-ine!” Sae gasped, feeling Ren pushing his cock into her again, pressing the tip against her walls. She melted from the touch, shaking as her pussy squeezed the younger man’s dick. 

“Are you okay, Sae?”

“Yes! J-just had a nightmare. I’m fine, Makoto!” 

“Alright. Did you already eat dinner? I brought leftovers from Leblanc.”

“I-I’m okay, Makoto! I-ah… I’m going to go back to sleep n-now!” Sae panted, feeling Ren’s dick press against her G-spot. He smiled down at her, before he began to kiss her neck once more.

“Alright. I’ll probably go to sleep too. Goodnight, Sae.”

“G-goodni-ight!” Sae’s eyes fell shut and she shuddered as she felt her body cumming. Her pussy wrapped tight around Ren’s shaft as the older woman came on her boyfriend’s cock.

Her muscles spasmed and her body trembled as every piece of her felt like it was exploding from the sensation. Every part of her felt warm and every part of her felt like it was pressing against Ren as he came inside of her, coating the walls of her pussy with his seed as he wrapped his arms around her and pressed his lips against her neck. 

He held her with such loving strength as Sae tried to keep her voice quiet, letting out a low, but powerful moan as she felt his seed spill inside of her. 

When the two’s orgasms finally subsided, they looked at one another with tired, but happy smiles… at least until Sae remembered what her boyfriend had done. She gently smacked his head, and he chuckled as she glared at him. 

“You… you…” She sighed, shaking her head as Ren kissed her cheek. 

“I love you too, gorgeous.”

“You’re impossible.”

“You wouldn’t want me any other way.” The two pulled apart and laid beside one another, not caring as the bed was stained with their juices. They faced one another as they stared into each other’s eyes, a peace falling over them as the excitement of the night finally caught up to them.

Sae yawned, pressing her face against her pillow as Ren laid his on another right beside her. 

“You mad at me?” he asked.

“Yes,” she muttered, closing her eyes. “But I’ll punish you tomorrow. For now, I just want to fall asleep in my arms.” 

“Looking forward to it, beautiful.”

And Ren wrapped his arms around her, eagerly awaiting whatever punishment Sae had in mind for him. He pecked her forehead as the two fell asleep against one another.