Prompt: The King's Game Ch. 2 (Fairy Tail)

Summary: After a short conversation to calm their nerves, Team Natsu, plus Juvia, continue their game. Includes: Romance, threesomes. 

---

Lucy let out a small gasp as she and her friends entered the hot springs. It was a beautiful and amazing sight. The water sparkled under the light of the moon and stars, and a single touch told each of them that the serene waters were warm, waiting for them to enter. 

The peace and serenity of the scene was especially welcomed for Lucy. She sighed in relief as she placed under hand under the water. She still felt a sense of unease from the group’s activity, specifically her own feelings during it. 

She tried to brush it all aside as she looked to the others. She could Natsu was already feeling ready for more, so she spoke up. “Why don’t we just rest and take it easy for a while? Enjoy ourselves.”

Thankfully everyone seemed to agree with her idea, and as everyone began to enjoy the springs, Lucy stood up and pulled her boyfriend aside. The two walked to a corner of the hot springs as the others took their own corners. Juvia and Gray were together, while Erza seemed content to be alone for now.

Natsu raised his brow as Lucy pulled on him, only to look into her eyes. With just a glance, he understood that something was troubling her heart, and he spoke first, his voice a quiet whisper. “What’s wrong?” 

“I… Trust me, you won’t like it,” she sighed, glancing away from him as her body sank into the warm pool. Natsu placed his hands on her, lifting her up. Her feet weren’t even touching the ground, yet he effortlessly held her in his hands.

“Come on, talk to me.” She glanced at him, her cheeks a dark shade of red, before she sighed. 

“I feel… wrong,” she admitted. Natsu raised his brow, and she continued. “What we did in the room, it felt… It felt amazing, but it also didn’t feel right.”

“It was all in good fun, Lucy.”

“I-I know, but it’s just… I feel bad about what I did with Gray, but the worst part about it was that it also felt really, really good,” she whimpered. 

“Lucy.” Natsu placed his hands on Lucy’s shoulders, and the blond gulped as her boyfriend smiled at her. “It was all just fun. What you felt, even what you’re feeling now, it’s all part of the fun,” he explained, and Lucy’s eyes fell to the water below her. 

“I mean, I said stuff I feel kind of… w-weird about. A-and having sex with Juvia, it was… well, I’m not ashamed to admit it wasn’t bad. D-different, but not bad.” he explained. “I feel the same way you do, I bet. It was great, but it was pretty weird. I mean, being with both Juvia and Erza...”

Lucy and Natu’s cheeks turned red together as they both thought of the threesome the pink-haired boy had experienced. The young man coughed, before he took Lucy’s face in his hands and made her look at him.

“But you know what? I will always love you, no matter what. That will never change. Juvia and Erza could themselves at me, you could throw yourself at Grey, and I’d still love you the most out of everything, and everyone.”

There were tears in Lucy’s eyes as she stared at her boyfriend’s blushing face. He looked away as she leaned in closer, before looking at her right before she embraced him. The two held one another, and Natsu slowly began to smile as he hugged her back. 

Lucy squeezed her boyfriend’s body as she pressed her breasts against his muscular chest. She kissed his naked skin as she felt a wave of relief wash over her. She had been scared that Natsu would have been mad at her, but she should of known better. 

Natsu loved her still. He always would. 

The two shared a quick, but loving peck, before their eyes moved over the area. They spot Juvia walking towards them, motioning to Gray and Erza. 

“I hate to break up your moment, but we were just wondering if you’d be joining us?” She smiled at the two, and Lucy looked at Natsu. 

Her fingers pressed against his skin as he smiled, stroking her back. “It’s just for tonight. It’s no problem, Lucy. You don’t have to say yes, but if you want to…” 

Lucy blushed, wondering just when Natsu became the more rational and calm headed of the two of them. 

“Besides, when this is all over, I’ll fuck you all day when we get home,” he promised, eyes narrowing as he kissed her cheek. Lucy felt her heart skip a beat at that promise, and his smirk only made her legs tremble as his teeth gleamed. 

“O-okay,” she uttered, nodding her head as she smiled. 

The two lovers pulled away, giving each other one last glance, before they moved to their new partners for the night.

Lucy swam to Gray, who was sitting at the edge of the pool. She climbed onto him, sitting on his lap as he watched her with sharp, enchanting eyes. He helped her sit on him, before watching her go in for a kiss. 

He placed a hand on her breast, trying to get her to slow down as he spoke. “Lucy, I spoke to Juvia, and-mmph?!” Gray’s eyes widened in shock as Lucy actually kept moving forward, silencing him with her lips on his. 

The dark-haired man moaned into her mouth, before he melted into it. He felt her tits rub against him as his eyes fell shut, just like hers. The kiss went on for a few more seconds, only for Gray to pull away when he felt Lucy’s tongue rubbing against his lips, clearly trying to slip into his mouth. 

Gray’s eyes opened and he pulled his head back. Lucy smiled at that, before she said, “Natsu and I talked to. Everything is okay between us.”

“Well, that’s good… Still, you could have let me fin-” Lucy kissed him again, and this time Gray thought, ‘What the hell?’ and kissed back.;

Her tongue slipped out of her mouth, and this time Gray welcomed her into his as the two kissed. Their tongues wrestled as their moans began to meld together. Gray’s hands fell on her back, stroking her skin as Lucy’s fingers stroked his smooth chest.

As the kiss became more and more passionate, Gray moaned louder against Lucy’s lips. He felt the blood inside of him rushing down, making his cock rise against Lucy’s firm ass. The hard prick poked against her skin, and Lucy only made it worse as she ground her butt against him. He felt her lips curl into a smile as he moved his hand down.

Gray dug his fingers into Lucy’s ass, before he gave her butt a smack, making her squeak with surprise, before moaning as he gave her butt another squeeze. He alternated between the two, smacking her ass, before groping it, but both had the same result.

Turning on the buxom blond grinding against his cock.

“Fuck me… Doggystyle,” she begged, breaking the kiss to whisper into his ear.

The young man grinned, and obeyed, fucking her right there on the edge of the hot spring. She laid on all fours, on her hands and knees, and she moaned as she felt that cock pushed into her. It filled her perfectly, and she trembled with every inch sinking into her. 

Lucy almost fell as she felt his crotch press against her, but she kept herself up as her eyes moved to find Erza touching herself. The red-haired woman was fingering her own pussy, while her other hand squeezed and groped her own large breast.

Then Lucy saw her boyfriend and Juvia, and the blue-haired woman was bouncing on the young man’s cock, moaning as her tits bounced before her eyes. Lucy felt a similar feeling of shame and excitement fill her, before she noticed something.

Natsu’s eyes on her, staring at her over Juvia’s shoulder. He smiled at her, and as Gray fucked Lucy’s womanhood, pressing their bodies together, Lucy smiled back.

Gray kept his pace, fucking Lucy so hard the woman’s entire body trembled with each thrust. Her pussy squeezed around his cock as he looked at Juvia and Natsu. Gray wore a smile on his face he fucked Lucy faster, feeling like it was a competition between him and his rival.

Lucy certainly didn’t mind. She continued to moan, quivering as her pussy tightened around Gray’s shaft. The warmth and tightness of her pussy made the dark-haired man moan, and together the two came. Neither was sure who came first, they were too lost to the pleasure as Gray’s semen coated the inside of Lucy’s pussy. 

He gave her ass a smack as her pussy milked his penis. Not even a single drop slipped out of her as the two adjusted, moving so that Gray could keep fucking her in another position. His cock didn’t come out of her, even as they moved so they were facing one another. They reseumed fucking now in the missionary position.

Gray went in rough, pounding the smaller woman as she wrapped her arms around him. Her tits pressed against his chest as he took his hands and moved them onto her tits. She moaned, a fucked silly smile on her face as his fingers dug into her soft tits. His thumbs dug into her nipples, rolling them under his touch as she gasped and mewled. 

“Ah, G-Gray! H-harder!” she begged, and Gray was happy to give her just that.

Lucy pulled Gray down, letting her lips brush against his ear as she moaned. “You better-ah… You better make me scream…” Hearing her low, husky voice begging for him… It turned him on even more as Gray’s thrusts went even faster. 

Gray lifted up one of her legs over his shoulder, giving him a new angle to fuck Lucy. The young woman screamed as she felt his cock plunge even deeper into her, pressing against a different spot now. She felt the bulbous tip of his cock slam into a spot of nerves untouched by Natsu, and her cries echoed throughout the springs. Her cries even left Juvia’s cries in the dust…

“Ah, fuck… Your pussy’s so tight,” Gray growled, thrusting his hips into her again and again. Lucy held onto him as tightly as she could, digging her fingers into his back as her hot breath pelted his chest. 

“Gray, I… I’m gonna cum,” Lucy moaned.

“Then cum!” he grinned, slamming into her pussy at an even faster rate. “I want to feel your pussy squeezing my cock,” he growled, and Lucy’s heart nearly skipped a beat as he looked down at her like he owned her.

Lucy’s nails dug into Gray’s skin as she trembled, cumming under the man. Her muscles spasmed, tightening her pussy around his throbbing penis. She could feel his rod twitching, before he came inside of her right after her own orgasm.

The two rod their climaxes together, bodies shaking against one another as they cried out once more. They held the other so tightly, sweaty skin sticking to the other as they panted. This time some of his sperm did spill out of her pussy, dripping onto the ground as they tried to catch their breath..

The two were panting as Gray stroked Lucy’s back. He looked at her and grinned. “How about a blowjob?” And Lucy smiled back as she asked him to sit up.

He sat on the edge of the hot spring as Lucy got into the water to suck his still hard cock. She wrapped her lips around the cum-covered treat, moaning as her tongue rubbing alongside the shaft. She moaned as she bobbed her head up and down, letting the savory treat slide along her tongue and press against the inside of her cheek.

She gave it a loud suck, feeling it dive down her throat as she moaned. Gray placed a hand on her head, enjoying the show as Lucy’s tongue smacked against the underside of his dick. She moaned against his sensitive flesh, only to stop when he felt his climax coming closer.

“H-hey, why’d you stop?” he asked, watching her lift her head off of his dick. Lucy didn’t say anything in return. She just took her breasts in hand, lifting them up so that Gray got a good look, before she wrapped her tits around his glistening shaft. “Ahh…”

Her tits were so soft, and so big. He struggled to control himself as the sides of her tits stroked up and down his dick. He could feel her press her tits together, engulfing him. He could feel how warm her body was, and the race of her heartbeat.

It all felt so good, and soon Gray was cumming from Lucy’s boobjob. In the back of his mind, he wondered if Natsu ever got the honor of feeling Lucy’s tits around his cock.

Part of him wished Natsu didn’t…

Gray came from Lucy’s tits, spraying his seed onto her face, hair, and especially her large breasts. His white, sticky seed coated her pale, flawless skin. He covered her as she moaned, feeling his penis throbbing between her tits. 

She was panting, drenched in his seed as she lifted herself up. Her hot breath brushed against his ear as she whispered, “Do you want me to ride you like before?”

“Of course,” he replied, licking his teeth as his cock stood hard even after all this. She smiled, and he pulled her onto his lap once more. 

The two kissed once more. Gray didn’t even show an ounce of hesitation as his and Lucy’s tongue met. Their tongues danced as she climbed back onto him and sank down on his cock, feeling it fill her once more.

She bounced on top of him, tits clapping against her chest as their hands stroked one another. They were both moaning, crying out in pleasure as tongues tasted one another. Gray’s hands moved up Lucy’s body, feeling her large breasts against his hands. 

Her pussy tightened when his fingers pinched her nipples, and she broke the kiss to stare into his eyes. She was blushing as he moaned, feeling his balls twitch under her. He opened his mouth, and he took one of her nipples into his mouth, sucking on it as she bounced. 

Lucy cried out his name, shaking as Gray’s lips suckled on her chest. She could feel her orgasm coming… She could herself about to lose control. She welcomed it as she screamed out, “Ahh! Ahh! G-Gray!”

For the third time, Lucy came on Gray’s cock, trembling as she felt his sperm filled her insides. His seed coated the inside of her womanhood as more cum spilled out of her, dripping down onto the ground in large globs of semen. 

“Hey, Lucy! Gray! You two wanna finish things together?” Natsu shouted, catching the attention of the two exhausted lovers. Lucy and Gray glanced at him, both out of breath as they smiled and nodded their heads.

The guys laid down while their lady lovers rode their cocks, face to face with one another. Both men gave the same expecting, hopeful stare, and both girls knew exactly what they wanted to see. 

Lucy and Juvia leaned towards the other, kissing each other as Erza sat nearby. The scarlet-haired woman leaned forward, joining the two beauties’ kiss. All three girls kissed, tongues wrestling as Juvia and Erza tasted Gray on Lucy’s tongue. They moaned as their lips brushed against one another and tongues tasted the others…

“Are you having fun?” Erza teased, leaning back as the two women continued to kiss like they were lovers.

They finally ended the kiss, both panting as they stared into each other’s eyes. “So much fun,” Lucy panted.

“Mmmhmm. Tons of fun.”

“I’m glad. Would you mind?” Erza’s hands led the other girls’ hands to her pussy, and they obeyed, finger fucking the busty redhead. 

They fingered Erza as one, pushing a single finger each into the commanding queen. She moaned loudly, panting as her pussy squeezed their digits. She bounced on their fingers, tongues wrestling with them, as Natsu and Gray watched with approving eyes. 

Lucy felt Gray’s cock pounding her pussy. Juvia screamed as she felt Natsu’s penis press against her G-spot. Erza mewled as her body trembled from the slender fingers inside of her…

All three girls came together, their voices melding together as Erza and Natsu filled their respective lover with their seed. 

Both girls were left panting as they lifted their bodies off of their man, before both fell by the other’s side. They laid on their boyfriend’s arm, feeling their true love embracing them as Erza sat back, trying to catch her own breath.

Both couples had the same exact going through their minds as they all basked in the light of the moon and stars. As they cuddled against their boyfriend’s arm, they thought about how wonderful tonight had been, how much fun they had together…

And that they shouldn’t play King’s Game with Erza ever again.