Prompt: Sharing Ren (Persona 5)

 Summary: Unsure of who to date, Ren lays in his bed, confused and horny. That's when he gets a couple of uninvited guests, Futaba and Kasumi, slipping into his room to help him decide who to pick. Includes: Threesome

---

Ren slept peacefully on his bed. As much as he loved having Morgana around, it was nice to finally have his bed all to himself. The small cat was with Ann this night, enjoying a movie marathon, apparently.

Whatever they decided to do together, Ren was just happy to sleep when he wanted to, and without having Morgana somehow end up on his face or something.

So Ren slept soundly, and as he slept, he dreamed.

He dreamed of Ann’s beautiful blond hair, bouncing up and down as she sucked on his cock, bobbing her head up and down between photoshoots. Her blue eyes were on him, and her tongue slid along the underside of his dick as one of her hands rubbed against his balls.

Ren shuddered in his sleep, pressing his face against his pillow as his dreams changed in a sleepy second. He dreamed of Makoto and her thick, yet slender legs, wrapped tightly around him as he fucked her. She had her arms around him, bouncing her up and down his dick as he held onto her. 

She moaned loudly as she proclaimed her love for him… Then he gave her a kiss, silencing her moans as her pussy tightened around his dick…

And then, just like that, Makoto was replaced with Haru Okumura, and the auburn-haired beauty was kneeling before Ren, tits out, and staring at him with bright eyes and rosy cheeks. She’d ask him if she was doing it right as she took her breasts in hand and wrapped them around his throbbing erection.

She’d sucked on the tip, and Ren found his dick hardening in his pajamas as he imagined the stacked woman servicing him. 

And from her, he was with Futaba, pressing his dick against her tight ass, pushing his cock into her as she moaned and dug her fingers into his bed. She’d drool onto his bed, leaving a stain as she bucked her hips, trying to get more of his cock inside of her. 

He’d spank her cute butt, only for Kasumi to suddenly tackle Ren down onto his bed. His dream changed once more, and Kasumi was riding him, bouncing on his cock as her hands stroked his naked chest. She cried out in pleasure, panting as she felt his hands on her own chest, feeling her supple breasts…

Yes, Ren was having a bit of trouble figuring out which girl to date, and ‘play’ with. His eyes shot open right before the climax, literally in this case, and he glared at his ceiling in the dark of his room. 

His dick was hard under his clothes, and he frowned as he thought to himself, ‘Not again.’ Least Morgana wasn’t around. He didn’t want to try and hide the damn thing again. 

It was just so hard to pick one! All of the girls he knew were beautiful in their own way, and he loved all of them, but worst of all, he lusted after all of them. 

Ren laid in his bed, just glaring a hole through the ceiling as he considered what to do. Should he just masterbate and hope he could go to sleep afterwards? He had to get up early for school tomorrow…

Speaking of school, Sadayo Kawakami was a gorgeous, gorgeous woman. God, the way her clothes squeezed her breasts, the way her beautiful lips moved for every word and lesson, the way her legs-

Ah. This was not helping in the least. Ren sighed, wondering if he got a girlfriend, would this problem end? Or was he just cursed to be as big of a pervert as he was? He laid on his back, rubbing his eyes as he contemplated his next move, when he heard something unmistakable. 

The door to Leblanc opening downstairs. 

Ren didn’t need to look at a clock to know that it couldn’t have been Sojiro. He listened closely, finding that the footsteps were pretty light, far too light for a man of Sojiro’s age and weight. Not to mention there was definitely two people downstairs.

He listened to them move as quietly as they could, probably too quiet for any normal teenager to hear, but Ren was a Phantom Thief. He listened to the sound with acute ears, hearing the intruders walk up the stairs to his room.

Was he being attacked? Did someone discover his identity and want to take him out? Or was this unrelated to him? Were they just a couple of stupid burglars out to try and rob the place? Either way, Ren wasn’t going to just lay around and do nothing. 

He was ready to spring into action and fight the two intruders, when a familiar voice shrieked.

“Ow!” 

“Futaba, careful! Are you okay?”

“Y-yeah. Just hit my toe on the step.”

Wait. That was Futaba, and that voice definitely belonged to Kasumi, the team’s newest member. 

What the hell were they doing inside Leblanc at this hour? It was early in the morning, just on the corner between morning and night, before even Sojiro arrived to set up his store. Why?

The two girls snuck into Ren’s attic, but rather than confront the two girls about why, Ren decided to have a bit more fun. So he closed his eyes and put on the most calm expression he could as Futaba and Kasumi found his ‘sleeping’ body.

“Is he asleep?” Futaba whispered.

“Think so,” Kasumi replied. The two girls moved closer, and Ren almost opened his eyes as he felt them actually get onto his bed. He was growing more and more curious about why these two girls were in his home, and why they were sneaking around like this in the middle of the night.

“Are you ready?” Kasumi inquired, and judging by the sound of it, she was sitting on his bed. 

“Mmhm! You ready?” Futaba replied. 

“As ready as I’ll ever be, I suppose,” she sighed. 

Ready? Ready for what? 

One of Ren’s eyes opened, and in the dark of his room, neither girl noticed one of his silver eyes spying on them. That silver eye bounced between them, before suddenly widening as he watched Futaba shrug her jacket off of her body and watching Kasumi unbuttoning her coat.

Their clothes fell to the ground as Kasumi stood up, pulling her top off of her body as Futaba pulled her own shirt off. 

What were they doing?! Well, the answer to that was obvious. They were stripping their clothes off, but why? Ren almost spoke, but his teeth bit down on his tongue, keeping himself quiet as the two girls continued to strip. 

Futaba wasn’t wearing a bra, and when she was down to her panties, she leaned forward, looking at Kasumi’s covered breasts. Ren could see the orange-haired woman staring and ogling the redhead’s breasts, and Kasumi tried to cover herself as Futaba smiled.

“Wooow… Kasumi, your boobs are so big. Looks like Haru has a new challenger.”

“F-Futaba, quit looking!” Kasumi hissed, her voice a low, and desperate, whisper. “It’s… weird.”

“What’s weird about it? We’re both girls.” Futaba tilted her head, before shrugging and pulling down her pink panties. They fell to the floor and she kicked the panties off, before getting onto the bed.

Ren’s eye widened again as he watched Futaba slip under his blanket. He could feel her hands brushing against his legs as she crawled under his blanket. Ren bit the inside of his cheek to keep himself quiet, while his eye locked onto the very pretty Kasumi.

The beautiful redhead undid her bra, and her supple tits bounced free. She was a deceptively stacked woman under her tight clothes, and her slender body was exactly what one would expect from a gymnast. She pulled her panties down her long, slender legs, and Ren could feel his dick hardening as he watched her stand naked by his bed, before she joined Futaba under his blanket.

Ren opened both of his eyes while both girls were under his blanket, but he kept his lips sealed, even as he felt their soft hands on his body, stroking his legs, before they suddenly pulled down his underwear. 

“Alright, let’s see the goods,” Futaba whispered, practically drooling as Kasumi gulped.

“W-what…? I-it’s… it’s huge,” Kasumi gasped. She gulped, shaking as she and Futaba’s placed their hands on Ren’s semi-hard cock. “He feels so hard, and yet soft,” she commented, marveling at the sensation as Ren struggled to control his breathing.

“He must be having a wet dream… I bet he’s thinking of you and your big butt,” the younger girl teased, making Kasumi gasp quietly. 

She wasn’t wrong, but Ren struggled to control himself as he felt their hands playing with his member. He couldn’t take much more of this, and he finally spoke up as he sat up.

“W-what exactly are you two doing?” 

Kasumi gasped as Futaba nearly screamed, falling back and taking the blanket with her. Futaba hit the ground, tangled and wrapped up in the blanket as Ren looked at the scarlet-faced redhead. Kasumi blinked, staring Ren in the eyes as he stared back at her.

“You’re supposed to be asleep,” she muttered, trying to stand her ground.

“I’m clearly not.” Futaba popped her head out from her blanket prison, and she blushed as she looked at the raven-haired man. 

“H-hi, Key Item…”

“Explain. Please.” Kasumi covered her breasts, but Ren noticed Futaba didn’t as she looked away. 

“Well, Kasumi and I had been talking lately, and well… Uh… I wanted to show Kasumi your package,” she explained. 

“So you came to look at my penis?” he asked, glancing down at his erection. He hadn’t covered it yet, letting it just stand tall between his legs as Kasumi coughed into her hand.

“No. She already showed me.”

“What?”

“I have footage of you changing,” the young hacker explained. “And… touching yourself to porn.” Futaba’s eyes fell down her body as Ren’s eyes widened.

“Wait, what? How did you-?”

“I… I have cameras set up in your room…”

“Cameras? Plural?!” 

“I-I put them up cause I wanted to make sure you wouldn’t steal stuff from the cafe!” Futaba explained, holding up her hands. “But I noticed you walking around naked a-a lot,” she squeaked. “A-and how you like to touch yourself to the thought of… us.”

Ren’s face was a bright, bright shade of red as he listened to the young girl. Unfortunately, she was right. He did walk around naked a lot. It was just comfortable for him. Clothes were such a hassle, if he was living alone, why not just walk around naked?

And yes… He did touch himself to his friends. A lot. Images flashed through his mind, imagining Futaba watching him as he jerked himself off, as he came to the thought of Futaba’s sleeping face or Haru’s large breasts or Ann’s plump rear or Makoto’s soft lips…

Fuck. The more he thought about, the more turned on he was getting. His dick was getting even harder, and both girls seemed to notice it. They eyed his cock, watching the thing throb as Ren blushed.

“And so you came here to… touch my penis?”

“We came here to share you,” Kasumi confessed, looking Ren in the eyes as she leaned forward. “After Futaba showed me her videos of you, I-I just couldn’t get you out of my mind. And after I saw you touching yourself to the thought of me, I knew… I knew that I wanted to make your fantasy a reality.”

Her hand slid down, and her fingers wrapped around his shaft as Ren gulped spit down his throat. His eyes met with Kasumi’s as the redhead licked her lips. 

“I know you touched yourself to the thought of us giving you a blowjob.” Futaba climbed onto the bed, leaving the blanket behind as she walked on all fours to Ren, her violet eyes on his dick. She licked her lips as she looked at Kasumi.

The two girls looked at one another, before looking at Ren. They were like a pair of lionesses, staring at him, and when he didn’t put up any defenses, they struck. 

Both girls wrapped their lips around his penis, each sucking on one side. Their tongues dragged up and down his shaft, and Ren dug his fingers into his bed as he leaned his head back. He was panting, shaking as he felt their soft lips kiss and suck on his skin. Their tongues slipped out at the same time, tasting his dick.

Kasumi took the head of the cock, sucking on his shaft as Futaba moved down to kiss and suck on the flesh. She moved lower, dragging her tongue along his rod, before she began to kiss and suck on his balls. 

Meanwhile Kasumi was bobbing her head up and down his dick, letting the tip press against the inside of her cheek as she closed her eyes. Her tongue smacked against the cock as she moaned loudly, placing a hand on the veiny shaft to stroke and squeeze the rod. 

The two girls worked together to blow him, leaving Ren to shake as he leaned his head back. Kasumi bobbed her head up and down, letting the cock push down her throat as Futaba lifted her head up and bumped into the older girl.

Kasumi lifted her head up with a pop and Futaba brought her head down, sucking on Ren’s dick as Kasumi shuddered. She climbed onto Ren, pushing his head down as she pressed her breasts against his face.

Ren opened his mouth without hesitation, sucking on one of Kasumi’s nipples as she moaned over him. His tongue darted out, licking her nipple as Futaba moved her head up and down on his dick, pressing her nose against his pubic hair as Kasumi shuddered. 

Futaba moaned, letting the vibrations travel along his dick. Her tongue slid all over his shaft, while her fingers stroked and rubbed his balls. Ren could feel the pressure building inside of him, and he knew he couldn’t hold out much longer.

The young man cried out, cumming down Futaba’s throat as the younger girl quivered. Sperm traveled down her throat, filling her as she pulled her head back. She let him cum all over her face, letting the semen cake her features and even land in her hair.

Futaba was left panting, trying to catch her breath as Kasumi pulled away from Ren. She moved over to Futaba, pouting.

“You couldn’t save some for me?” Kasumi asked, trying to hide her whining, pleading town.

“Mmm. There’s plenty,” Futaba replied, before she placed a hand on the back of Kasumi’s head and pulled her in for a kiss. Kasumi and Ren’s eyes both widened as the two watched Futaba kiss the former, and the redhead moaned as she felt Futaba’s tongue slip into her mouth.

Ren felt his cock harden again, and his heart raced as he watched the two kiss. Futaba fed Kasumi his seed, pushing his cum into her mouth as Kasumi tried and failed to control herself. She was shaking in Futaba’s arms, sucking semen right off of the other girl’s tongue.

Futaba was the one to break the kiss, not Kasumi, and Futaba licked her lips afterwards. She was blushing as she touched her own chest, rubbing her breasts with her fingers. Kasumi rubbed her arm against her lips, before glaring at the other girl.

“W-what the hell, Futaba?!”

“What? I wanted to share!”

“W-we’re both girls!” 

“So? You’re hot, I’m… kind of pretty,” she muttered, twirling a lock of orange hair around her finger. “Ren doesn’t mind, right?” 

“I certainly do not.” Kasumi blushed, shaking her head as she glanced at the young man’s erection. Her eyes widened as she saw his cock. 

“You’re still hard?” she realized, her voice dripping with amazement. 

Ren smiled, raising his brow as Futaba bit her lower lip. Kasumi glanced at her female partner, and she blushed as the two practically pounced onto her. 

---

Kasumi was arguably the least experienced with sex. While Futaba and Ren were both virgins, the two had fantasized and dreamed of a moment like this. They had also watched plenty of porn and hentai, giving them plenty of ideas of what to do. 

Kasumi was ordered to sit on Ren’s face as Futaba held her pussy right over Ren’s throbbing erection. The redhead squeaked, gasping as she felt the man’s lips press against her pussy. She was panting, shaking as his tongue slipped out to lick her wet folds. 

At the same time, Futaba lowered herself down on his cock, and she moaned loudly as she felt his dick fill her pussy. She fell forward, placing her hands on Ren’s chest as she sank herself lower down his shaft. 

Kasumi’s hands brushed against the other girl’s as Ren’s tongue flicked against her pussy again, and she felt her muscles tense as he gently sucked on her. His tongue drew circles on her womanhood as Futaba was filled. 

The small woman was so damn tight, and her pussy squeezed Ren, caressing his dick with tight, warm, wet walls. She moved her hips slowly, subtly, letting the tip of his cock pressed against different parts of her as their bodies finally touched. 

“Holy crap, Futaba,” Ren chuckled, making Kasumi squeak as the vibrations of his voice touched her pussy. “You’re so tight. And you took my entire cock…”

“I’ve… touched myself a lot… Ah,” Futaba shuddered on Ren’s dick, squeezing her walls around his shaft as she leaned forward. Her lips pressed against Kasumi’s shoulder, who blushed once more. 

Her face was as red as her hair as she tried to pull away from Futaba. “S-stop,” she muttered. “I-I’m-ahh… I’m straight.”

“Aren’t you a little curious?” Futaba asked, lifting her hips up and down Ren’s dick as she stared into Kasumi’s eyes. “What’s the worst that can happen?” the other girl inquired, leaning closer again to press her lips against Kasumi’s cheek.

The young woman had never considered herself gay before. Never even considered kissing another girl. Yet here she was, leaning forward at Futaba’s suggestion. She pressed her lips against Futaba’s, meaning for it to just be a peck, but then Ren’s tongue penetrated her pussy.

Kasumi moaned against Futaba’s lips as the smaller girl placed a hand on the back of her head, holding their lips together as Futaba’s tongue slipped into Kasumi’s mouth. Their tongues wrestled as Ren began to move his body. 

His tongue swirled inside of Kasumi as he bounced Futaba on his cock, making both women moan and mewl against one another. Futaba lifted up her other hand and placed it on Kasumi’s chest, playing and pulling on her nipple as the bed rocked from their fun. 

Ren couldn’t control himself, and judging by the way Futaba’s pussy was stroking the sides of his dick, neither could she. With a low moan against Kasumi’s womanhood, the young man came, filling Futaba’s pussy with streams of his semen, coating the walls and insides of her cunt. 

Futaba broke the kiss with Kasumi, and the red-haired woman watched as saliva linked their mouths together. She watched as Futaba closed her eyes and leaned her head back, cumming on Ren’s shaft as his seed spilled inside of her, filling her to the point that it was dripping out of her pussy. 

“Your turn, Kasumi,” Ren growled between her legs, and she blushed as he took control once more.

---

Kasumi laid on all fours, ‘doggy-style’ as Futaba put it. It was so humiliating, but she wondered if that was the point? She trembled with anticipation as Ren kneeled behind her, rubbing his dick against her pussy. 

He was teasing her, tapping his tip against her entrance as Futaba laid in front of Kasumi. Cum was dripping out of her pussy and onto the bed, in clear view of Kasumi. Ren placed his hands on Kasumi’s ass, giving each cheek a squeeze, before he pushed his cock into her. 

Kasumi gasped, before biting her lower lip as the dick spread her apart. It hurt, but not nearly as badly as she had been afraid. The young woman had lost her hymen a long time ago due to her dream of being a gymnast. He was slipping into her relatively easily, filling her as she rocked back and forth. 

Ren lifted up one of his hands and Kasumi gasped as she felt his hand smack her butt. Her body trembled, but her pussy tightened around his shaft as Futaba giggled. 

“Someone likes being spanked,” she commented, moving so that she and Kasumi were face to face. 

“I-I-ahh!” Another smack, making her moan and tremble as her pussy squeezed his shaft. 

Ren kept pushing, and even as Kasumi felt like she was being split apart, she didn’t tell him to stop. She wanted this. She knew she did. She squeezed her eyes shut, gasping as Ren’s body finally connected with hers. 

He didn’t move. He just let her get used to his cock inside of her as Futaba kissed her once more. Their tongues danced as Kasumi moaned into the other girl’s mouth. Ren would spank the redhead every now and again, making her tremble against his cock and squeeze his cock tighter. 

He resumed fucking her, pushing her against Futaba as the bed rocked under them. He grabbed her scarlet hair with his hand, pulling on it and making her break the kiss with Futaba. To Ren’s amusement, and arousal, Kasumi took one of her hands and placed it on Futaba’s cheek, pulling the girl in for another kiss. 

The raven-haired man moved his hips, letting his cock press against different parts of Kasumi, searching for the best reaction. When the young woman broke the kiss again and moaned loudly in pleasure, panting as her eyes almost rolled into her skull and her tongue hung out of her mouth, he knew he had found her G-spot.

So he slammed his cock into that spot again and again, and Kasumi cried out in pleasure as she soon came, her arms giving out as she fell face first on the bed. Drool spilled out of her mouth and onto the bed as Futaba watched with wide, amazed eyes. 

Kasumi felt her muscles convulse and her body spasm as she laid on Ren’s bed. She was shaking, quivering as her pussy squeezed down around his dick. Then he came inside of her, and she closed her eyes as tears of joyous pleasure fell onto the bed, just as drops of Ren’s semen spilled out of her pussy. 

Just like with Futaba, Ren’s cum spilled out of her pussy and onto the bed, staining it as Kasumi trembled. 

---

Ren smiled as he leaned his head back, opening his eyes as he felt Kasumi’s lips on his balls and Futaba’s lips on his tip. The two girls were cleaning his cock, his seed still dripping out from their pussies.

He had his hands on the two girls, who looked at him with such love and devotion. Futaba licked her lips, smiling at him as she stared into his eyes. She moved down silently, and Kasumi rose up. The two left a path of kisses on Ren’s dick as they traded places.

The young man felt his dick throbbing once more as he closed his eyes. 

Maybe he finally had his answer on who to date…

He’d had to fuck them a few more times to find out for sure, though.