Commission: Joining In (Fairy Tail)

Summary: Erza, Lucy, and the other girls are enjoying their time at a bathhouse together when Natsu barges in. What follows is Lucy joining in on Erza and Natsu's fun, as an older, but still immortal Mavis watches with perverted glee. Includes: Threesome.

---

Lucy was at a loss. It seemed like the entire room just transformed in a single instant, like a sudden change from water to hot, hot steam. 

One minute, all the girls were simply bathing together. Lucy and many of her friends were simply enjoying the water, bathing together in the hot, warm liquid. Their muscles relaxed, their stress melted, when suddenly Erza started to feel them up.

Maybe that was the catalyst of it all. 

000

Lucy had been resting with her eyes closed, enjoying the feeling of the water rising up to her chin. She took in a deep breath, inhaling the warm aroma, feeling it send an excited chill down her spine, before she exhaled, releasing her held breath. 

Then she felt a hand on her back, but she thought nothing of it. She just allowed herself to stay comfortable, barely even feeling the hand moving up and down her back. Then another hand fell on her shoulder, and the hands began to massage her, digging their thumbs into her back.

Lucy closed her eyes, smiling and quietly moaning as she felt the fingers press into her. She shuddered, only to gasp as she felt those hands move over her body. They slid over her skin, before groping her chest, taking her large tits in hand and just squeezing them.

The beautiful blond tried to pull away, and after a brief struggle, the hands let her go. Lucy turned around, covering her chest as she looked at Erza. 

“Erza? What are you doing?” she asked, blushing a bright shade of red.

Yet Erza didn’t seem to even notice Lucy’s embarrassment and shock. She blinked, before tilting her head. “Just helping you wash up, Lucy.”

“W-well, t-thanks, but I’m okay.”

“Are you sure?” Erza moved closer, and Lucy had her back to the wall as Erza’s equally huge tits pushed against Lucy’s. The blond was a rosy-hue mess as she looked at her friend, staring right into her eyes as Erza inched closer.

Their lips were so close as Erza moved her body, and Lucy felt her heart race as she felt Erza’s nipples poke into her body. 

“Are you okay, Lucy?” Erza asked, placing her hands on Lucy’s back, stroking her skin up and down. “I’m happy to help you wash up.”

“N-no. I-I mean, I’m good. I’m good.” She placed her hands on Erza’s chest, and Lucy felt her body tremble as she felt Erza’s nipples poke against the palms of her hands. “I can clean myself.”

Erza backed off as soon as Lucy said that, moving back and nodding her head. “Alright.” She smiled at Lucy, and the blond felt her blush travel down her neck and tingle her ears. She watched Erza swim towards Mavis, and when Erza placed her hands on her body, Mavis had a very different reaction than Lucy.

“Need help bathing, Mavis?” Erza asked, placing her hands on the eternally young woman. Mavis smiled, opening her arms and nodding her head.

“I’d love some help. Could you get my back?” The two girls rose out of the water and sat on the edge of the large pool. Erza picked up a bottle of soap and lathered her hands, before placing them on Mavis’ back.

The two gorgeous women giggled, with Mavis closing her eyes. Erza rubbed her hands on the girl’s back, lathering up a layer of soap as Mavis moaned. 

“Your skin is so soft.”

“Being eternally eighteen can do that,” Mavis chuckled. “Good for the body.” Lucy watched the two, gulping as her eyes locked on them. 

It was hard to believe, but it was true. Mavis was over a century old, and yet she was Lucy and Erza’s age. Her body slender, smaller and more petite. Small, almost flat breasts with a young body that hadn’t finished growing… and would never finish, now that Lucy thought about it.

But the young woman still had such a beauty to her, Lucy realized. Something in Mavis’ emerald eyes, or maybe it was her ethereal, almost golden hair. Her pale, almost moonlight colored skin, or her impossibly small and slender figure…

Lucy found herself staring, watching as Erza stroked and cleaned Mavis’ back. She moved her hands, slipping them to Mavis’ chest to grope and play with her small breasts.

“You have such cute breasts, Mavis,” Erza complimented, smiling.

“Heehee! Stop it. That tickles!” The shorter woman laughed. Erza embraced her, pressing their bodies together as Lucy caught Erza’s fingers pinching Mavis’ nipples. She pulled on the smaller woman’s nipples, and Lucy could feel her heart pounding from watching the two. 

Mavis moaned, and Lucy shivered. She looked around the room, looking at the other girls, and none of them seem to react to the bizarre show. Erza was playing with Erza’s chest, and no one beyond her seem to think this was odd. They just enjoyed each other’s company as Erza smiled at Mavis.

“Do you want me to help clean you?” Mavis asked, and Erza chuckled as the smaller of the two turned to face. 

“That would be great. Thank you.” And without missing a beat, Mavis placed her hands on Erza’s tits, playing with them as Lucy’s jaw hit the floor.

She groped and squeezed Erza’s tits, to the point where Lucy was wondering if she was even trying to clean Erza, or if it was all just an excuse to feel her breasts.  

Lucy wished she could have torn her eyes away. There was something so mesmerizing about Erza’s body. The red-haired woman was beautiful, no doubt there. Gorgeous, and sexy, and with a sense of confidence that only made her more alluring and beautiful.

And Mavis was equally beautiful. Such a gorgeous, almost otherworldly beauty.

Lucy had never really considered herself attracted to girls, but she’d be lying if she said she didn’t find the two beautiful. She gulped, taking a long breath, when suddenly a new guest entered the large room.

A man, one she was quite familiar with. Natsu burst into the room, greeting the girls, and Lucy almost screamed as she saw him. He was wearing his bathrobe, but he was already taking it off as he greeted her.

He pulled it apart, revealing his naked body as Natsu and the other girls blushed. As Natsu walked forward, other girls rose up.

Lucy didn’t even notice it at first. Her eyes were on Natsu, staring at his naked body, and the fleshy rod between his legs. His clothes laid on the floor, and her eyes were now locked on his cock.

At least now she was sure she wasn’t just attracted to girls.

She stared at Natsu’s cock, watching the thing dangle between his legs. He was so big. He looked almost as thick as her arm, and he wasn’t even that hard. Lucy’s face felt so hot as Natsu hopped into the water, greeting her with a smile.

The other girls, meanwhile, were walking out through the door Natsu had just entered through. Lucy saw the other girls walking away, closing the door behind them before she could even say anything.

She was left alone, trapped with a naked Natsu, and when she looked around the room, her only allies were Mavis and Erza, possibly the most perverted of the women Lucy had been with.

Lucy’s eyes finally broke away from Natsu’s cock, and when she looked at his body, she found herself as absorbed as she had been with Mavis and Erza. She was smitten, clearly overwhelmed by just how… handsome Natsu was. 

He was an athletic, well built man. His body was fully exposed, allowing her to admire his physique as he looked around the room. Even if she ignored his large, thick cock, how could she ignore his muscles? Or his handsome face? Or his toothy grin?

The beautiful woman was trapped with three impossibly attractive people, and she felt her face burn as she tried to submerge her face in water. 

000

That brought her to the here and now. Natsu was by her side, crossing his arms over his firm chest as he raised his brow.

“Wonder what their problem is?” he wondered aloud. “Why’d everyone leave all a sudden?”

“I suppose they just weren’t comfortable with a man around. They clearly lacked confidence in their own bodies,” Erza sighed. “Such a shame.”

“N-no! T-that’s not the problem!” Lucy huffed, glaring at Natsu, only to crumple and turn her head away. “Natsu, why are you naked?!” 

“Huh? Because I’m bathing, duh.”

“Honestly, Lucy, that seems like a very obvious question,” Erza agreed.

“Yeah! This is a girl’s bath! W-why are you here, Natsu?”

“Huh? Me and Erza used to bath all the time.”

“What?” Lucy blinked, and the red-haired woman nodded her head. 

“It’s true. Natsu, Grey, and I would bathe together all the time when we were young.”

“Speaking of which, Erza, you mind helping me wash up?” Natsu asked.

“Not at all, Natsu, but only if you return the favor.” The young man nodded his head, and Lucy watched as the two got out of the water, sitting on the edge of the pool. Erza squirted soap into her hands and Lucy watched her friend place her hands on Natsu’s body. 

“Aww, that’s so sweet,” Mavis complimented. “Lucy, why don’t you join in?” she asked, tilting her head. “It seems like they’re just enjoying how close they are.”

Lucy’s eyes bounced between Mavis and the couple. Erza’s hands moved up and down Natsu’s chest, and the blond felt her cheeks burn at the sight, before Natsu took the bottle of soap and squirted it onto his own hands. 

He lathered it up, before placing his hands on Erza’s body, squeezing and groping her tits like Mavis had been doing just a minute ago. Lucy’s eyes widened, and Erza moaned, shaking slightly as she felt Natsu’s fingers around her nipples.

“Ahh, Natsu…”

“Got to make sure I clean every part of you, Erza.” He released her tits and slipped his hands under her breasts, lifting them up as he cleaned the underside of her chest. “Can’t miss a spot.”

“So considerate,” Erza giggled, before she began to move Natsu’s hands down his body. “But I need you to move if I’m going to clean any lower.”

“Give me a minute. I have to double check your breasts.” And Erza gave him that minute. His hands roamed over her chest, squeezing and playing with the redhead’s rack like it was no big deal, and as Lucy watched, she began to feel… hot.

She covered her chest, watching Natsu feeling Erza up, and all of his touching was clearly beginning to have an effect on Erza. 

The woman’s face was beginning to turn red, and her breath was growing more and more shallow as the seconds ticked by. When Natsu’s fingers pinched her, now hard, nipples, she was left shaking, biting her lower lip as she closed her eyes. 

Natsu freed them again, before he drove his thumbs against her nipples, pressing down on the hard nubs as Erza kept her eyes closed. She was clearly moaning as Natsu played with her chest, and Lucy could almost feel those same hands on her body, playing with her nipples and groping her hefty tits.

“It’s amazing how close they are,” Mavis whispered, and Lucy’s eyes widened as she felt the other girl’s voice brush against her ear. “Seeing them like that. Clearly in need of something more. I think it’s obvious what they want. This is just foreplay, before they get to the real fun.”

Mavis moved to Lucy’s other ear, whispering, letting her hot breath tickle Lucy’s earlobe. “Or maybe they know they can’t have too much fun with you watching. Maybe they can’t really enjoy themselves with you here watching them... They just don’t realize how much you’re enjoying their show.”

Lucy moved away from Mavis, blushing madly as she pondered what the other woman had said. No way that was true, right? No, it was impossible. 

But questions raced through her mind. Were Erza and Natsu clearly attracted to one another? Did they know exactly what they were doing or not? Did they notice Lucy squirming, clearly aroused by their game?

Lucy gulped. No. No, she wasn’t turned on. She was just… horribly curious. 

She should leave the two alone. Let them have their privacy, but Lucy’s body refused to move on her command. Her eyes were glued on their bodies as Natsu finally pulled his hands away. 

“There. All clean.”

“Good,” Erza panted, before Natsu picked up a bucket of warm water and pouring it down onto Erza. The water flowed down her skin, carrying the soap off of her body as Lucy admired the glistening goddess.

Erza did the same for her male friend, helping wipe his chest clean, and just like before, Lucy found herself staring intently at the couple that seemed to have forgotten about her and Mavis. 

“Alright, ready to clean your cock now, Natsu?” Erza asked, as if she was asking him to turn around so she could his back.

“Yep.” Natsu stood up, out of the water, and Lucy watched him stand before Erza with a proud smile on her face. “Get to cleaning.”

“So demanding… You haven’t changed at all since we were young,” Erza laughed, and Lucy didn’t bother to waste time pondering that statement. 

Instead, she just watched as Erza cupped the water with her hands. She lifted the ‘bowl’ of water up, before dropping it onto Natsu’s flaccid penis. Even soft, that thing was so long, and so thick, Lucy couldn’t imagine something like that inside of her. It would have to hurt, wouldn’t it?

It would have to be just… be terrible inside her cunt, stretching out her pussy, filling her like nothing else could…

Erza clearly did not share Lucy’s fears as she stroked the dick, moving her soft fingers up and down the shaft with a smile. 

“Someone is happy to see me. Or, happy to feel me?” she chuckled, wrapping her fingers around the base of his cock, gently squeezing it in her hand.

“Can you blame me?” Natsu chuckled, laughing and grinning like what they were doing was natural. And maybe it was, Lucy realized. She had never seen the two bathed before. Maybe this was-

Lucy’s mind just stopped as she watched Erza open her mouth and take Natsu’s cock in. Her head pushed forward, sinking down halfway his dick as she closed her eyes and just gently sucked on the flesh rod. 

Natsu moaned, placing a hand on Erza’s head, playing with her scarlet locks as his tip pressed against Erza’s cheek. Lucy could see the outline of his dick through her skin, and she watched as Erza continued to move her head back and forth on the shaft. 

The woman made an almost impossible to hear gagging sound as it sank down her throat. She took with almost no effort, almost like she had done it a dozen times before. She bobbed her head back and forth, sinking a little lower each time, letting her nose brush against Natsu’s hairs as Mavis whispered into Lucy’s ear again.

“She’s having so much fun… and she’s taking that cock so easily. Don’t lie, Lucy, don’t you wish you could take Natsu’s dick that easily?” 

Lucy tried to  shake her head when she caught something out of the corner of her eyes. She saw Mavis sitting on the ground around the large pool of water, quite clearly touching herself. The small woman had her legs spread, and she was pressing a finger against her clit, moving it against her body as she moaned quietly. 

“Ahh… It’s amazing, isn’t it? How much cock Erza can take?” the eternally young woman laughed, shuddering as her pussy became more and more wet. She glanced at Lucy, locking eyes with her as she smiled. “Don’t look at me. Look at them. Can you honestly tell me you don’t want to get involved in that?”

“If Lucy wants to join in, we won’t stop her,” Natsu declared, and Lucy felt her heart skip a beat. She turned to the two, and Erza placed her hands on Natsu’s chest, pushing so her mouth could be freed of his thick dick. 

“Agreed. Lucy is more than welcome to join us. Or she can sit back and watch me take it,” Erza licked her lips, moaning at the taste of the pink-haired man’s shaft. “She can even leave if she wants, but I think she already knew that.”

“Oh, she definitely knows,” Mavis giggled, before quivering as she slipped a finger into her own pussy. She gasped, fingering herself as Natsu held a hand out to Lucy. Erza returned to her duty of cleaning Natsu’s cock, dragging her tongue up and down the shaft. 

“What do you say, Lucy? You want to join us?”

Lucy could feel her heart racing and her pussy quivering as she ogled the two. She found it so hard to breathe as Erza’s muffled moans filled the room. 

It was wrong, wasn’t it? She couldn’t join them… Yet Lucy found her body moving through the pool of water, moving closer to Erza and Natsu with hungry eyes. 

Lucy pulled herself out of the water and crawled on the ground, watching Erza fondle Natsu’s balls with one of her hands. She gave it a soft squeeze, before she began to rub them as she took the cock down her throat once more. 

“While Erza cleans my cock, why don’t you lick my balls clean?” Behind Lucy, Mavis moaned loudly, shuddering as she fingered herself to the scene playing out before her. 

“Ahh, do it, Lucy. You know you want to! Just be happy. Enjoy yourself.”

Enjoy yourself… Yeah, that did sound nice, didn’t it? Lucy gulped her fears down, and her pussy dripped her juices down to the ground as the blond pressed her nose against Natsu’s balls. She gave them a shy eskimo kiss, before she opened her mouth. 

The balls quivered, no doubt from Erza’s mouth sucking on his cock. Her tongue was probably smacking against the shaft inside of her, coating it in her saliva. Making it nice and clean…

Lucy stuck out her tongue and she dragged it up and down his balls, making the man moan quietly. “Just like that, Lucy. You’re a natural.” She felt a twinge of excitement at that. She parted her lips further, and she took one of his balls in her mouth, gently sucking on it. 

She switched back and forth, kissing and sucking on his testicles, before sticking out her tongue to smack his balls with that. Her tongue moved side to side, tasting him as his balls began to glisten with her saliva. 

“Good job, Lucy,” Erza giggled, letting the cock pop out of her mouth as she licked her lips. “Care to trade?”

Lucy nodded her head, barely even giving an answer as she and Erza switched spots. It was easy to take that monster cock in her mouth. Easier than the blond imagined, at least. Maybe she really was a natural…

She let the cock pushed down her throat, and even as tears pooled in the corners of Lucy’s eyes, she kept pushing. She wanted to be like Erza and take this whole dick in her mouth. She kept pushing herself, sinking lower and lower down the cock as Natsu’s fingers played with her golden hair.

“Damn, Lucy. You’re amazing at this. And your mouth is so tight,” he groaned, and Lucy did her best to impress. 

She made sure her tongue smacked against his shaft, and she swore she could almost taste Erza’s saliva on the penis. Lucy moved her head back and forth, letting her tongue drag along the underside, moaning as felt it stretch her throat. 

Her hands landed on Natsu’s skin, stroking his body as her lips dragged along the slick member. Erza was just below her, kissing and licking the same man’s balls, and as Lucy bobbed her head, her drool began to spill out from her mouth.

The cock pushed her drool out, letting it fall onto Erza’s face, who moaned at the sensation. She kept licking and kissing his balls, never stopping, always finding some new spot to clean for the man.

His balls throbbed, and Lucy felt his cock twitching in her mouth. Her eyes widened, realizing all too late what was happening as she felt cum spill down her throat. She choked on it, feeling it coat the walls of her throat as she pulled her head back.

Lucy coughed again and again, spitting her cum onto the ground with a blush. Erza freed Natsu’s balls from her lips, pouting as she watched Lucy spit Natsu’s cum onto the ground. Speaking of which, the man just kept cumming. 

His seed spilled onto Lucy’s face, with some of it even ending up in her hair. More of it fell onto her tits, coating her large boobs with his seed, as if he was marking his territory. Lucy blushed profusely while the rest of her body was relatively untouched… save for Lucy’s incredibly wet, wanting cunt.  

She was so horny now, so desperate to be fucked. She was shaking from the need as Erza suddenly pulled on Lucy. Their lips met in a kiss, and Erza was sure to plan. The lucky man looking at them was going to be cumming soon, but for now, he could enjoy the show. 

Lucy cried out against the kiss, only to shudder as she tasted someone else. Two someones. Erza’s saliva and the fresh taste of Natsu’s dick on Erza’s cock. 

Her train of thought was shot down as she tasted Erza’s cock in her mouth. The blond could taste it, she realized. How good this kiss was, and how their tongues seemed to connect, how it felt to connect… Like firecrackers on her tongue as she tasted Erza’s Natsu-flavored saliva. 

“You shouldn’t waste his cum,” Erza finally whispered, breaking their intense kiss as she smiled at the woman’s collection. 

“Alright, who wants to get fucked first?” the man of the hour asked, crossing his arms as both girls shuddered.

000

Lucy wasn’t sure what had possessed her. She wasn’t sure what led to her submitting to Natsu, and joining Erza in ‘cleaning’ the man. 

Now Lucy was on her knees, just over Natsu’s cock. Erza smiled at Lucy, before she laid down next to Natsu on her chest, kissing the pink-haired man. Lucy watched the two kiss passionately, stopping only to look at the blond expectantly.

With their eyes watching her, Lucy sank her body down, letting the cock fill her, slipping into her. She was already wet from her own arousal, and his dick was slick with her and Erza’s saliva and spit. He entered her so easily, Lucy quivered as she felt a cock enter her for the first time.

It wasn’t painful. It was easy, and simple, and it slipped into her without any problem, leaving Lucy short of breath as pleasure went through her body like lightning. Shocking one nerve, before jumping to another. 

Lucy was a virgin, but her hymen was gone from years of exercise to keep her body fit and shapely. She felt the dick go deeper in, inch after inch, and she was panting, gasping for air as she closed her eyes. 

Everything melted away as Lucy felt the cock fill her. She sank down, past the halfway point, before rising up. She bounced up and down on Natsu’s dick, moaning louder as his dick stretched her pussy. 

There was only the barest feeling of pain as Lucy bounced on Natsu, and that pain was fading every time his cock fucked her. She moaned, falling forward and placing her hands on the man’s chest as a pair of soft lips kissed her cheeks.

Lucy opened her eyes, just in time to see Erza lean in for a kiss. Their lips pressed together, and Lucy went still, frozen in time, before she melted, pressing her lips against Erza’s. 

The beautiful, buxom redhead placed her pussy on Natsu’s face, inches from his lips, and her hands fell on Lucy’s chest. Erza groped and squeezed the large breasts, practically mauling them with her ferocity and carnal desire. Lucy moaned, having never felt anyone treat her so roughly.

It made her already wet pussy quiver with need, and she squeezed Natsu’s cock as she quickened her pace. She bounced again and again on it as Erza’s tongue slipped into Lucy’s mouth, exploring and tasting the blond. The scarlet-haired beauty moaned loudly as she tasted Natsu’s precum on her tongue, only to mewl even louder as Natsu’s tongue dragged along Erza’s slit.

Erza broke the kiss, and Lucy stared at her, watching the usually cool and confident woman shuddering as Natsu’s tongue licked her. His tongue moved against her pussy skillfully, smacking against her wet folds, tasting her, before pushing into her pussy.

“Ah… F-fuck… Lucy’s, h-he’s amazing at licking pussy. He really has a gift for it,” Erza giggled, before she leaned forward, almost kissing Lucy again. “But his cock is even better. Tell me how it feels to have it for the first time?” 

“I-it feels… ahh, g-good?” Lucy muttered, and Erza shook her head. 

“Not good enough.”

“Ah! I-it feels really good,” Lucy gasped, feeling Natsu’s hands on her hips, taking control of her rhythm, making her pick up speed. 

“Liar,” Mavis whispered, and Lucy turned her head to see the small, petite woman sitting in the corner, touching herself to the sight of the three. Her legs were spread apart, and her fingers were pushing in and out of her wet womanhood. 

Mavis moaned loudly, shaking as three fingers fucked her, and her other hand squeezed and played with her breast just like Erza was with Lucy’s. She smiled, licking her lips, almost like she was feeding off of the sight. Lucy gulped, feeling her face burn as she realized her first time had an audience, but all of her worries faded as Natsu made her bounce again.

“Come on, Lucy,” Natsu chuckled, smacking the blond’s butt. “Be honest about how you feel.” And before Lucy could say anything, Natsu started to lift her up and down. She was no longer in control. He was fucking her, plain and simple, and Lucy’s eyes almost vanished into her skull as she screamed.

Her tits bounced wildly, stopped only by Erza’s hand on one and her face on the other. Her lips wrapped around Lucy’s rack, squeezing and pulling on the blond’s breasts. Lucy’s tits bounced wildly, even smacking against the other woman’s face, yet Erza only moaned between the two jugs. 

The blond had never felt this good before. She was shaking, going mad with pleasure. Her brain felt like it was overheated, and her tongue stuck out of her mouth as she drooled, letting drops of saliva fall onto Erza’s head. 

Meanwhile Erza was coating one of Lucy’s nipples in her own spit, licking and sucking on Lucy’s nipple like a child would for her mother. The blond’s other breast was squeezed, pumped by Erza’s hand, as if trying to get the cow to spray her with milk. Lucy mewled loudly, and her pussy tightened as Erza continued to abuse her tits.

Lucy could feel the pressure building inside of her, and every time Natsu’s cock kissed the entrance to her womb, she shuddered, gasping and moaning louder and louder. Her moans mixed with Mavis’ cries, and even Erza’s muffled voice. Lucy wrapped her arms around her scarlet-haired friend, and Erza lifted her head up to kiss the blond.

Their lips danced against one another, tongues wrestling as Lucy came. She came from Erza’s mouth and Natsu’s cock, and honestly, even Mavis’ moans seemed to drive Lucy mad. The blond came on the young man’s dick as he groaned, shooting his seed into her waiting and wanting pussy. 

His seed coated the walls of her pussy, even spilling into her empty womb. Lucy could practically feel his sperm inside of her, impregnating her as she leaned her head back. Erza held the woman upright, keeping her still as cum spilled out of her pussy and onto Natsu’s body. 

“Ahh… M-more,” Lucy begged, a trickle of drool falling from her mouth and down her chin. Erza licked it up, moaning as she and Lucy kissed once more. 

000

Lucy and Erza moved positions once more. This time the two were laying on one another, with Lucy under her stronger, crimson-haired partner. Both girls watched Natsu walk behind them, out of their eyesight as Mavis moaned.

“Make them cum, Natsu,” she teased, licking her lips as she stared at the two. “I want to hear them scream for you!” Lucy blushed as she glanced at the woman. Honestly, it seemed like Mavis was having more fun watching than she would have from actually joining in. 

“Can do!” Natsu took his thick dick by the base, and he smacked Lucy’s ass with it, before he pressed the tip against Lucy’s creampied pussy. 

“N-Natsu, please,” Erza blushed. “I still haven’t had my turn yet. Don’t tell me Lucy’s replacing me as your favorite,” the woman muttered, pouting as she moved her body subtly. Lucy moaned, feeling the other woman’s hard nipples poking into her.

Lucy kissed the woman’s cheek, licking her sweaty skin. Every breath Lucy took was thick with Erza’s scent, and the blond couldn’t lie. The thought of replacing Erza as Natsu’s favorite… That made her tingle with something she had never felt before.

“Heh. Don’t worry, Erza. That’ll never happen.” Even after hearing that, Lucy wanted it more than ever. Still, she focused on the here and now, watching as Erza closed her eyes and moaned loudly. 

The two women could hear Natsu’s dick slipping into the woman’s pussy, and he quickly began to pick up speed, fucking her pussy harder and harder, making Erza bounce and jiggle on top of Lucy. 

Their tits smacked against one another, and their bodies held one another as the sound of Natsu plowing Erza’s cunt filled the air. Lucy could hear Mavis’ loud cry, and when she looked at the smaller woman, there was no doubt in Lucy’s mind.

Mavis had just cum to the sight of the two girls being fucked. “H-harder! Fuck them harder!” Mavis begged, spraying her juices onto the ground as she panted. “Keep fucking them! Ah, more, Natsu!”

“Y-yes! More,” Erza grinned. “I can take it. Don’t be afraid to break me, Natsu! Even if you did, you have another slut to fuck.”

Lucy blushed, but she didn’t argue the role as she and Erza kissed again. Their tongues wrestled as Natsu lifted his hand up and brought it down, spanking Erza. The woman moaned, sucking on Lucy’s tongue as he spanked her again.

Erza was shaking on Lucy, and every smack seemed to intensify their kiss. Some drool spilled from their kiss, dripping down onto Lucy. The blond moaned loudly, exploring Erza’s mouth as Natsu kept spanking her. 

The woman’s ass was soon as red as her hair, when suddenly Natsu pulled his dick out of her and slammed it into Lucy’s already filled cunt. Erza whined, breaking the kiss to turn and glare at Natsu. Meanwhile, Lucy was moaning loudly, feeling the man’s hard cock slam into her.

His seed from his last orgasm spilled out of her cunt, falling down Lucy’s body and pooling under the two. Lucy felt her muscles spasm, and her pussy squeezed tighter around the shaft, before she suddenly felt empty again.

Natsu had pulled out of her, and now he was fucking Erza again, making the warrior scream in pleasure as Lucy pouted. 

The mighty dragon continued to torture the two girls, moving back and forth. He’d fuck one of them, thrusting his dick back and forth for a few minutes, before he’d move to the other one and fuck them for a while.

Sometimes he’d torture them by not even fucking either of them. He’d just smack his dick against their bodies, letting them suffer in silence as they waited for him to pick one of them. 

He seemed to enjoy torturing poor Erza the most, which was fine by Lucy. The blond loved her friend like a sister, but what was torture for Erza, felt so damn good for herself.

Natsu would fuck Lucy for a few minutes, only to pull out. He’d rub his length against Erza’s pussy, wiping his wet cock against her folds and inner thighs, only to return back to Lucy. He’d fuck Lucy hard enough to shake their bodies, but even if he was nicer on Lucy, he still tortured her too. 

He seemed to know just when one of the girls was about to cum, and he would pull out at the last second, leaving the two girls to whine and moan for his penis. 

By now, Mavis had came more than either girls had, and they could feel their minds eroding as Natsu continued to torture them.

Eventually one of them was finally granted mercy, and that lucky woman didn’t know what to do when Natsu kept fucking her. Erza mewled, a fucked silly smile on her face as Natsu fucked her pussy once more, and this time he didn’t stop.

He rammed his member into her again and again, and Erza squeezed Lucy in a tight embrace. The scarlet-haired beauty screamed in pleasure, cumming on Natsu’s dick. Her muscles spasmed, and her pussy squeezed tightly around the muscular man’s shaft.

The man slammed into her, grinning a toothy grin. He unleashed a torrent of cum inside of her, spilling his seed into her waiting womb. His thick, syrup-like cum clung to the walls of her pussy, and the white flood filled her insides to the point where Erza felt like she might pop.

Her eyes rolled into her skull as a grin formed on her face. Drool fell down her face, and Lucy kissed it, licking her chin as she whimpered like an animal. She begged for more from Natsu, who could only grin at the sight of the two beauties he had tamed.

000

“Ahh, I have to say, Natsu, I’m impressed. You’re still so ha-aah, hard…” Erza trembled as she sat on the ground, watching Lucy lick and clean her creampied pussy. The blond sucked Natsu’s seed from Erza’s cunt as the man slowly fucked her pussy. 

“Thanks,” he grunted, pushing into the blond’s body again. “But it’s pretty easy when I got a pair like you two.” He brought his hand down, spanking Lucy, who moaned against Erza’s filled cunt.

“Charmer,” she chuckled, smiling at her pink-haired lover. She gasped, before moaning as Lucy’s tongue licked her clit. “Y-yes. Right there, Lucy. Aaah…” Lucy drew a circle around the clit with her tongue, before she flicked it back and forth. 

Erza soon came against Lucy’s face, letting her own wet juices spray the girl’s features as Natsu spanked her ass. 

“Good job, Lucy! Way to look out for your teammates. As a reward, I’ll give you another load of my cum!”

“Ahh, t-thank you, Natsu,” the woman panted, pulling her face from Erza’s pussy just to utter her gratitude, and then it was back to licking Erza’s cunt. 

“Mmm, good girl, Lucy.” Erza looked at Natsu, smiling at him as she quivered. “I hope you replace all this lost cum, Natsu.”

“Don’t worry. I intend to. Plus a little extra,” he grinned, spanking Lucy’s ass once more. 

The two seemed to ignore her again, but honestly, Lucy didn’t seem to mind. She felt so good being on the bottom of their chain of command. Even Mavis, who didn’t even participate, stood over Lucy.

That just made the blond feel hotter as she felt Natsu pick up his pace, fucking her pussy harder again, letting his seed spill onto the ground again as he fucked the beautiful blond into another orgasm.