Witch Glass Shall You Pick (Ea)

A commission for FunMeYay

After the era of hunting witches, those who weren't discovered went into hiding, and with it, the knowledge to use magic was gone from the world. That was until the world reached the modern day. With it, witches like Sophie could come out of hiding and use magic again.

Though most of them had to get jobs as things like fortune tellers to cover up the fact they had access to real magic, most humans nowadays either believed it to be nonsense or believed in it and liked it, as long as it was being used for them.

Sophie was one of the witches who used her magic to start a business. Unlike many of the others, she chose to use magic to become a private eye of sorts, one whose main clientele is women who think their partners are cheating on them.

It’s a very fruitful business, as there were a lot of men who didn’t know the meaning of loyalty, so there would always be women needing her services. When one of these women starts suspecting their partners and uses the internet, Sophie’s magic automatically brings them to her website.

There they can make an appointment with her, and come see her in person. She’ll have them tell her about their partner and the places they like to hang out, all the things expected of a normal private investigator.

All she really needed though was the person's name, and once the client left, Sophie would head on down to her lair and get to work. She’d cast a seeing spell on her crystal ball using the target's name and from there the real work started.

Most of Sophie’s cases ended pretty quickly thanks to this, as most cheaters use their phones to do so. So within a couple of hours, Sophie would see them on their phone messaging someone in a sexual manner or using some sort of dating app.

In a few rare cases, Sophie would catch them in the act. Then using a memory print spell, she’d take a piece of paper and magically create an exact image of them for evidence to supply to the person who hired her, should the time come.

Normally a P.I. would simply take this to the client and be done with the job, but Sophie was a witch, and they never do things the normal way. Once she has all the proof, Sophie likes to lure in the cheaters and play a little game with them.

They’d always come hoping to get rid of the photos, and they always offered a lot of money, but Sophie always shut them down and told them that she’d rather play a game with them, a simple wine-drinking game.

Sophie would sit them down, pull out a bottle of wine, two wine glasses, and two very special potions. She pours wine into both glasses, then one potion into each of the wine glasses. She then brings both wine glasses to the cheater and presents them.

She then makes a bet with the person. She tells them that she has spiked both drinks. One had a potion that when consumed would quickly transform them into the woman of his dreams. If they get that one, they obviously lose, and then Sophie will release the proof to her client.

The other drink had a potion in it that would make the cheater’s partner, the one who hired Sophie, obey them completely from now on. Whatever the cheater wanted they would do without hesitation. If they get that they win, and she’ll destroy the evidence.

In the end, they always take the bet, either because they think she’s crazy and it’s fake or that it’s worth the risk to keep their cheating hidden. Thus begins Sophie's favorite part of her job, the mind games.

Sophie doesn’t actually give a damn about cheating, both men and women have done it for as long as she’s lived, and that was nearly a thousand years, what she did care about was taking men down a peg or two.

After all, most of her life was lived when men controlled everything and treated her and all women terribly, so it was always nice to get revenge for all that, and what better way than by playing games that mess with their minds?

Once the game began, Sophie would push both drinks towards the cheater and tell them all they had to do was pick the right one. She’ll then spin them a few times, and then slightly pull the losing drink towards her, like she’s suggesting she wants it.

That gets their minds racing about whether or not it’s the right one. They begin trying to figure out which drink will make them leave with their manhood, the evidence, and the power to control the partner they cheated on.

Right before they make their first attempt at a choice, Sophie will say something to throw them off. Sometimes it’s about all the sexy women that have been created here, or merely something like saying if she were them, she wouldn’t pick that one.

After that came the movements, like with her face. If they reached for the wrong one, she’d look nervous, while when they reached for the right one, she’d look happy. If that didn’t do the trick, she’d do stuff like shake her leg or tap her finger acting frustrated.

She’d even make her voice crack, blink faster, or even breathe heavier, all to throw them off more and trick them into picking the wrong glass of wine. Most of the time she ends up getting the same result, a man too afraid to pick.

That’s how she knows she’s won. After that, there was one sure-fire way to get them to take the wrong glass, and that was for her to offer to make the choice for them, and then pick up the wrong glass.

She then puts the glass up to her lips, which is when they always stop her. They always assume she wouldn't willingly take the losing one and try to drink it. So they tell her that they want the glass in her hands.

They then take the glass from her and bring it up to their face. Sophie will grab the other glass of wine and offer to click glasses with them, which they always refuse. Then the two of them take a big sip of their wine and wait to see the results, which Sophie always knew since she kept track.

Moments later Sophie would watch a grown man start to cry as he turned into the woman of their dreams, who was usually a very curvy woman, with large breasts, a big ass, and you guessed it a high libido.

At first, they’d look at their new bodies shocked, confused, and in disbelief. They’d then touch certain parts of their bodies to confirm they were actually women, then they’d look up at Sophie nervously, and start begging her to turn them back into men.

Sophie would roll her eyes and tell them that a bet was a bet and that their current body was now their new permanent one, and that they best get used to it. She then gives them a cheeky warning about cheating, before teleporting them away with magic.

She really didn’t care what happened to them next, although she knew it wouldn't be easy for them. No one would believe they were formally males, and they were always too embarrassed to ask the person they cheated on for help, especially knowing Sophie gave them the proof of it.

So they had no choice but to figure out how to start over, which again Sophie didn’t care about and it wasn’t her problem, who cared if a few men went missing now and then, no one really missed them anyway.

However, she did get investigated once or twice about the missing people. She’d had a hundred and sixteen clients so far, and only ninety-five were actually cheaters and turned into women at the end by Sophie.

But thanks to magic, there was no evidence to connect her to them disappearing. After the cheater is transferred and out of her hair, Sophie calls the client back. gives them the results, and tells them that they already took care of informing the nasty cheater on their behalf.

They always thanked her and promptly paid the invoice sent to them. Then they spread the word about her being the best P.I. when it comes to discovering and getting rid of cheating men, so she ends up with more and more work.

It’s truly her perfect job, she gets paid to weed out bad men and replace them with women all while still getting to use magic. She’s basically making the world a better place with her power. Unfortunately, not everyone thinks so, and sooner or later, one of her victims will find a way to get back at her for turning them into a woman, it is only a matter of time.