Beating The Witch At Her Own Game (Com)

 A commission for FunMeYay

Uncensored version: https://www.patreon.com/posts/beating-witch-at-113058231

Sophie had just finished up with her last client when an email came in from another woman looking to find out if her boyfriend was cheating on her. However, this client was very different from her normal clients.

That was because she was one of the former men Sophie had caught cheater, and who lost her game and became a woman. Sophie was really surprised to see one of them pop up again, and she was a bit suspicious.

So Sophie spied on Kate for a bit, and to Sophie’s surprise, Kate had not only managed to adapt to her new life as a woman, but she actually built a nice new life and actually hadn’t continued her terrible cheating ways.

Knowing that Sophie didn’t feel like she was trying to get revenge, but actually found out if her boyfriend was cheating on her. Clearly, if he is, she wants him to suffer the same punishment that she did.

Sophie didn’t care though, a client was a client, and turning men into women was her favorite hobby, and knowing that some of them became decent women like Kate, made Sophie feel assured that she was doing good for the world.

So Sophie contacted Kate and got all the details she needed about him and got to work. It took a few days as Kate’s boyfriend was very careful about his cheating. Most days he was out working on the streets as a magician, and some nights he did shows at parties and small locations.

Well on the third night, he lied to Kate about going to a party to work and ended up meeting a girl at her house. Once inside they two quickly grabbed each other and started making out, and before Sophie knew it, they were naked, and fucking very passionately in the woman's bedroom.

Sophie did her thing and got photos and sent them off to the magician to lure him to her place and into her feminizing trap. As expected, he was there the next day and demanded the photos that Sophie had, be deleted immediately.

Sophie offered him her same gamble. One wine glass had a potion that would turn him into a woman, and the other had a potion that would allow him to fully control his girlfriend and make her do whatever he wanted without hesitation.

He agreed to the game, and Sophie brought out the wine, the wine glasses, and potions and placed them on the table in front of him. She then poured the wine. That’s when they both heard something smash in the front room of Sophie’s office.

She got up and went to check on it. Though she was only gone for a few seconds, that was enough time for Kate’s boyfriend to work his magic, and using his skills in sleight of hand, he was able to replace the feminized potion with a dud, he had hidden up his sleeve.

That’s when Sophie came back and took both potions, then she hid which one was which, and poured one potion into each wine glass. She then placed the potions on a table away from them and then spun the glasses around.

Kate’s boyfriend had no idea which was the dud and which was the potion he wanted, and he needed to get the right one or else Sophie would get suspicious, and now something fishy was going on.

Luckily he had two major advantages, the first being Kate. She told him all about the mind games that she’d play on him. She went into detail about everything she did, even how her face looked when she did them.

That made it much easier for him to use his second advantage. He had a degree in the human psyche, which he used to easily trick people he performed for, and made his acts much more mind-bogglingly amazing.

Using both of those he was going to get the potion that would allow him to control his girlfriend, except he didn’t plan to use it on Kate, instead, he was going to use it on Sophie and control her instead.

Unbeknownst to Sophie, this whole thing was Kate’s revenge, carried out by her boyfriend who loved her so much that he was willing to risk turning into a woman to make her happy. It all started last week when she stumbled upon Sophie’s website.

Seeing it infuriated her, after all, becoming a woman was a big change, and made life really hard since she couldn't use her old identity, but Kate managed to pull through. She knew she had to get revenge.

So she started planning and brought her boyfriend into it. Her plan was to have him go hook up with some random woman after she contacted Sophie, that way she would think he was actually a no-good cheater.

Then once he gets invited to her house and she starts the game, she’ll create a distraction so he can swap the feminization potion with the dud she created. Then all he had to do was read her like a book and get the control potion.

Now he had no desire to control Kate, but that's where the real revenge starts. Sophie had done some research after she was turned into a woman. She was hoping to find a way back to normal by studying spell books, but she found out she couldn’t cast magic.

However, she did discover the exact recipe and spell used to create the control potion Sophie uses, and as it turned out, whoever drinks it can pick the woman they want to control. Sophie had always just told them it had to be their girlfriends in order to protect herself.

Well, at Kate’s request, he was going to use it on her, as soon as he drank the right potion that is. It took about twenty minutes of reading Sophie and watching exactly how she reacted each time he went to reach for a glass.

He even flipped the script a bit and asked her questions, ones designed to annoy her and to get her to lie, that way he got a better grasp on which of her distractions were real, or fake. In the end, it all worked out according to Kate’s plan.

Her boyfriend drank the control potion and Sophie was both surprised and annoyed, but told him he lucked out and got the right one. As she was explaining how he could control Kate, she started to feel weird and knew right away she had been playing.

She tried to cast a spell to block the effects of the potion, but it was too late. He ordered her not to ever reverse the effects, and she now had to obey. He then turned towards the front and called out to Kate to come inside.

Katie then strutted in looking really happy with herself. She went on for a bit about how good this felt, and how she was going to save men everywhere from her awful way of punishing them. She then ran up to her boyfriend and kissed him on the lips.

She then said she was really glad he didn’t turn into a girl, and that they’d get to stay together. He reciprocated her love, and then the two turned their gaze towards Sophie, and discussions about what to do to her began.

They both agreed that she needed to look a bit sexier, so Kate’s boyfriend ordered Sophie to use magic to remove her clothes and place them with a leather hardness, one that held her arms tightly against her body, while also spreading her breasts apart.

Sophie did so, as she didn’t have a choice, and in seconds she was standing there without her robes, breasts exposed, and in a tight leather harness. Kate then looked at her boyfriend and asked what happened to her, she looked much thicker with her robes on.

He suggests they must have made her look like that because of some enchantment, but now that he could control her, he could just make it permanent and apparent in her new outfit. Kate clapped her hands and said that was a great idea.

So he ordered her to cast a spell on herself, one that would give her an hourglass figure, one to make her breasts a couple of sizes larger and her nipples very erect, and lastly one to make her butt fuller and her thighs thicker.

Kate was pleased with the change, especially since it made Sophie into the sexy type of woman that she turned Kate into. Kate then stared at Sophie for a moment before her boyfriend asked her what was wrong.

Sophie said she didn’t feel like she was punished enough, and she really didn’t like looking her in the eyes. She wanted Sophie to have to look up to them from now on. He smiled and said he had a good idea to fix that.

He looked at Sophie and ordered her to use one last spell to hogtie herself. Her ankles and wrist should be wrapped in rope and then the two tied together. Sophie gulped, but again thanks to the potion she had no choice but to cast the spell.

She fell to the floor, her legs were pulled towards her butt, her arms pulled behind her back and both were wrapped in tight scratchy rope, which she couldn't unbind, then they were tied together. Kate then looked down at Sophie and said this was perfect.

Kate’s boyfriend then asked what they should do with her now. Kate thought about it for a moment and said that they’d take her home. She then rubbed her boyfriend's chest and said that he deserved a new toy for doing such a good job.

He looked down at Sophie and smiled, he mentioned trying out a few things that he’d always wanted to do. Sophie gulped, and could only watch as they dragged her off to their home to use her however they pleased. Sophie should have known after all the men she got the better of, one was bound to come back and get the better of her.