Vinland Saga - Reaction Replacement Poll

OOHHHH, Now I'm wondering, if all these choices were Stark children, which is which?

Romaniablack

Just need to go back to the dart board, eh?

Romaniablack

I definitely will keep Berserk on the retro poll and in the 2nd place poll if it get there and happens to not win, because I really want to see it!

Romaniablack

Thank you for voting!! I'm excited for whatever wins!

Romaniablack

I am internally leaping for joy seeing TPN winning!! I'm looking forward to your reaction very much!! :D

(maya) lilacpeachycu

it's close now :) either way it's a fact that underrated series like Golden Kamuy won't win this poll lol

killerqueen2000

I'm trying to stay as blind as I can so we'll see if it wins, but thanks for the comment!

Romaniablack

S1, then manga, then S2 sounds like a good idea. You get to see the story as intended, and get to satisfy your curiosity about how bad S2 is. Only downside is that you'd get to read a couple of volumes immediately after watching them, but Posuka Demizu's art looks fantastic so it should still be very fun.

cw

I've heard about Season 2 being universally panned, but honestly, one of the reasons I was even drawn to include this show on the poll was because of that -- I'm a completionist, so I would WANT to watch Season2 as well, despite how bad it may be (please no spoilers). However, I would definitely poll patreon as to whether I read the manga first and then watch it or vice versa. Thanks for voting!

Romaniablack

TPN is fun and has one of the strongest first arcs in a shounen manga I've ever seen. But from what I've heard (I'm a manga only) I'd strongly recommend going directly to the manga after season 1. Season 2 is universally panned to a degree I've rarely seen, and I fear it would spoil the surprises and reveals from the good version of the story. If you're committed to watching season 2 as well, I might change my vote.

cw

I sadly don't have slots for 2 right now -- the 2nd place show will go on the 2nd place poll for later this summer/fall. :)

Romaniablack

2nd place will also be watched?😬

Cyber_JokerWTF

It's wild with the top three! Thanks for the votes and suggestions -- I like to go into the series completely blind, so I don't want any reasons in the reply, please, but I would be keeping with the order presented in the anime. Thanks for voting!

Romaniablack

Thank you for voting! It had a lot of requests! :)

Romaniablack

Love seeing Dororo on this!!

Isabelle

Will we end up with the Brandon Stark of anime? We shall see.

Alex Kornejo

I see this in every election, 'tactical voting' and I hate it, hahaha.

Alex Kornejo

Everyone adores the manga, but every adaptation has had a 'but'. I think that's what keeps it from being the runaway champ.

Alex Kornejo

The way this vote is going is surprising. Happy to see The Promised Neverland and Berserk in top spots. Also, if Berserk won, I'd like to bring up the idea of watching episode 1 last and starting at episode 2.

A

Yay rah! Thank you for voting!!

Romaniablack

Right! I try to be a glass half full person hahaha! But I would never want to dissuade someone from voting for a series they love just because it might not "win" -- I always take into account how the series do as a whole to determine if they go on future polls.

Romaniablack

showing some love for fate/zero and golden kamuy

Aimee

Oh sure, anything's possible. I just don't think it's a good idea to assume that it will win.

Ica

Thank you for voting! Yes, all of these shows I eventually want to see and they were the most nominated! :) I am really excited for whatever wins and to eventually see them all! :)

Romaniablack

We'll see! I definitely want to see eventually! :D Thanks for voting!

Romaniablack

We still have 6 days of voting, so you never know! :)

Romaniablack

Doesn't seem to be winning. It's third now and the gap is kinda big.

Ica

I haven’t seen most of these, love Berserk though. I’m pleasantly surprised Dororo made the voting list too, I really loved that show (the newer anime) and its criminally underrated. Even if they don’t win the poll, I really look forward to you watching these at some point.

NameLame

Golden Kamuy is behind but we can still get a comeback let's goooo

Kessler

It's a great show to watch someone react to. Great mix of seriousness and comedy

Kessler

Y'all can vote for as many as you want! Hahaha! This is going to be Game of Thrones cut-throat!

Romaniablack

NO 86 Must be stopped. I change my Dororo vote to Promise Never Land😆

Tyrone Tyrone

hinna hinna

killerqueen2000

I definitely want to get to it eventually! :) Thank you for voting!!

Romaniablack

I've been a big proponent of Golden Kamuy from the start. If you held my feet to the fire, it's not the best on the list, but it has many unique qualities to it that nothing else has. Just a fantastic underrated show, based on an even more fantastic manga.

Nathan Grenawalt

It's definitely going to stay on the polls because I've heard such good things! :) Thanks for voting!

Romaniablack

Pyscho pass is underrated in my opinion but sadly doesn't look like it'll win the poll. Hope it will some day.

Abby

I'm excited by whatever wins, but I've heard that series is great! Thank you for voting!

Romaniablack

Hahahaha, If you didn't vote for Golden Kamuy, I'd be disappointed!

Romaniablack

Berserk is cool but it will win so I'm not voting lol. Gooolldenn Kamuyyy'

killerqueen2000

Berserk should be an automatic vote by anyone xD

Thank you so much for voting!! :D :D

Romaniablack

Fate/Zero Berserk Promised Neverland

Tyrone Tyrone

Right?! They all look great, so I'm excited for whatever wins! Thanks for voting!

Romaniablack

Personally would be happy with any one of those honestly.

NamelessMonster

My brother was really excited to see it on here -- one day it'll win! :) Thank you for voting! I'm excited for whatever wins!

Romaniablack

The poll is super close so I'm excited!

Romaniablack

Damn, it sucks seeing Fate/Zero being the lowest rated show. It's my personal favorite anime, but I guess I'm the minority there lol. Anyway, I'm sure Romania will enjoy any show that's on this list.

Alex Johnson

I hope it will win even if 86 and Promised Neverland have the advantage of being recent! But it’s such a Gem !!

Be Happy

Thank you for voting! <3

Romaniablack

Berserk all the way 😁

Be Happy

Thank you for voting! I'm really excited to eventually get to that series and THANK YOU for the spoiler tag! :)

Romaniablack

It's definitely been a series that has intrigued me -- I hope to eventually get to it all! Thanks for voting!

Romaniablack

Thank you for voting! <3

Romaniablack

Oh gosh the Berserk anime and the manga please oh please

Sascha

Leaving a vote for Psycho-Pass as it would pair nicely as a replacement. If someone wants to try it and go in with zero info don't read ahead, mild theme spoilers only (though if you have seen it and think too spoiler-y, let me know). Specifically - what is peace and violence, a good dose of class warfare, a futuristic+technology dependant society and all that follows. Fun times.

Sunspots

Sooo many good choices here! I’m also glad Promised Neverland says (anime and manga) because while season 1 was beautifully done season 2 blew over so much content. I didn’t even read the manga but I could tell it was extremely rushed.

Destiney Marie